计算机断层扫描血管造影与多普勒超声对颈动脉狭窄测量与分级比较
回顾性分析100条颈动脉的DUS与28天内CTA图像,CTA分别用人工与半自动方法评估,按NASCET公式计算狭窄并分级。半自动法观察者间一致性良好(κ 0.786),以DUS为金标准检测≥50%狭窄的敏感度75%、特异度91%,均高于人工法(63%和86%)。结论认为CTA较DUS倾向于低估狭窄程度,半自动法重复性更好且与DUS一致性更高。
要点
- 半自动CTA法观察者间一致性良好(κ 0.786),人工法仅为中等(κ 0.407)。
- 以DUS为金标准,半自动法检测≥50%狭窄敏感度75%、特异度91%,高于人工法63%和86%。
- CTA与DUS一致性:半自动法中等(κ 0.453),人工法仅一般(κ 0.344),CTA倾向低估狭窄。
核心结论
- 与DUS相比,CTA倾向于低估颈动脉狭窄程度。
- 半自动CTA报告方法重复性更好,与DUS一致性更高。
- 作者认为这些发现对临床实践中用CTA测量颈动脉狭窄程度有实际意义。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性从多学科团队会议记录中识别100条颈动脉的图像,患者在本单位接受颈动脉DUS并在28天内接受颈动脉CTA。
- CTA由2名研究者分别使用人工法和半自动法评估。
- 两种方法均采用北美症状性颈动脉内膜切除试验(NASCET)公式计算狭窄度,并分级为轻度(0-49%)、中度(50-69%)或重度(70-99%)。
- 计算Cohen kappa以及检测≥50%狭窄的特异度和敏感度。
主要发现
- 人工法观察者间一致性为中等(κ 0.407,加权κ 0.517),半自动法为良好(κ 0.786,加权κ 0.842)。
- 以DUS为金标准,半自动法检测临床显著颈动脉狭窄(≥50%)的敏感度为75%、特异度为91%,人工法分别为63%和86%。
- DUS与半自动CTA报告方法的一致性为中等(κ 0.453,95%CI:0.320-0.586;加权κ 0.598,95%CI:0.486-0.710)。
- DUS与人工CTA报告方法的一致性仅为一般(κ 0.344,95%CI:0.209-0.478;加权κ 0.446,95%CI:0.315-0.577)。
关键数值与推荐
- 狭窄分级采用NASCET公式:轻度0-49%、中度50-69%、重度70-99%。
- 以DUS为金标准,半自动CTA法检测≥50%狭窄的敏感度75%、特异度91%;人工法敏感度63%、特异度86%。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出这些发现对临床实践中用CTA测量颈动脉狭窄程度有实际意义,未据此给出具体推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Doppler ultrasound (DUS) and computed tomography angiography (CTA) are the most commonly used imaging modalities for carotid disease. The aim of this study was to test the accuracy and reproducibility of CTA-derived measurements of carotid stenosis and compare them with those obtained by DUS. METHODS: Images of 100 carotid arteries of patients who underwent carotid DUS at our unit and CTA of the carotids within a 28-day period were identified retrospectively from multidisciplinary team meeting records. CTAs were assessed by 2 investigators, each using a manual and a semi-automated method. With both methods, the degree of stenosis was calculated using the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial equation and graded as mild (0-49%), moderate (50-69%), or severe (70-99%). Cohen's kappa and specificity and sensitivity for ≥50% stenosis were calculated. RESULTS: The interobserver agreement was moderate (κ 0.407, weighted-κ 0.517) for the manual method and good (κ 0.786, weighted-κ 0.842) for the semi-automated method. Using DUS as the gold standard, the semi-automated method had greater sensitivity (75%) and specificity (91%) in detecting clinically significant carotid artery stenosis (≥50%) than the manual one (63% and 86%, respectively). Agreement between DUS and the semi-automated method of CTA reporting was moderate (κ 0.453, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.320-0.586, weighted-κ 0.598, 95% CI: 0.486-0.710), whereas DUS and the manual method of CTA reporting had only fair agreement (κ 0.344, 95% CI: 0.209-0.478, weighted-κ 0.446, 95% CI: 0.315-0.577). CONCLUSIONS: CTA tends to underestimate the degree of stenosis when compared with DUS. The semi-automated method of CTA reporting has greater reproducibility and greater agreement with DUS. These findings have practical implications when CTA is used to measure the degree of carotid stenosis in clinical practice.
引用
- Birmpili P, Porter L, Shaikh U, et al. Comparison of Measurement and Grading of Carotid Stenosis with Computed Tomography Angiography and Doppler Ultrasound. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29522870. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2018.01.102
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。