现成开窗支架与开放手术治疗胸腹主动脉瘤时健康主动脉牺牲的比较
本研究比较了使用现成t-Branch支架(TB组)与开放手术(O组)治疗胸腹主动脉瘤时牺牲的健康主动脉长度及肋间动脉丢失数量。18对匹配患者中,TB组牺牲健康主动脉中位长度49 mm,O组14 mm(P < .001);肋间动脉丢失中位对数分别为4对和2对(P = .004)。分层后,仅在IV型TAAA中TB组牺牲健康主动脉更长(125 mm,P = .008),III型和IV型TAAA中肋间动脉丢失更多。
要点
- 现成开窗支架治疗TAAA比开放手术牺牲更多健康主动脉和肋间动脉。
- IV型TAAA中现成支架牺牲健康主动脉长度显著增加。
- III型和IV型TAAA中现成支架导致更多肋间动脉丢失。
核心结论
- 使用t-Branch装置相比开放手术与IV型TAAA中更多健康主动脉牺牲及近端健康主动脉来源的肋间动脉丢失增加相关。
- 常规使用该现成装置可能增加脊髓缺血风险,需进一步分析。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心匹配队列研究,纳入2010至2016年两中心连续18例TAAA患者使用现成t-Branch装置(TB组),与同期464例开放手术TAAA患者中按1:1匹配18例(O组)。
- 匹配依据为t-Branch可行性、左锁骨下动脉至动脉瘤起始距离及术前CTA评估的近端锚定区直径。
主要发现
- TB组牺牲健康主动脉中位长度49 mm(IQR 31-60 mm),O组14 mm(IQR 10-20 mm),P < .001。
- TB组丢失肋间动脉中位对数4对(IQR 3-4),O组2对(IQR 1-3),P = .004。
- 分层并减去近端密封所需25 mm后,仅IV型TAAA中TB组牺牲健康主动脉更长(125 mm,IQR 56-155 mm),P = .008。
- 肋间动脉对丢失仅在III型TAAA(P = .043)和IV型TAAA(P = .024)中更多。
- 匹配组间30天临床结局无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- TB组牺牲健康主动脉定义为密封区长度,O组为术后CTA评估的牺牲健康自体主动脉总长度。
- 真实不必要牺牲主动脉计算为减去近端密封所需最小覆盖25 mm。
- 匹配样本包括6例II型、7例III型、5例IV型TAAA。
临床怎么用
- 对于IV型TAAA,选择现成开窗支架时应权衡健康主动脉牺牲和肋间动脉丢失带来的脊髓缺血风险。
- 在III型和IV型TAAA中,需特别关注肋间动脉丢失数量,考虑脊髓保护策略。
局限性
- 样本量小(18对匹配),可能影响统计效能和泛化性。
- 仅短期30天临床结局比较,缺乏长期脊髓缺血等结局数据。
- 匹配基于特定解剖参数,可能存在残余混杂。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Off-the-shelf devices for branched endovascular aortic repair of thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm (TAAA) have been developed to overcome the manufacturing- and logistics-related delays characteristic of device customization. Nonetheless, the structural requirements of branched endovascular aortic repair, together with the need for additional thoracic components to suit different anatomies, might lead to a large sacrifice of healthy aorta. METHODS: We enrolled 18 consecutive TAAA patients treated between 2010 and 2016 in two centers employing the off-the-shelf t-Branch (Cook Medical, Bloomington, Ind) device (TB group). We matched these 18 patients one-to-one with another 18 patients of the 464 consecutive TAAAs treated in the same period by means of open repair (O group) in one of the two centers. The patients were matched on the basis of t-Branch feasibility, distance from the left subclavian artery to the beginning of the aneurysm, and diameter of proximal landing zone evaluated at preoperative computed tomography angiography. We compared the overall length of sacrificed healthy native aorta (the sealing zone in the TB group) in the two groups according to postoperative computed tomography angiography, and we investigated the number of intercostal arteries lost from that healthy aortic segment. We calculated also the real unnecessary sacrificed aorta by subtracting the compulsory minimum neck coverage requested to obtain the proximal sealing (25 mm). RESULTS: We matched one-to-one six extent II, seven extent III, and five extent IV TAAAs. Overall, the length of sacrificed healthy aorta was longer (P < .001) in the TB group (median length: TB group, 49 mm [interquartile range (IQR), 31-60 mm]; O group, 14 mm [IQR, 10-20 mm]), and consequently the number of intercostal arteries lost (median number of pairs lost: TB group, four [IQR, three-four]; O group, two [IQR, one-three]) was higher (P = .004). Stratifying the results according to TAAA extent and after having subtracted from the TB group the length of aorta required for proximal sealing (25 mm), the length of sacrificed healthy aorta was longer (P = .008) only in the extent IV TAAA, 125 mm (IQR, 56-155 mm). The number of intercostal artery pairs sacrificed was longer only in extent III TAAA (P = .043) and extent IV TAAA (P = .024). No significant 30-day clinical outcomes difference was observed between the matched groups. CONCLUSIONS: The use of the t-Branch device compared with open repair is associated with a greater sacrifice of healthy aorta in extent IV TAAA and with an increased loss of intercostal arteries arising from healthy aortic proximal neck. The theoretical possible increased risk of spinal cord ischemia secondary to the routine use of this off-the-shelf device should thus be analyzed further.
引用
- Bertoglio L, Cambiaghi T, Ferrer C, et al. Comparison of sacrificed healthy aorta during thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm repair using off-the-shelf endovascular branched devices and open surgery. J Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29100806. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2017.08.052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。