面对面互动与电子病历在采用2005年Caprini评分进行静脉血栓栓塞症风险分层中的比较
本研究比较了仅通过电子病历(EMR)回顾与面对面互动结合EMR回顾计算2005年Caprini评分的效果。面对面队列在Caprini 7-8分(29.5% vs 24.8%)和>8分(26.6% vs 10.5%)的比例更高,且更易被分入更高风险分层,并识别出更多个人深静脉血栓史、家族VTE史和多胎妊娠丢失史。结论认为单独使用EMR可能低估患者围术期VTE风险。
要点
- 面对面评估较单纯EMR回顾更易将患者分入更高Caprini风险分层。
- 面对面评估识别出更多个人深静脉血栓史、家族VTE史和多胎妊娠丢失史。
- 单独使用EMR可能遗漏关键VTE风险因素,导致围术期VTE风险估计偏低。
核心结论
- 单独使用电子病历可能无法准确估计患者层面的VTE风险(采用2005年Caprini评分)。
- EMR回顾可能遗漏个人或家族VTE史、妊娠丢失史等关键VTE风险因素,导致围术期VTE风险估计偏低。
- 医患互动对于准确的VTE风险分层的重要性怎么强调都不为过。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性建立队列1:仅通过EMR回顾(不与患者直接接触)计算2005年Caprini评分。
- 前瞻性建立队列2:通过面对面互动结合EMR回顾计算2005年Caprini评分。
- 纳入对象为在全身麻醉下手术、需要术后住院并开始依诺肝素预防的血浆与重建外科患者。
- EMR回顾队列536例独特患者,面对面队列207例独特患者,数据完整。
- 所有纳入患者的EMR回顾或面对面筛查均由作者亲自执行。
主要发现
- 面对面队列较EMR回顾队列有更高比例患者被分层为Caprini 7-8分(29.5% vs 24.8%)和Caprini >8分(26.6% vs 10.5%)。
- 面对面讨论组被分层至更高Caprini风险分层的可能性显著更高。
- 面对面讨论识别出个人深静脉血栓史增加2倍(12.6% vs 6.3%;P = .005)。
- 面对面讨论识别出VTE家族史增加3倍(16.9% vs 5.2%;P < .001)。
- 面对面讨论识别出多胎妊娠丢失史增加20倍(13.6% vs 0.6%;P < .001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 2005年Caprini评分用于量化围术期VTE风险。
- 面对面队列Caprini 7-8分比例为29.5%,EMR回顾队列为24.8%。
- 面对面队列Caprini >8分比例为26.6%,EMR回顾队列为10.5%。
- 个人深静脉血栓史:面对面队列12.6% vs EMR回顾队列6.3%(P = .005)。
- VTE家族史:面对面队列16.9% vs EMR回顾队列5.2%(P < .001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出,单独使用EMR可能提供不准确的患者层面VTE风险估计(采用2005年Caprini评分)。
- 原文结论指出,EMR回顾可能遗漏关键VTE风险因素,导致围术期VTE风险估计偏低。
- 原文结论强调医患互动对准确VTE风险分层的重要性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Perioperative venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk can be quantified with the 2005 Caprini score. The Caprini score has previously been validated by review of the electronic medical record (EMR) in >3000 plastic surgery patients. However, the accuracy of Caprini-based risk stratification using the EMR, as opposed to face-to-face contact with the patient, remains unknown. METHODS: Plastic and reconstructive surgery patients who had surgery under general anesthesia, required postoperative admission, and were started on enoxaparin prophylaxis were identified. The 2005 Caprini scores were calculated retrospectively using EMR review only (no direct contact with the patients) to establish cohort 1. The 2005 Caprini scores were calculated prospectively using face-to-face interaction with the patients, followed by EMR review, to establish cohort 2. For all included patients, EMR review or face-to-face screening was personally performed by the authors. We compared the proportions of patients with identified Caprini risk factors and the aggregate risk scores of patients between cohorts. RESULTS: Complete data were available for 536 unique patients in the EMR review cohort and 207 unique patients in the face-to-face cohort. Patients whose risk scores were calculated face to face had higher Caprini scores than those calculated by EMR review alone. The face-to-face cohort had a higher proportion of patients risk stratified as Caprini 7-8 (29.5% vs 24.8%) and Caprini >8 (26.6% vs 10.5%) compared with the EMR review cohort. Patients risk stratified by face-to-face discussion were significantly more likely to be stratified into a higher risk Caprini stratum. Face-to-face discussion identified a 2-fold increase in patients with personal history of deep venous thrombosis (12.6% vs 6.3%; P = .005), a 3-fold increase in patients with family history of VTE (16.9% vs 5.2%; P < .001), and a 20-fold increase in patients with personal history of multiple lost pregnancies (13.6% vs 0.6%; P < .001) compared with EMR review. Observed differences for family history of VTE and history of pregnancy loss persisted after propensity score analysis, created using component variables in the 2005 Caprini score plus gender; this supports the conclusion that observed differences were not due to site variation or case mix. CONCLUSIONS: When it is used in isolation, the EMR may provide inaccurate estimation of patient-level VTE risk using the 2005 Caprini score. This study demonstrates that EMR review may miss key VTE risk factors, such as personal or family history of VTE, history of pregnancy loss, and others; this omission results in lower estimates of perioperative VTE risk. The importance of provider-patient interaction for accurate VTE risk stratification cannot be overstated.
引用
- Pannucci CJ, Fleming KI. Comparison of face-to-face interaction and the electronic medical record for venous thromboembolism risk stratification using the 2005 Caprini score. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2018. PMID: 29452956. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2017.10.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。