内镜静脉获取与腹股沟下旁路术后更差但正在改善的结局相关
基于血管质量倡议腹股沟下旁路模块2011至2023年数据,将7929例开放静脉获取(OVH)与2643例内镜静脉获取(EVH)患者按3:1倾向性评分匹配,比较远期结局。EVH术后手术部位感染率更低(1.8% vs 2.9%,P=0.003),但1年随访时OVH组一期通畅率(71% vs 65%)、一期辅助通畅率(86% vs 81%)和二期通畅率(90% vs 85%)均更高,截肢率(6% vs 9%)、再干预率(20% vs 25%)和主要不良肢体事件率(25% vs 30%)均更低。EVH的一期通畅率从2011年的59%升至2020年的70%(P=0.042),与OVH的差距随时间缩小。
要点
- EVH组手术部位感染率显著低于OVH组(1.8% vs 2.9%,P=0.003)。
- 1年随访OVH组一期通畅率显著高于EVH组(71% vs 65%,P<0.001)。
- EVH组一期通畅率从2011年59%升至2020年70%(P=0.042),与OVH差距缩小。
核心结论
- EVH与更低的术后伤口并发症率相关,但OVH在研究期间提供了更优的通畅、再干预和保肢远期结局。
- EVH的一期通畅率多年来有所改善,显著缩小了两种获取方法在该结局上的差距。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,数据来自血管质量倡议腹股沟下旁路模块2011至2023年。
- 纳入因外周动脉疾病行股动脉起源的腹股沟下旁路且使用单段大隐静脉的患者,排除原位旁路。
- 按静脉获取技术分为OVH组和EVH组,采用3:1最近邻倾向性评分匹配(无放回)平衡协变量。
- 匹配后OVH组7929例,EVH组2643例。
- 使用Kaplan-Meier和Cox回归分析估计远期事件率并评估关联。
主要发现
- EVH组手术部位感染率显著低于OVH组(1.8% vs 2.9%,P=0.003)。
- 移植物感染(P=0.12)、心肌梗死(P=0.16)、卒中(P=0.13)和重返手术室(P=0.14)在两组间相似。
- 1年随访时,OVH组一期通畅率显著高于EVH组(71% vs 65%,P<0.001),一期辅助通畅率(86% vs 81%,P<0.001)和二期通畅率(90% vs 85%,P<0.001)也显著更高。
- 1年随访时,OVH组截肢率(6% vs 9%,P<0.001)、再干预率(20% vs 25%,P<0.001)和主要不良肢体事件率(25% vs 30%,P<0.001)均显著低于EVH组。
- EVH旁路的一期通畅率从2011年的59%升至2020年的70%(P=0.042);2011至2012年OVH组一期通畅率显著高于EVH组(72% vs 59%,P=0.006),但该差异随时间减小,在最近研究的2019至2020年区间无显著差异(73% vs 70%,P=0.214)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The impact of great saphenous vein harvest technique on infrainguinal bypass outcomes remains a matter of debate, with no robust evidence favoring a specific technique over the other. This study aims to compare the outcomes of open vein harvest (OVH) with endoscopic vein harvest (EVH) in patients undergoing infrainguinal bypass surgery. METHODS: Patients who underwent an infrainguinal bypass from a femoral origin using a single-segment great saphenous vein between 2011 and 2023 were identified in the Vascular Quality Initiative infrainguinal bypass module. Only patients undergoing a bypass for peripheral artery disease were included, and those undergoing in-situ bypass were excluded. Patients were then classified according to their vein harvest technique into OVH and EVH groups. Three-to-one nearest-neighbor propensity score matching without replacement was performed to ensure balance of covariates between the two comparison groups. Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression analysis were used to estimate long-term event rates and evaluate the association of vein harvest technique with the primary outcomes of primary patency, primary-assisted patency, secondary patency, reintervention, amputation, and major adverse limb events, defined as the composite outcome of amputation and/or reintervention. RESULTS: A total of 7929 patients who underwent OVH were matched to 2643 patients who underwent EVH. All baseline characteristics, demographics, and operative details were balanced after propensity score matching. EVH had a significantly lower rate of surgical site infections (1.8% vs 2.9%; P = .003), whereas other perioperative outcomes, including graft infection (P = .12), myocardial infarction (P = .16), stroke (P = .13), and return to operating room (P = .14) were similar between the two groups. At 1-year follow-up, OVH patients had a significantly higher primary patency (71% vs 65%; P < .001), primary-assisted patency (86% vs 81%; P < .001), and secondary patency (90% vs 85%; P < .001), and significantly lower rates of amputation (6% vs 9%; P < .001), reintervention (20% vs 25%; P < .001), and major adverse limb events (25% vs 30%; P < .001) compared with EVH patients. The primary patency of EVH bypasses significantly increased from 59% to 70% between 2011 and 2020 (P = .042). Although OVH had a significantly higher primary patency compared with EVH in 2011 to 2012 (72% vs 59%; P = .006), this difference diminished over time, with no significant difference observed in the most recent interval (2019-2020) studied (73% vs 70%; P = .214). CONCLUSIONS: Although EVH is associated with a lower postoperative wound complication rate, OVH conferred superior long-term outcomes of patency, reintervention, and limb salvage over the study period. Nonetheless, EVH has demonstrated improvements in primary patency over the years, significantly narrowing the gap in this outcome between the two harvest methods.
引用
- Chahrour M, Chamseddine H, Shepard A, et al. Endoscopic vein harvest is associated with worse but improving outcomes in infrainguinal bypass. J Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 39743157. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2024.12.126
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。