高收入国家血管诊断影像检查与操作过度使用的系统评价与荟萃分析
该系统评价与荟萃分析检索2010年至2025年文献,纳入14项研究共16,706,904例患者,评估高收入国家血管诊断影像检查与操作的过度使用情况。结果显示颈动脉超声和静脉双功能超声的过度使用合并累积发生率分别为19%和46%,肾动脉成形术和腔静脉滤器置入分别为92%和72%,过度使用与医疗费用增加相关,但证据确定性多为低至中等。
要点
- 颈动脉超声过度使用合并累积发生率为19%(95%CI 10-30%),证据确定性中等。
- 静脉双功能超声过度使用累积发生率为46%(95%CI 43-48%),证据确定性中等。
- 肾动脉成形术和腔静脉滤器置入过度使用发生率分别为92%和72%,证据确定性低。
核心结论
- 高收入国家血管诊断影像检查与操作的过度使用可能较为常见,并与医疗费用增加相关。
- 由于纳入研究存在重要局限性,上述发现需在制定减少过度使用的措施前进一步确认。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与荟萃分析,方案注册号CRD42021257490,检索Medline、Embase和EBM Reviews(2010年1月1日至2025年5月14日)的英文研究。
- 纳入14项研究,共16,706,904例患者,涉及2种血管诊断影像检查和8种操作。
- 三名研究者独立筛选文献、提取数据并评估偏倚风险,采用随机效应模型合并数据,使用GRADE评估证据确定性。
主要发现
- 颈动脉超声过度使用合并累积发生率为19%(95%CI 10-30%),证据确定性中等。
- 静脉双功能超声过度使用累积发生率为46%(95%CI 43-48%),证据确定性中等。
- 肾动脉血管成形术过度使用合并累积发生率为92%(95%CI 85-97%),证据确定性低。
- 下腔静脉滤器置入过度使用合并累积发生率为72%(95%CI 0-100%),证据确定性低。
- 颈动脉双功能超声过度使用的校正危险因素包括年龄增长和较高社区收入中位数四分位;间歇性跛行血管内干预过度使用的校正危险因素包括曾吸烟和终末期肾病。
关键数值与推荐
- 颈动脉超声过度使用合并累积发生率19%(95%CI 10-30%),中等确定性。
- 静脉双功能超声过度使用累积发生率46%(95%CI 43-48%),中等确定性。
- 肾动脉血管成形术过度使用合并累积发生率92%(95%CI 85-97%),低确定性。
- 下腔静脉滤器置入过度使用合并累积发生率72%(95%CI 0-100%),低确定性。
临床怎么用
- 临床应关注颈动脉超声和静脉双功能超声在无症状或低症状患者中的过度使用风险。
- 对肾动脉血管成形术和下腔静脉滤器置入应严格把握适应证,避免过度使用。
- 年龄增长、较高社区收入、吸烟史和终末期肾病可能是过度使用的危险因素,需在决策时予以考虑。
局限性
- 纳入研究存在重要局限性,导致部分结局证据确定性低。
- 下腔静脉滤器置入过度使用发生率的95%CI极宽(0-100%),提示估计不精确。
- 仅纳入英文研究,可能存在语言偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We sought to synthesize and evaluate evidence for the overuse of vascular diagnostic imaging tests and procedures in high-income countries as they may be overused in asymptomatic, minimally symptomatic, and/or high-risk patients with limited life expectancy. METHODS: After protocol registration (CRD42021257490), we searched Medline, Embase, and Evidence-Based Medicine Reviews (January 1, 2010-May 14, 2025) for English language studies that reported the incidence/prevalence of overuse of vascular diagnostic imaging tests and/or procedures in high-income countries; adjusted predictors of overuse; or adjusted associations between overuse and outcomes. Three investigators independently reviewed titles/abstracts and full-texts, extracted data, and assessed risk of bias. Data were pooled using random-effects models. Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation was used to assess estimate certainty. RESULTS: Among 11,748 citations, we included 14 studies (n = 16,706,904 patients) that examined two unique vascular diagnostic imaging tests and eight unique procedures. The most frequently overused vascular imaging tests included carotid (pooled cumulative incidence = 19%; 95% confidence interval [CI] = 10-30%; moderate certainty) and venous duplex (cumulative incidence = 46%; 95% CI = 43-48%; moderate certainty). The most frequently overused vascular procedures included renal artery angioplasty (pooled cumulative incidence = 92%; 95% CI = 85-97%; low certainty) and inferior vena cava filter placement (pooled cumulative incidence = 72%; 95% CI = 0-100%; low certainty). Adjusted risk factors for carotid duplex overuse included increasing age and higher median neighborhood income quartile. Adjusted risk factors for overuse of endovascular intervention for claudication included ever smoking and end-stage renal disease. Overuse was associated with increased health-care costs in all studies examining this outcome. CONCLUSION: Overuse of vascular diagnostic imaging tests and procedures may be common in high-income countries and associated with increased healthcare costs. However, because the included studies had important limitations, our findings that should be confirmed before methods to reduce the above overuse are developed.
引用
- Kirkham AM, Sypes EE, Xu CC, et al. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Evidence for Overuse of Vascular Diagnostic Imaging Tests and Procedures in High-Income Countries. Ann Vasc Surg. 2026. PMID: 42567310. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2026.07.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。