荷兰腹主动脉瘤手术调整后医院结局报告
荷兰外科动脉瘤审计(DSAA)强制纳入2013–2014年5898例腹主动脉瘤手术患者,采用V-POSSUM及重估V(p)-POSSUM进行风险调整比较医院结局。择期、症状性、破裂AAA死亡率分别为1.9%、7.5%、28.7%,V-POSSUM在择期组高估死亡率且区分度中等,重估模型风险调整仅对急性AAA的医院变异有影响。
要点
- 择期AAA死亡率EVAR后0.9%、开放术后5.0%;急性AAA分别为15.6%和27.4%。
- V-POSSUM在择期AAA多数风险组高估死亡率(p < .01),区分度中等(C-statistic .719)。
- 重估V(p)-POSSUM风险调整对择期AAA医院变异无影响,对急性AAA有影响。
核心结论
- DSAA中AAA手术死亡率与文献一致,但V-POSSUM对择期AAA医院比较无区分力。
研究设计与样本
- 全国强制性审计纳入2013年1月至2014年12月所有原发AAA手术患者,共5898例。
- 择期AAA 4579例,急性AAA 1319例(症状性371例,破裂948例)。
- 分析V-POSSUM与重估V(p)-POSSUM的校准与区分度,并以重估模型进行医院间风险调整。
主要发现
- 择期、症状性、破裂AAA死亡率分别为1.9%、7.5%、28.7%。
- 择期AAA死亡率EVAR后0.9%、开放术后5.0%;急性AAA分别为15.6%和27.4%。
- V-POSSUM在择期AAA多数风险组高估死亡率(p < .01),区分度中等(C-statistic .719),重估V(p)-POSSUM区分度差(C-statistic .665)。
- V-POSSUM在急性AAA高危组高估、低危组低估(p < .01),区分度中等(.713),重估V(p)-POSSUM区分度差(.688)。
- 重估V(p)-POSSUM风险调整对择期AAA医院变异无影响,对急性AAA有影响。
关键数值与推荐
- 择期AAA死亡率EVAR后0.9%、开放术后5.0%。
- 急性AAA死亡率EVAR后15.6%、开放术后27.4%。
- V-POSSUM在择期AAA的C-statistic为.719,重估V(p)-POSSUM为.665。
- V-POSSUM在急性AAA的C-statistic为.713,重估V(p)-POSSUM为.688。
临床怎么用
- 择期AAA医院比较不宜单独依赖V-POSSUM,因其高估死亡率且区分度有限。
- 急性AAA进行医院结局比较时应使用重估V(p)-POSSUM进行病例组合风险调整。
- EVAR比例差异与医院手术量无关,调整风险后未发现医院量与治疗或结局相关。
局限性
- 仅纳入荷兰2013–2014年数据,结论外推需谨慎。
- V-POSSUM及重估模型区分度中等至差,可能影响医院比较可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE/BACKGROUND: The Dutch Surgical Aneurysm Audit (DSAA) is mandatory for all patients with primary abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) in the Netherlands. The aims are to present the observed outcomes of AAA surgery against the predicted outcomes by means of V-POSSUM (Vascular-Physiological and Operative Severity Score for the enUmeration of Mortality and Morbidity). Adjusted mortality was calculated by the original and re-estimated V(physiology)-POSSUM for hospital comparisons. METHODS: All patients operated on from January 2013 to December 2014 were included for analysis. Calibration and discrimination of V-POSSUM and V(p)-POSSUM was analysed. Mortality was benchmarked by means of the original V(p)-POSSUM formula and risk-adjusted by the re-estimated V(p)-POSSUM on the DSAA. RESULTS: In total, 5898 patients were included for analysis: 4579 with elective AAA (EAAA) and 1319 with acute abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAAA), acute symptomatic (SAAA; n = 371) or ruptured (RAAA; n = 948). The percentage of endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) varied between hospitals but showed no relation to hospital volume (EAAA: p = .12; AAAA: p = .07). EAAA, SAAA, and RAAA mortality was, respectively, 1.9%, 7.5%, and 28.7%. Elective mortality was 0.9% after EVAR and 5.0% after open surgical repair versus 15.6% and 27.4%, respectively, after AAAA. V-POSSUM overestimated mortality in most EAAA risk groups (p < .01). The discriminative ability of V-POSSUM in EAAA was moderate (C-statistic: .719) and poor for V(p)-POSSUM (C-statistic: .665). V-POSSUM in AAAA repair overestimated in high risk groups, and underestimated in low risk groups (p < .01). The discriminative ability in AAAA of V-POSSUM was moderate (.713) and of V(p)-POSSUM poor (.688). Risk adjustment by the re-estimated V(p)-POSSUM did not have any effect on hospital variation in EAAA but did in AAAA. CONCLUSION: Mortality in the DSAA was in line with the literature but is not discriminative for hospital comparisons in EAAA. Adjusting for V(p)-POSSUM, revealed no association between hospital volume and treatment or outcome. Risk adjustment for case mix by V(p)-POSSUM in patients with AAAA has been shown to be important.
引用
- Lijftogt N, Vahl AC, Wilschut ED, et al. Adjusted Hospital Outcomes of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Surgery Reported in the Dutch Surgical Aneurysm Audit. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2017. PMID: 28256396. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2016.12.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。