单中心安全网医院中BEST-CLI排除患者更易发生大截肢
在单中心城市安全网医院2014年8月至2019年10月因慢性威胁肢体缺血行血运重建的159例患者中,仅17例(11%)符合BEST-CLI入组标准,142例(89%)不符合。不符合者5年大截肢率显著更高(P=.02),大再干预率更低(P=.01),全因死亡率无差异(P=.63)。
要点
- 159例血运重建患者中仅11%(17例)符合BEST-CLI入组标准,89%(142例)不符合。
- 排除主因为患者依从性(46%)、开放旁路过高风险(25%)及机构英语能力政策(18%)。
- 不符合者5年大截肢率显著更高(P=.02),大再干预率更低(P=.01),全因死亡率无差异(P=.63)。
核心结论
- 城市安全网医院中多数CLTI患者不符合BEST-CLI入组标准。
- 非医学因素在超过半数患者的排除中起作用,作者强调需纳入这些因素以更好评估该院理想管理策略。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,纳入2014年8月至2019年10月因CLTI行血运重建的全部患者。
- 评估试验及中心特异性排除标准,按入组标准将患者分为不符合组与符合组,比较人口学、合并症、术前用药、既往干预及结局。
主要发现
- 159例血运重建患者中17例(11%)符合BEST-CLI入组标准,142例(89%)不符合。
- 排除原因:患者感知的试验方案依从能力46%(包括计划在他处随访或无法遵守随访预约),开放旁路过高风险25%(36例),机构政策排除英语能力有限者18%(26例)。
- 79例(56%)符合单一排除标准,52例(37%)符合2条,11例(8%)符合3条。
- 与符合BEST-CLI患者相比,不符合者5年大截肢率显著更高(P=.02),大再干预率更低(P=.01),全因死亡率无差异(P=.63)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: BEST-CLI (Best Endovascular Versus Best Surgical Therapy for Patients with Critical Limb Ischemia) is the largest randomized clinical trial for chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI). However, as with any randomized clinical trial, generalizability is a concern. Our aims were to determine and quantify reasons for trial exclusion in all patients who underwent revascularization for CLTI at a single urban safety net hospital and to compare outcomes after revascularization of patients who were not eligible for BEST-CLI with patients who were eligible. METHODS: All patients who underwent revascularization for CLTI from August 2014 to October 2019 at a single center were identified. Trial- and site-specific exclusion criteria were assessed, and patients were grouped by enrollment criteria. Demographics, comorbidities, preoperative medications, prior interventions, and outcomes were then compared between noneligible and eligible patient groups. Categorical variables were compared using Pearson's χ2 tests. Normally distributed variables were compared via Student t tests and non-normally distributed variables were assessed using Mann-Whitney U tests. Kaplan-Meier curves were constructed for time-to-event analysis of outcomes. RESULTS: Of the 159 patients who underwent revascularization, 17 (11%) met BEST-CLI enrollment criteria and 142 (89%) were ineligible. The primary reasons for exclusion were perceived patient ability to adhere to trial protocol (46%), which included patients who had planned follow-up elsewhere or were unable to adhere to follow-up appointments. A total of 36 patients (25%) were deemed at excessive risk for open bypass; 26 patients (18%) were limited by an institutional policy excluding patients with limited English proficiency. Seventy-nine patients (56%) met a single criterion for exclusion, 52 patients (37%) met 2 criteria, and 11 patients (8%) met 3 criteria. Compared with patients eligible for BEST-CLI, noneligible patients had a significantly greater 5-year major amputation rate (P = .02) and lower major reintervention rate (P = .01), but no difference in all-cause mortality (P = .63). CONCLUSIONS: Most patients presenting with CLTI at an urban safety net hospital failed to meet the BEST-CLI enrollment criteria. Nonmedical factors played a role in the exclusion of more than one-half of these patients, which underscores the importance of accommodating these factors to better assess ideal management strategies in this hospital setting.
引用
- Schwarz SM, Warren AS, Hemingway JF, et al. Patients excluded from BEST-CLI were more likely to undergo a major amputation at a single urban safety net hospital. J Vasc Surg. 2025. PMID: 40250779. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2025.04.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。