外科医生和医院经验对纽约州腹主动脉瘤修复结局的影响
基于纽约州2000至2011年18842例血管外科医生实施的腹主动脉瘤修复数据,采用分层logistic回归分析医生和医院经验对开放手术(OSR)和腔内修复(EVAR)结局的影响。结果显示,完整AAA开放手术结局受医生年手术量显著影响,而EVAR结局与医院低手术量相关;破裂AAA开放手术中低容量医院和医生结局更差,但EVAR未见显著关联。
要点
- 完整AAA开放手术:年手术量最低(1-4例)的医生院内死亡率高于高手术量(>11例)医生,调整OR 1.87(95%CI 1.1-3.17)。
- 完整AAA EVAR:低容量医院(<33例和34-81例)死亡率高于高容量医院,调整OR分别为2.6(1.3-5.3)和2.7(1.5-4.8)。
- 破裂AAA开放手术:低容量医院(<9例)死亡率高于高容量(>27例)医院,调整OR 1.56(1.02-2.39);低容量医生(<4例)主要并发症风险更高(OR 1.58,1.04-2.41)。
核心结论
- 完整AAA开放手术结局主要受医生年手术量影响,而EVAR结局与医院低手术量相关。
- 破裂AAA开放手术中低容量医院和医生结局更差,但EVAR未见医院或医生特征与不良结局显著相关。
- 医生手术量与医院手术量的交互作用复杂,因就诊急迫性和治疗方式而异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,使用纽约州 statewide 规划与研究合作系统数据,纳入2000至2011年由血管外科医生实施的AAA修复患者18842例。
- 通过链接纽约专业办公室和国家提供者识别数据库确定医生和医院特征,采用分层logistic回归模型分别分析完整和破裂AAA的EVAR与OSR结局。
- 医生从医学院毕业年数、医院和医生年手术量按三分位数分组,调整患者合并症后评估对结局的影响。
主要发现
- 完整AAA修复共17118例,其中26.2%接受OSR,73.8%接受EVAR;破裂AAA修复共1724例,其中63.9%接受OSR,36.1%接受EVAR。
- 完整AAA OSR后,最低容量医生(1-4例)较最高容量医生(>11例)院内死亡风险更高(调整OR 1.87,95%CI 1.1-3.17),主要并发症风险也更高(OR 1.23,95%CI 1-1.51)。
- 完整AAA EVAR后,低容量医院(<33例和34-81例)较高容量医院死亡风险更高,调整OR分别为2.6(95%CI 1.3-5.3)和2.7(95%CI 1.5-4.8)。
- 破裂AAA OSR后,低容量医院(<9例)较高容量医院(>27例)死亡风险更高(调整OR 1.56,95%CI 1.02-2.39),低容量医生(<4例)主要并发症风险更高(OR 1.58,95%CI 1.04-2.41)。
- 破裂AAA EVAR后,未发现医院或医生特征与较差结局显著相关。
临床怎么用
- 完整AAA开放手术应优先由年手术量较高的血管外科医生实施,以降低死亡和并发症风险。
- 完整AAA EVAR应优先在年手术量较高的医院开展,以改善患者结局。
- 破裂AAA开放手术应避免在低容量医院或由低容量医生实施,以降低死亡和并发症风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess the impact of the surgeon's and hospital's experience on the outcomes of open surgical repair (OSR) and endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) of intact and ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) in New York State. METHODS: New York Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System data were used to identify patients undergoing AAA repair from 2000 to 2011. Characteristics of the provider and hospital were determined by linkage to the New York Office of Professions and National Provider Identification databases. Distinct hierarchical logistic regression models for EVAR and OSR for intact and ruptured AAAs were created to adjust for the patient's comorbidities and to evaluate the impact of the surgeon's and hospital's experience on outcomes. The provider's years since medical school graduation as well as annual volume of the facility and provider are examined in tertiles. Adjusted odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals are presented. RESULTS: A total of 18,842 patients underwent AAA repair by a vascular surgeon. For intact AAAs (n = 17,118), 26.2% of patients underwent OSR and 73.8% underwent EVAR. For ruptured AAAs (n = 1724), 63.9% underwent OSR and 36.1% underwent EVAR. After intact AAA repair, OSR adjusted outcomes were significantly influenced by the surgeon's annual volume but not by the facility's volume or the surgeon's age. The lowest volume providers (1-4 OSRs) had higher in-hospital mortality rates than high-volume (>11 OSRs) surgeons (adjusted odds ratio, 1.87 [95% confidence interval, 1.1-3.17]). Low-volume providers also had higher odds of major complications (1.23 [1-1.51]). For patients with intact AAA undergoing EVAR, mortality was higher at low-volume facilities (2.6 [1.3-5.3] and 2.7 [1.5-4.8] for <33 EVARs and 34-81 EVARs, respectively). After OSR for ruptured AAA, treatment at a low-volume facility (<9 OSRs for ruptured AAA) was associated with greater mortality than at high-volume (>27 OSRs for ruptured AAA) centers (1.56 [1.02-2.39]), whereas low-volume physicians (<4 OSRs for ruptured AAA) had higher odds of major complications (1.58 [1.04-2.41]). In the case of EVAR for rupture, there were no characteristics of the hospital or surgeon significantly associated with poorer outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: For intact AAA, the surgeon's volume was an important factor for OSR outcomes, whereas low facility volume was associated with worse outcomes after EVAR. For ruptured AAA, low-volume surgeons and low-volume facilities had worse outcomes after OSR but not after EVAR. The interaction between the surgeon's volume and the hospital's volume is complex and varies on the basis of the acuity of presentation and treatment modality.
引用
- Meltzer AJ, Connolly PH, Schneider DB, et al. Impact of surgeon and hospital experience on outcomes of abdominal aortic aneurysm repair in New York State. J Vasc Surg. 2017. PMID: 28359718. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2016.12.115
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。