文献速递主动脉疾病

基于体模真值评估中心线分析软件的术前测量精度

How Precise Are Preinterventional Measurements Using Centerline Analysis Applications? Objective Ground Truth Evaluation Reveals Software-Specific Centerline Characteristics.
PubMed 文献 · J Endovasc Ther · 2017-06-07

研究利用3D打印主动脉瘤体模的CAD真值,评估3款临床批准和1款研究用中心线分析软件的测量精度。结果显示各软件中心线位置误差0.7±0.8至2.9±2.5 mm,直径误差可达8.0±11.0 mm,商业软件均低估总长度4.6±0.9至10.4±4.3 mm。中心线精度最高的软件直径和长度测量最准确。

要点

  • 所有软件中心线均与真值显著不同,位置误差达2.9±2.5 mm。
  • 一款软件直径误差超8.0±11.0 mm,缘于管腔尺寸不稳定扭曲。
  • 商业软件均低估中心线总长度,最大误差-14.6 mm。

核心结论

  • 一款临床批准软件无法提供可重复的中心线分析结果。
  • 另一款批准软件的长度误差可能影响支架选择与手术成功。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用CAD软件和3D打印机制作3个主动脉瘤体模。
  • 分析体模和3例患者的CTA,使用3款临床批准和1款研究软件。
  • 用专用评估平台将3D中心线坐标、管腔内径和长度与CAD真值对比。

主要发现

  • 3D中心线位置平均误差在测试软件间为0.7±0.8至2.9±2.5 mm。
  • 所有软件计算的中心线与真值显著不同。
  • 3款软件直径平均误差0.5±1.2至1.1±1.0 mm,另一款超8.0±11.0 mm。
  • 所有商业软件系统性低估中心线总长度-4.6±0.9至-10.4±4.3 mm,最大误差-14.6 mm。
  • 3D中心线精度最高的软件直径和长度测量最精确。

临床怎么用

  • 中心线分析软件的选择需考虑其精度差异,用户应知晓软件特性。
  • 长度误差可能影响支架移植物选择,需谨慎对待测量结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To evaluate different centerline analysis applications using objective ground truth from realistic aortic aneurysm phantoms with precisely defined geometry and centerlines to overcome the lack of unknown true dimensions in previously published in vivo validation studies. METHODS: Three aortic phantoms were created using computer-aided design (CAD) software and a 3-dimensional (3D) printer. Computed tomography angiograms (CTAs) of phantoms and 3 patients were analyzed with 3 clinically approved and 1 research software application. The 3D centerline coordinates, intraluminal diameters, and lengths were validated against CAD ground truth using a dedicated evaluation software platform. RESULTS: The 3D centerline position mean error ranged from 0.7±0.8 to 2.9±2.5 mm between tested applications. All applications calculated centerlines significantly different from ground truth. Diameter mean errors varied from 0.5±1.2 to 1.1±1.0 mm among 3 applications, but exceeded 8.0±11.0 mm with one application due to an unsteady distortion of luminal dimensions along the centerline. All tested commercially available software tools systematically underestimated centerline total lengths by -4.6±0.9 mm to -10.4±4.3 mm (maximum error -14.6 mm). Applications with the highest 3D centerline accuracy yielded the most precise diameter and length measurements. CONCLUSION: One clinically approved application did not provide reproducible centerline-based analysis results, while another approved application showed length errors that might influence stent-graft choice and procedure success. The variety and specific characteristics of endovascular aneurysm repair planning software tools require scientific evaluation and user awareness.

来源:J Endovasc Ther,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hoegen P, Wörz S, Müller-Eschner M, et al. How Precise Are Preinterventional Measurements Using Centerline Analysis Applications? Objective Ground Truth Evaluation Reveals Software-Specific Centerline Characteristics. J Endovasc Ther. 2017. PMID: 28587563. doi:10.1177/1526602817713737

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。