破裂腹主动脉瘤修复风险分层中风险评分性能的比较评估
本研究利用NSQIP(2011-2018)和VQI(2003-2021)登记库中所有开放或腔内修复破裂腹主动脉瘤的患者,比较7种风险评分的区分度和校准度。NSQIP中GAS区分度最高(AUC 0.687),VQI中DAS最高(AUC 0.688);Medicare风险评分校准最佳(ICI 0.007和0.003)。风险评分可辅助但不能替代临床决策。
要点
- 在NSQIP中GAS区分度最高(AUC 0.687),在VQI中DAS最高(AUC 0.688)。
- Medicare风险评分校准最佳,ICI在NSQIP为0.007、在VQI为0.003。
- mHRS和HI兼顾区分度与校准度,且简单易算,适合急诊临床。
核心结论
- 风险评分是有价值的工具,可辅助但不能替代破裂腹主动脉瘤患者的临床决策。
- GAS和DAS区分度更优,最适合区分低风险和高风险患者。
- Medicare风险评分提供最准确的风险预测。
- mHRS和HI兼顾足够的区分度和校准度,且简单易算,适合急诊临床环境。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入NSQIP(2011-2018)和VQI(2003-2021)中所有接受开放或腔内修复破裂腹主动脉瘤的患者。
- 计算7种风险评分:荷兰动脉瘤评分(DAS)、格拉斯哥动脉瘤评分(GAS)、改良Harborview风险评分(mHRS)、Hardman指数(HI)、Leiden评分、Medicare风险评分和新英格兰血管外科组(VSGNE)风险评分。
- 对所有患者(开放和腔内联合)用受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线评估区分度,AUC值在数据集内用DeLong检验比较。
- 用图形校准曲线评估校准度,并通过整合校准指数(ICI)量化。
主要发现
- 共纳入2134例NSQIP患者和6458例VQI患者。
- 在NSQIP中,GAS区分度最高(AUC 0.687;与所有其他评分比较P < .010)。
- 在VQI中,DAS表现最佳(AUC 0.688;与所有其他评分比较P < .050)。
- Medicare风险评分校准最佳,ICI在NSQIP为0.007、在VQI为0.003。
- DAS倾向于低估风险,而所有其他评分均高估死亡风险。
临床怎么用
- 风险评分可辅助但不能替代破裂腹主动脉瘤患者的临床决策。
- GAS和DAS区分度更优,最适合区分低风险和高风险患者。
- Medicare风险评分提供最准确的风险预测。
- mHRS和HI兼顾足够的区分度和校准度,且简单易算,适合急诊临床环境。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Several risk scores are available to stratify the mortality risk of ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm (rAAA) repair. This study compared the performance of seven risk scores found in the literature using the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) and Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI) registries. METHODS: All patients who underwent open or endovascular rAAA repair in NSQIP (2011 - 2018) and VQI (2003 - 2021) were included. The following risk scores were calculated: Dutch Aneurysm Score (DAS); Glasgow Aneurysm Score (GAS); modified Harborview Risk Score (mHRS); Hardman index (HI); Leiden score; Medicare risk score; and Vascular Surgery Group of New England (VSGNE) risk score. Discrimination was assessed for all patients (combined open and endovascular) using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves, with area under the curve (AUC) values compared within datasets using the DeLong test. Calibration was evaluated using graphical calibration curves and was quantified via the integrated calibration index (ICI). RESULTS: A total of 2 134 NSQIP patients and 6 458 VQI patients were included. In NSQIP, the GAS had the highest discrimination ability (AUC 0.687; p < .010 vs. all); while in VQI, the DAS performed best (AUC 0.688; p < .050 vs. all). The Medicare risk score exhibited the best calibration with an ICI of 0.007 in NSQIP and 0.003 in VQI. The DAS tended to underestimate risk, while all other scores overestimated death. CONCLUSION: Risk scores serve as valuable tools to augment, but not replace, clinical decision making in patients with rAAA. The GAS and DAS demonstrated superior discrimination, rendering them best for distinguishing between low and high risk patients. Meanwhile, the Medicare risk score offers the most accurate risk prediction. The mHRS and HI offered a balance of adequate discrimination and calibration while remaining simple and easily calculable, making them practical for urgent clinical settings.
引用
- Warren AS, Hemingway JF, Quiroga E, et al. Comparative Assessment of Risk Score Performance in Ruptured Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Repair Risk Stratification. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2025. PMID: 40188860. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2025.04.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。