计算机断层扫描在下肢静脉淋巴水肿诊断中的作用
本研究纳入35例(50条肢体)慢性静脉疾病患者,比较CT皮肤增厚、蜂窝状皮下间质水肿及肌间隔水肿与ISL分期和淋巴闪烁显像的关系。以ISL分期为参照,皮肤增厚的敏感度95%、特异度75%、准确率92%;以淋巴闪烁显像为参照,蜂窝状改变与肌间隔水肿敏感度均为100%、特异度均为0%、准确率均为88%。作者认为CT可作为下肢静脉淋巴水肿的筛查工具,蜂窝状改变是最佳CT指标。
要点
- 以ISL分期为参照,CT皮肤增厚的敏感度95%、特异度75%、准确率92%。
- 以淋巴闪烁显像为参照,蜂窝状改变与肌间隔水肿的敏感度均为100%、特异度均为0%、准确率均为88%。
- 淋巴闪烁显像与ISL分期的相关性差(r=0.18;P=.20)。
核心结论
- CT扫描可作为下肢静脉淋巴水肿的筛查工具。
- 静脉淋巴水肿的CT诊断取决于所用参照标准,即ISL分期还是淋巴闪烁显像。
- 以ISL分期为参照时皮肤增厚的敏感度、特异度和准确率最高;以淋巴闪烁显像为参照时蜂窝状改变或肌间隔水肿敏感度和准确率高但特异度低。
- 结合评估者间一致性,蜂窝状改变被认为是诊断静脉淋巴水肿的最佳CT指标。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为比较CT特征与ISL分期及淋巴闪烁显像的诊断研究,研究对象为接受下肢CT扫描和淋巴闪烁显像的慢性静脉疾病患者。
- 共纳入35例患者(50条肢体),其中女性28例,左侧22条肢体。
- 采用三名评估者对CT进行评估,评估者不知晓患者的ISL分期和淋巴闪烁显像结果;以三名评估者中两人的一致结果作为分析值。
- 每个肢体每个变量的最终评分取大腿、小腿、踝部三个层面中最严重的数值。
- CT评估内容包括皮肤增厚(有/无)、皮下间质水肿(蜂窝状,评分为0-2分)和肌间隔水肿(评分为0-2分),评估部位为大腿(髌骨顶点上方20 cm)、小腿(髌骨顶点下方10 cm)和踝部(外踝上方5 cm)。
主要发现
- 淋巴闪烁显像与ISL分期的相关性差(r=0.18;P=.20)。
- 以ISL分期为参照,CT诊断静脉淋巴水肿的敏感度/特异度/准确率分别为:皮肤增厚95%/75%/92%,蜂窝状改变100%/0%/84%,肌间隔水肿100%/0%/84%,任一项CT变量100%/0%/84%,任意两项CT变量100%/0%/84%,全部三项CT变量93%/63%/88%。
- 以淋巴闪烁显像为参照,CT诊断静脉淋巴水肿的敏感度/特异度/准确率分别为:皮肤增厚82%/0%/72%,蜂窝状改变100%/0%/88%,肌间隔水肿100%/0%/88%,任一项CT变量100%/0%/88%,任意两项CT变量100%/0%/88%,全部三项CT变量82%/0%/72%。
- CT变量中,大腿、小腿与踝部的皮肤增厚无显著差异(P=.5);肌间隔水肿从大腿到小腿加重(P<.0001),小腿与踝部之间无差异(P=.3)。
- 蜂窝状改变的严重程度在踝部最重、大腿最轻,三个部位之间均有显著差异(P=.008)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为CT扫描可作为下肢静脉淋巴水肿的筛查工具,但诊断取决于所用参照标准是ISL分期还是淋巴闪烁显像。
- 作者在结合评估者间一致性后认为,蜂窝状改变是诊断静脉淋巴水肿的最佳CT指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Phlebolymphedema, the most common cause of secondary lymphedema in Western societies, seldom gets the attention it deserves. Diagnosis is often missed and when evaluated is through lymphoscintigraphy (LSG) which is cumbersome. This study aims to assess the role of computed tomography (CT) scanning in the diagnosis of phlebolymphedema of the lower extremities by comparing CT characteristics with the International Society of Lymphology (ISL) grading system and LSG. METHODS: Patients presenting with chronic venous disease who underwent a CT scan and LSG of the lower extremities (diagnostic testing) formed the study cohort. Three assessors blinded to the patients' ISL stage and LSG results evaluated the CT for skin thickening (present/absent), subcutaneous interstitial edema (honeycombing; graded 0-2), and muscle compartment (MC) edema (graded 0-2), in the thigh (20 cm above apex of patella), leg (10 cm below apex of patella), and ankle (5 cm above lateral malleolus). Agreement from two of the three raters determined the value used for analysis. Additionally, the final score used for each variable for each limb was determined by taking the most severe value of the three levels. The three CT variables were then compared independently and together with ISL stage and LSG to determine their diagnostic potential for phlebolymphedema. Also assessed was the severity of each CT variable across each limb in addition to the evaluation of the extent of their inter-rater agreement. RESULTS: Of the 35 patients (50 limbs), 28 were female, with left laterality noted in 22 limbs. Clinical, Etiological, Anatomical, and Pathophysiological clinical class for the cohort included C0 to 2, 4 limbs (8%); C3, 13 limbs (26%); C4, 17 limbs (34%); C5, 9 limbs (18%); and C6, 7 limbs (14%). Thirty-one limbs underwent stenting for chronic iliofemoral venous obstruction after having failed conservative therapy. Of the 50 limbs, 8 (16%) were ISL stage 0, 10 (20%) ISL stage 1, 2 (4%) ISL stage 2, and 30 (60%) ISL stage 3. With LSG, 6 (12%) had a normal study, 21 (42%) mild disease, 0 (0%) moderate disease, and 23 (46%) severe disease. Correlation between LSG and ISL stage was poor (r = 0.18; P = .20). With ISL stage as a reference, the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of CT in diagnosing phlebolymphedema were as follows: skin thickening (95%/75%/92%), honeycombing (100%/0%/84%), MC edema (100%/0%/84%), any one CT variable (100%/0%/84%), any two CT variables (100%/0%/84%), and all three CT variables (93%/63%/88%). With LSG as a reference, the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of CT in diagnosing phlebolymphedema were as follows: skin thickening (82%/0%/72%), honeycombing (100%/0%/88%), MC edema (100%/0%/88%), any one CT variable (100%/0%/88%), any two CT variables (100%/0%/88%), and all three CT variables (82%/0%/72%). For CT variables, there was no significant difference between skin thickening in the thigh vs calf vs ankle (P = .5). MC edema, however, worsened from thigh to calf (P < .0001) without a difference between the calf and the ankle (P = .3). The severity of honeycombing was worst in the ankle and least in the thigh, with a significant difference between all 3 sites (P = .008). The inter-rater agreement (kappa statistic) varied from 0.2 for skin thickening to 0.7 for honeycombing. CONCLUSIONS: CT scanning can be used as a screening tool for phlebolymphedema in the lower extremities. However, such a diagnosis depends on the reference standard used, ISL stage vs lymphoscintigram. Although skin thickness offered the greatest sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy when the ISL stage was used, honeycombing or MC edema had high sensitivity and accuracy but low specificity when LSG was used as the reference. Factoring in inter-rater agreement as well, honeycombing was noted to be the best CT variable to diagnose phlebolymphedema.
引用
- Thaggard D, Powell T, Jayaraj A, et al. Computed tomography scanning in the diagnosis of lower extremity phlebolymphedema. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2025. PMID: 39756516. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2024.102166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。