血管疾病所致下肢大截肢网络患者教育材料可读性、质量与内容评估
该研究对血管疾病所致下肢大截肢的网络患者教育材料进行描述性审计,检索8个术语并纳入58个网站。结果显示材料平均可读性超过推荐六年级水平,JAMA基准均分1.54/4,DISCERN均分46.8/80为「一般」质量,关键临床内容覆盖低。
要点
- 网络截肢教育材料可读性普遍高于推荐六年级水平,患者难以理解
- JAMA基准均分1.54/4,DISCERN均分46.8/80,整体质量一般
- 关键临床内容覆盖不足,替代手术仅26%、手术风险仅33%报告
核心结论
- 尽管下肢大截肢负担重,网络患者教育材料可读性和质量常较低且缺乏关键内容。
- 亟需开发高质量、易获取的材料以支持教育和共享决策。
研究设计与样本
- 对血管疾病所致下肢大截肢的网络患者教育材料进行描述性审计。
- 使用Google Chrome无痕模式检索8个搜索词,每个词审查前30条结果,共筛查240个网站,纳入58个。
- 可读性用5种验证工具评估,质量用JAMA和DISCERN标准评估,并分析关键临床内容。
主要发现
- 平均可读性评分均超过推荐六年级水平:Flesch-Kincaid 10.47、Gunning Fog 12.55、SMOG 12.95、Coleman-Liau 10.83、Automated Readability Index 9.86。
- JAMA基准平均分1.54/4,59%报告时效性、36%披露、33%报告作者、26%注明出处。
- DISCERN平均分46.8/80,质量为「一般」。
- 关键临床内容覆盖低:26%报告替代手术、33%报告手术风险、41%手术描述、50%生活质量、67%假肢/助行器、74%术后护理、74%适应证。
- DISCERN与内容评分中度相关(r=0.5),Flesch-Kincaid与SMOG高度相关(r=1.0),质量与可读性评分不相关。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应谨慎直接推荐网络截肢教育材料,因其可读性和质量常不足。
- 共享决策时需补充关键内容如替代手术、手术风险、适应证等。
- 可参考DISCERN和JAMA标准筛选可靠来源,但需注意可靠来源仍可能难懂。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess the readability, quality, transparency, and clinical content of online patient education materials related to major lower extremity amputation (LEA) due to vascular disease. METHODS: We conducted a descriptive audit of online patient education materials on major LEA due to vascular disease. Using Google Chrome Incognito mode, we searched eight search terms ("leg amputation," "below-knee amputation," "above-knee amputation," "amputation for poor circulation," "amputation for peripheral artery disease," "vascular surgery leg amputation," "diabetic leg amputation," "foot amputation surgery") and reviewed the first 30 results per term to identify relevant websites and patient education. Readability was assessed using five validated tools (Flesch-Kincaid, Gunning Fog, SMOG, Coleman-Liau, Automated Readability index). Quality was assessed using JAMA and DISCERN criteria. Content was analyzed for key clinical elements. RESULTS: Of 240 websites screened, 58 were included. Mean readability scores exceeded the recommended sixth-grade level: Flesch-Kincaid (10.47), Gunning Fog (12.55), SMOG (12.95), Coleman Liau (10.83), Automated readability index (9.86). The average JAMA Benchmark score was 1.54/4, with 59% reporting currency, 36% disclosure, 33% reporting authorship, and 26% attribution. DISCERN scores averaged 46.8/80 ("fair" quality). Content coverage of key clinical concepts was low: 26% reported alternative procedures, 33% reported surgical risks, 41% operation description, 50% quality of life, 67% prosthetics/mobility aids, 74% postoperative care, and 74% indications. DISCERN and content scores were moderately correlated (r = 0.5), Flesch-Kincaid and SMOG were highly correlated (r = 1.0). Quality and readability scores were uncorrelated, suggesting reliable sources may remain hard to understand. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the burden of major LEA, online patient education resources often have low readability and quality and lack critical content. There is an urgent need to develop high-quality, accessible materials to support education and shared decision-making.
引用
- Laor B, Elrakhawy K, Blanchette V, et al. Assessing online patient education materials for major lower extremity amputation. J Vasc Surg. 2026. PMID: 41866095. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2026.03.432
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。