血管外科住院医师与进修医师在主动脉腔内手术的毕业熟练度高于开放手术
该研究基于2018至2023年多机构操作评估数据库,分析54名学员和50名带教对579例主动脉手术的评分。结果显示,毕业时学员在腔内主动脉手术中达到自主和胜任的比例高于开放手术,带教与学员自评均显示开放手术获得高熟练度评分的可能性更低。
要点
- 毕业时腔内主动脉手术的自主评分比例高于开放手术。
- 带教评估显示开放手术获得自主和胜任评分的 odds ratio 为0.25(95%CI 0.11-0.53)。
- 学员自评在开放手术中的熟练度也低于腔内手术(OR 0.39,95%CI 0.19-0.77)。
核心结论
- 血管外科培训学员毕业时在腔内主动脉手术中比开放主动脉手术更容易达到自主和胜任水平,且与培训模式无关。
- 学员在开放主动脉手术中自评的熟练度高于带教评估。
研究设计与样本
- 多机构回顾性研究,使用Society for Improving Medical Professional Learning应用数据库2018至2023年数据。
- 纳入19个项目的54名学员和50名带教,共完成579例评估(腔内394例,开放185例)。
- 评估对象为PGY4-5住院医师和所有进修医师的主动脉手术操作表现与自主性。
主要发现
- 肾下腹主动脉瘤修复中,毕业年住院医师和进修医师在60.9%的腔内手术和21.1%的开放手术中被评为自主。
- 肾下腹主动脉瘤修复中,毕业年学员在50%的腔内手术和22.2%的开放手术中被评为可独立执业。
- 所有主动脉手术中,毕业年学员在58.0%的腔内手术和41%的开放手术中被评为自主。
- 所有主动脉手术中,毕业年学员在49.0%的腔内手术和37.0%的开放手术中被评为胜任。
- 带教评估中,毕业时开放手术获得自主和胜任评分的OR为0.25(95%CI 0.11-0.53),学员自评OR为0.39(95%CI 0.19-0.77)。
临床怎么用
- 培训项目需关注开放主动脉手术的操作经验积累,以缩小与腔内手术的熟练度差距。
- 可利用操作评估数据识别开放主动脉手术培训中的薄弱环节并设计针对性模拟或带教方案。
局限性
- 样本来自特定评估数据库,仅代表参与机构的学员和带教。
- 评估基于主观评分,可能存在评估者偏倚。
- 研究未报告病例复杂度、术者角色等可能影响熟练度的因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Practice patterns regarding the surgical management of aortic pathologies have evolved over time, with a shift in care toward endovascular interventions and increasingly complex endovascular techniques. This raises concern for inadequate experience with aortic surgery, both open and endovascular, in vascular surgery training. Although numerous studies have explored trends in the volume of aortic cases completed during training, none have examined graduating proficiency in aortic surgery. We sought to examine the competence and autonomy of graduating vascular surgery trainees performing aortic operations using a multi-institutional sample of trainees. METHODS: Operative performance and autonomy ratings of post-graduate year 4-5 residents and all fellows performing aortic interventions from the Society for Improving Medical Professional Learning application database were collected for vascular surgery participating institutions from 2018 to 2023. 'Supervision only' and 'passive help' ratings were coded as 'autonomous,' whereas 'exceptional performance' and 'practice ready' were coded as 'competent.' Descriptive statistics were calculated for open and endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair. Mixed effects logistic regressions were conducted to estimate the predictive association between procedure type and graduating trainee proficiency for all aortic procedures. RESULTS: A total of 54 trainees and 50 faculty from 19 programs completed 579 assessments (n = 394 endovascular; n = 185 open). For infrarenal aortic aneurysm repair, in the final year of training residents and fellows were assessed as 'autonomous' for 60.9% of endovascular and 21.1% of open procedures and were assessed as competent for independent practice in 50% of endovascular and 22.2% of open procedures. Regarding all aortic procedures, trainees were assessed as autonomous for 58.0% of endovascular and 41% of open procedures, and competent for 49.0% of endovascular and 37.0% of open procedures in their final year. There were no differences when comparing graduating integrated residents and fellows. However, trainees were less likely to achieve autonomous and competent ratings for open, as compared with endovascular, cases by graduation on both faculty (odds ratio, 0.25; 95% confidence interval, 0.11-0.53) and trainee self-assessment (odds ratio, 0.39; 95% confidence interval, 0.19-0.77). CONCLUSIONS: Vascular surgery trainees are more likely to achieve proficient levels of autonomy and competence in endovascular aortic cases by graduation, regardless of training paradigm. Trainees are also more likely to perceive themselves as achieving higher levels of proficiency than their faculty assessors rate them in open aortic procedures. These findings highlight the importance of developing innovative solutions to enhance aortic surgical skills in training.
引用
- Buchanan E, Sun T, Droz N, et al. Vascular surgery residents and fellows graduate at higher levels of proficiency in endovascular as compared to open aortic operations. J Vasc Surg. 2025. PMID: 41205839. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2025.10.045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。