八种破裂性腹主动脉瘤死亡预测模型的外部验证显示预测准确性有限
本研究在2010至2020年多中心区域医疗系统315例破裂性腹主动脉瘤修复术中,外部验证八种30天死亡预测模型的区分度、校准度和临床效用。仅三种模型区分度尚可(AUC≥0.70),GAS的AUC最高为0.74(95%CI 0.68-0.79),所有模型校准度差至中等,作者认为现有模型应谨慎用于临床实践。
要点
- 八种破裂性腹主动脉瘤死亡预测模型中仅三种区分度尚可(AUC≥0.70),GAS的AUC最高为0.74(95%CI 0.68-0.79)。
- 所有模型校准度差至中等,现有模型对破裂性腹主动脉瘤死亡相关重要生理特征捕捉不足。
- 使用VSS时,非预期存活者较预期死亡者术前休克比例更低(72% vs 96%,p=0.050)、凝血功能障碍更轻(INR中位数1.2 vs 1.8,p=0.015)。
核心结论
- 现有破裂性腹主动脉瘤风险预测模型仅显示尚可的区分度和差至中等的校准度,提示其未充分捕捉与破裂性腹主动脉瘤死亡相关的重要生理特征,应谨慎应用于临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- 对2010至2020年多中心整合区域医疗系统(含大型中央四级转诊机构)内破裂性腹主动脉瘤修复术进行回顾性审查,共纳入315例修复术(平均年龄73.6±10.0岁,男性72.1%,开放修复49.8%),30天死亡率为32.1%。
- 使用八种模型预测术后30天死亡:更新版格拉斯哥动脉瘤评分(GAS)、新英格兰血管研究组破裂性腹主动脉瘤风险评分、Harborview术前破裂性腹主动脉瘤风险评分、改良Harborview风险评分、温哥华评分系统(VSS)、人工神经网络评分、荷兰动脉瘤评分和爱丁堡破裂动脉瘤评分。
- 通过受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)、Hosmer-Lemeshow χ2检验、Brier评分和决策曲线分析评估模型的区分度、校准度和临床效用。
- 比较各计算器的非预期存活者(预测30天死亡>80%但仍存活)与预期死亡者的比例,并使用非预期存活频率最高的模型对两组进行比较。
主要发现
- 三种模型区分度尚可(AUC≥0.70),其中GAS的AUC最高为0.74(95%置信区间0.68-0.79)。
- 所有模型校准度差至中等。
- 使用VSS时,非预期存活者(n=25)较预期死亡者(n=23)术前休克比例更低(72% vs 96%;p=0.050),凝血功能障碍显著更轻(国际标准化比值中位数1.2[四分位距1.1,1.5]vs 1.8[1.3,2.2];p=0.015)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为现有风险预测模型应谨慎应用于临床实践。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Over a dozen ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm (rAAA) mortality risk prediction models currently exist; however, lack of external validation limits their applicability. This study aimed to evaluate the accuracy of eight common rAAA mortality risk prediction models in a large, contemporary, external validation cohort. METHODS: A retrospective review of rAAA repairs at a multicentre integrated regional healthcare system with large central quaternary referral facility (2010 - 2020) was performed. Eight models were used to predict 30 day post-operative death, including the Updated Glasgow Aneurysm Score (GAS), Vascular Study Group of New England rAAA Risk Score, Harborview Pre-operative rAAA Risk Score, Modified Harborview Risk Score, Vancouver Scoring System (VSS), Artificial Neural Network Score, Dutch Aneurysm Score, and Edinburgh Ruptured Aneurysm Score. The models were assessed for discrimination, calibration, and clinical utility using receiver operating characteristic curves (area under the curve [AUC]), Hosmer-Lemeshow χ2 test, Brier scores, and decision curve analysis. The proportion of unexpected survivors (survival despite > 80% predicted 30 day death) to expected deaths was compared across calculators, and both groups were compared using the model demonstrating the highest unexpected survival frequency. RESULTS: Three hundred and fifteen rAAA repairs were included (mean age 73.6 ± 10.0 years; 72.1% male; 49.8% open repair) with a 30 day mortality rate of 32.1%. Three models had fair discrimination (AUC ≥ 0.70), with GAS having the highest AUC (0.74, 95% confidence interval 0.68 - 0.79). All models demonstrated poor to adequate calibration. Using VSS, unexpected survivors (n = 25) had less pre-operative shock (72% vs. 96%; p = .050) and statistically significantly less coagulopathy (median international normalised ratio 1.2 [interquartile range 1.1, 1.5] vs. 1.8 [1.3, 2.2]; p = .015) compared with expected deaths (n = 23). CONCLUSION: Current rAAA risk prediction models demonstrated only fair discrimination and poor to adequate calibration. These findings suggest that existing risk prediction models have not sufficiently captured important physiological characteristics associated with rAAA death and should be applied cautiously to clinical practice.
引用
- Li SR, Mazroua MS, Reitz KM, et al. External Validation of Eight Ruptured Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Mortality Prediction Models Demonstrates Limited Predictive Accuracy. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2025. PMID: 39978535. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2025.02.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。