指南与共识主动脉疾病

获得性结局指标在区分腹主动脉开放修复术中心围术期死亡率上优于推荐手术量指南

Earned outcome metrics outperform recommended open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair volume guidelines in discriminating perioperative mortality among centers.
指南 / 共识 · J Vasc Surg · 2025-08-05

该研究基于Vascular Quality Initiative数据库2016至2019年择期肾下腹主动脉开放修复术(OAR)数据,比较获得性结局指标(DAR<0)与SVS年手术量≥10例阈值对中心质量的区分能力。结果显示DAR<0阈值识别出更多高质量中心(70% vs 31%),且对粗死亡率和风险调整死亡率的区分度均优于手术量阈值。

要点

  • DAR<0阈值识别70%中心为高质量,而手术量阈值仅31%。
  • DAR<0中心粗死亡率3.0% vs 11.4%,绝对差8.4%大于手术量阈值2.5%。
  • 不一致分类时,后续死亡率与初始DAR分类一致,即使未达手术量阈值。

核心结论

  • 获得性结局阈值在识别高质量OAR中心方面优于SVS手术量阈值,主要因检测到低手术量但结局优于平均的中心。
  • 应同时考虑质量和手术量指标进行绩效基准比较。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,使用Vascular Quality Initiative数据库2016至2019年择期肾下OAR数据,共3701例患者,106个中心。
  • 采用获得性结局方法计算风险调整手术质量,以低手术量「替代水平」中心的预测死亡数为基准计算超额死亡(DAR=观察死亡-预测死亡)。
  • 中心按手术量(≥10 OAR/年)和DAR(<0)分类,评估与粗死亡率和风险调整死亡率的关系,并分析2016至2019年分类对2020至2023年OAR死亡率的预测能力。

主要发现

  • 按SVS手术量阈值,33个中心(31%)年OAR≥10例;按获得性结局阈值,74个中心(70%)DAR<0。
  • 仅56%中心被两种标准一致分类;DAR<0中心中44个(42%)年OAR<10例。
  • DAR<0中心粗死亡率3.0% vs 11.4%(P < .001),手术量≥10例/年中心3.4% vs 6.0%(P < .001),DAR<0绝对死亡率差异更大(8.4% vs 2.5%)。
  • 风险调整死亡率:DAR<0中心3.1% vs 10.7%,手术量≥10例/年中心3.5% vs 5.6%。
  • 不一致分类的中心,后续4年(2020-2023)死亡率与初始DAR分类一致,即使未达手术量阈值。

关键数值与推荐

  • SVS推荐OAR年手术量≥10例作为高质量指标。
  • 获得性结局阈值定义为DAR<0(观察死亡数少于低手术量替代水平中心的预测死亡数)。

临床怎么用

  • 在OAR质量基准比较中,应使用同时反映质量和手术量的指标,而非仅用手术量阈值。
  • 低手术量但结局优于平均的中心可被DAR指标识别为高质量中心。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) has endorsed a minimum open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair (OAR) volume of ≥10/year as an indicator of high-quality care. However, this threshold excludes most United States centers, despite an acceptable average mortality rate nationwide. In sports metrics, "replacement level" is used as a baseline for comparison, representing below-average quality of a readily available replacement player. We hypothesized that a novel earned outcome metric, reported relative to the quality of a "replacement level" center, would outperform the SVS volume threshold while still adequately representing high OAR quality overall. METHODS: Elective infrarenal OAR from the Vascular Quality Initiative database were studied, from 2016 to 2019. Risk-adjusted surgical quality was estimated using earned outcomes methods to analyze in-hospital/30-day death: deaths above replacement (DAR) were calculated as the number of observed deaths relative to predicted deaths at low-volume "replacement level" centers (observed - expected). Centers were categorized according to: (1) case volume (≥10 OAR/year); and (2) quality (DAR <0). The association of volume and DAR categorizations with crude and risk-adjusted mortality were assessed. Concordance of center categorization using the two thresholds and the ability of 2016 to 2019 center characterization to forecast OAR mortality for 2020 to 2023 were estimated. RESULTS: In total, 3701 patients underwent OAR at 106 centers during the study period. Using the SVS volume threshold, 33 centers (31%) performed ≥10 OAR/year. Using the earned outcomes threshold, 74 centers (70%) had DAR <0. Slightly over one-half of centers were classified similarly using both criteria (56%). However, using the DAR threshold, 44 centers with <10 OAR/year (42%) had DAR <0. Although reduced crude mortality rates were seen among patients undergoing OAR at centers with DAR <0 (3.0% vs 11.4%; P < .001) and at centers with ≥10 OAR/year (3.4% vs 6.0%; P < .001), the absolute mortality difference was higher using DAR <0 (8.4%) compared with ≥10 OAR/year (2.5%). Differences in risk-adjusted mortality also demonstrated better discrimination of mortality at centers with DAR <0 (3.1% vs 10.7%) compared with OAR ≥10/year (3.5% vs 5.6%). Among centers classified concordantly using both thresholds, mortality rates were similar in the subsequent 4 years (2020-2023). However, for centers classified discordantly, subsequent mortality rates were consistent with initial DAR characterization, even when they did not meet the volume threshold. CONCLUSIONS: Measuring OAR quality is critically important to patients, payers, and providers. An earned outcomes threshold in OAR outperforms the SVS volume threshold for identifying high-quality centers, largely due to detection of low-volume centers with above-average outcomes. Metrics that account for both quality and volume should be utilized when benchmarking performance.

来源:J Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jones DW, Simons JP, Markert EX, et al. Earned outcome metrics outperform recommended open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair volume guidelines in discriminating perioperative mortality among centers. J Vasc Surg. 2025. PMID: 40769464. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2025.07.047

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。