美国和欧洲血管外科培训项目主任近期发表文献趋势
该研究检索2015年底美国和欧洲血管外科培训项目主任名单,统计其2010至2015年PubMed收录的血管相关文献。结果显示,美国项目主任年均发表2.80篇,欧洲为2.17篇(P=0.37);两地区前三分之一主任均贡献了超过三分之二的文献,欧洲集中度更高。
要点
- 美国项目主任年均发表2.80篇,欧洲项目主任年均2.17篇,差异无统计学显著(P=0.37)。
- 美国前三分之一主任贡献69%的文献和77%的《血管外科杂志》文献,欧洲分别为87%和98%。
- 美国4.4%主任无发表、18.4%无《血管外科杂志》发表,欧洲分别为30.0%和65.9%。
核心结论
- 在美国和欧洲,前三分之一的项目主任均贡献了超过三分之二的文献,欧洲的集中度更高,前三分之一贡献了近90%的总文献。
- 美国项目主任在腔内下肢静脉、开放下肢、教育、胸主动脉腔内修复、开放颈动脉和腔内静脉等主题发表更多,欧洲同行在血管医学、回复和非血管主题发表更多。
研究设计与样本
- 研究查询了2015年底美国血管外科项目主任协会(APDVS)和欧洲医学专家联盟(EUMS)的血管外科培训项目主任名单。
- 英国和德国项目未在EUMS网站列出主任姓名,因此未纳入欧洲数据。
主要发现
- 每位项目主任年均PubMed引用数为2.36篇。
- 欧洲273位项目主任年均发表2.17篇,美国114位项目主任年均发表2.80篇(P=0.37)。
- 《血管外科杂志》(JVS)文献占总文献24.0%,其中欧洲占12.7%、美国占45.0%。
- 美国前三分之一主任贡献69%的总文献和77%的JVS文献,欧洲前三分之一主任贡献87%的总文献和98%的JVS文献。
- 美国5位主任(4.4%)无发表、21位(18.4%)无JVS发表;欧洲82位主任(30.0%)无发表、180位(65.9%)无JVS发表。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We hypothesized that there may be significant differences between academic productivity of the vascular training programs in the United States (US) and Europe. In an effort to explore this theory, we reviewed the number of vascular publications listed in PubMed from 2010 to 2015 for US and European directors in vascular surgery. METHODS: The list of program directors from the Association of Program Directors in Vascular Surgery (APDVS) and the European Union of Medical Specialists (EUMS) were queried for the names of the directors of vascular surgical training programs at the end of 2015. PubMed listed 5,474 citations published from 2010 to 2015. Three thousand five hundred sixty-one were from Europe while 1,912 were from the US. UK and German programs did not list their directors' names in the EUMS website and were thus not included in the European data. RESULTS: The average number of citations in PubMed per program director was 2.36 per year. In Europe, each of the 273 program directors averaged 2.17 publications per year, whereas each of the 114 US program directors averaged 2.80 publications per year (P = 0.37). Journal of Vascular Surgery (JVS) publications made up 24.0% (12.7% in Europe and 45.0% in the US). In the US, the top third produced 69% of the publications and 77% of the JVS publications, whereas in Europe, the top third produced 87% of the publications and 98% of the JVS publications. In the US, 5 program directors (4.4%) had no publications and 21 (18.4%) had no JVS publications. In Europe, 82 program directors (30.0%) had no publications, whereas 180 (65.9%) had no JVS publications. Abstracts were categorized by topic for comparison. CONCLUSIONS: In both Europe and the US, the top third produced more than two-thirds of the publications, with the disparity being even more pronounced in Europe where the top third produced almost 90% of the total publications. Comparing the topics of the publications from Europe and the US, it was found that the US program directors published a great deal more on Endovenous Lower Extremity, Open Lower Extremity, Education, thoracic endovascular aortic repair, Open Carotid, and Endo Venous, whereas their European counterparts published more in the areas of Vascular Medicine, Replies, and Not Vascular.
引用
- Aurshina A, Hingorani A, Hingorani A, et al. Recent Trends in Publications of US and European Directors in Vascular Surgery. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29486231. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2017.11.070
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。