膝下动脉造影的观察者间与观察者内变异性
研究将15例膝下动脉造影图像在3个不同场合呈现给7名评估者(3名血管外科住院医师和4名血管外科医师),评估血管识别、直径、狭窄程度、治疗决策及球囊/支架选择。观察者间一致性在估计血管直径、狭窄程度和治疗决策上为中等,球囊直径一致性差;观察者内一致性在血管直径和狭窄程度上为中至良好,球囊直径差至中等。结论认为需要更客观的诊断方法来评估膝下病变的直径和形态。
要点
- 观察者间一致性:估计血管直径ICC为0.62,狭窄程度为0.72,是否治疗为0.53,球囊直径为0.21。
- 观察者内一致性:估计血管直径ICC范围0.62-0.80,狭窄程度0.76-0.87,治疗决策0.76-0.87,球囊直径0.07-0.57。
- 数字减影血管造影(DSA)评估膝下动脉病变存在观察者间和观察者内变异性,球囊尺寸选择一致性差至中等。
核心结论
- 本研究显示估计血管直径的观察者间一致性为中等,观察者内一致性为中至良好;治疗决策的观察者内一致性为中至优秀,观察者间一致性为中等;球囊尺寸选择的观察者间和观察者内一致性均为差至中等;需要更客观的诊断方法来评估膝下病变的直径和形态。
研究设计与样本
- 共15例造影图像及相应患者特征,在3个不同场合呈现给7名评估者(3名血管外科住院医师和4名血管外科医师)。
- 评估者回答一系列问题,包括血管识别、估计直径、估计狭窄程度、治疗决策以及将使用的球囊或支架类型(包括直径)。
- 主要结局为估计动脉直径、估计狭窄程度和治疗决策的观察者间与观察者内变异性;次要结局为血管识别和病变处理方式。
- 观察者间和观察者内一致性使用组内相关系数(ICC)和Hubert's kappa计算,解释为差(<0.50)、中等(0.50-0.75)、良好(0.75-0.90)和优秀(>0.90)。
主要发现
- 观察者间一致性:估计血管直径ICC为0.62(中等),狭窄程度ICC为0.72(中等),是否治疗狭窄ICC为0.53(中等),球囊直径ICC为0.21(差)。
- 观察者内一致性:估计血管直径ICC范围为0.62-0.80(中至良好),估计狭窄程度ICC范围为0.76-0.87(良好)。
- 观察者内一致性:治疗决策ICC范围为0.76-0.87(中至优秀),球囊直径ICC范围为0.07-0.57(差至中等)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The gold standard imaging modality for assessing crural arterial disease is digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Using DSA, the operator can estimate the diameter and degree of stenosis and determine the diameter of the balloon. Since these measures are estimates, it allows for interobserver and intraobserver variability. This study aimed to determine the interobserver and intraobserver variability in the assessment of crural angiography. METHOD: A total of 15 angiographies with corresponding patient characteristics were presented to 7 assessors, including 3 vascular surgery residents and 4 vascular surgeons on 3 separate occasions. A series of questions was presented, including vessel identification, estimated diameter, estimated degree of stenosis, treatment decision, and which type of balloon or stent would be used including diameter. The primary outcomes were interobserver and intraobserver variability in the estimated diameter of the artery, the estimated degree of stenosis and treatment decision. Secondary outcomes were vessel identification and how the lesion would be treated. Interobserver and intraobserver agreement was calculated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and Hubert's kappa, interpreted as poor (<.50), moderate (.50-.75), good (.75-.90), and excellent (>.90) agreement. RESULTS: Interobserver agreement was moderate (.62) for estimated vessel diameter, moderate (.72) for degree of stenosis and moderate (.53) for whether the physician would treat the stenosis. The interobserver agreement was poor regarding balloon diameter (.21). The intraobserver agreement ranged from moderate to good (.62-.80) for estimated vessel diameter and was good for estimated degree of stenosis (.76-.87). The intraobserver agreement regarding treatment decision ranged from moderate to excellent (.76-.87) and ranged from poor to moderate (.07-.57) for balloon diameter. CONCLUSION: This study shows moderate interobserver agreement and moderate to good intraobserver agreement regarding estimated vessel diameter. In addition, moderate to excellent intraobserver agreement and moderate interobserver agreement regarding treatment decision was found. This study also showed poor to moderate agreement, both interobserver and intraobserver, regarding balloon sizing. There is a need for more objective diagnostic modalities to assess the diameter and morphology of crural lesions.Clinical ImpactDigital subtraction angiography (DSA) is currently the golden standard imaging modality guiding below-the-knee percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA). Due to the lack of objective measurements with DSA, physicians estimate vessel diameter and percentage of stenosis. The present study shows that there is inter- and intraobserver variability in the assessment of DSA, indicating there is a need for objective imaging modalities guiding below-the-knee PTA.
引用
- van Wely C, Oosterveld RJ, Zonnebeld N, et al. Interobserver and Intraobserver Variability in Crural Angiography. J Endovasc Ther. 2025. PMID: 39851195. doi:10.1177/15266028251315029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。