术中定位系统联合增强现实技术改善无血管腔内经验操作者的腔内导航学习曲线
本研究在三维打印腹主动脉瘤模型上比较荧光透视、IOPS平板显示及IOPS增强现实头戴设备引导下覆膜支架门控插管任务;无血管腔内经验组使用增强现实较荧光透视缩短插管时间(4.3±4.4 vs 7.1±4.9分钟,P=0.04),技术成功率分别为92%与77%(P=0.59)。
要点
- 无血管腔内经验者使用增强现实较荧光透视缩短门控插管时间(4.3±4.4 vs 7.1±4.9分钟,P=0.04)。
- 无血管腔内经验者技术成功率荧光透视77%、IOPS平板显示与增强现实均为92%(P=0.59)。
- 培训中外科医生三种方式插管时间无显著差异,但IOPS平板显示或增强现实有缩短趋势。
核心结论
- 对于无任何血管腔内操作经验的参与者,增强现实较荧光透视可缩短门控插管时间,提示增强现实可能对早期从业者有益并减轻学习曲线。
- 随着操作者成为专家,其适应不同血管腔内方式的能力增加,学习曲线消失。
研究设计与样本
- 在混合手术室(GE Allia IGS 7)中,将GORE Excluder AAA分叉主动脉覆膜支架部署于连接7000 MDX流量泵的三维打印腹主动脉瘤模型内,复现生理条件。
- 共26名参与者分为三组:第1组无血管腔内经验(n=13)、第2组培训中外科医生(n=12)、第3组一名专家外科医生。
- 每名参与者按随机分配顺序分别使用荧光透视、IOPS平板显示(IOPS-FS)及研究性IOPS增强现实头戴设备(IOPS-AR)完成插管任务,均使用同一传感导丝和可操纵6Fr导管。
- 主要终点为插管时间和技术成功,技术成功定义为在每次试验最长15分钟截止时间内导管沿导丝进入主动脉覆膜支架主体内。
主要发现
- 第1组平均插管时间IOPS-AR较荧光透视缩短(4.3±4.4 vs 7.1±4.9分钟,P=0.04),IOPS-FS与荧光透视无统计学差异(6.3±4.5 vs 7.1±4.9分钟,P=0.63)。
- 第1组技术成功率荧光透视77%、IOPS-FS与IOPS-AR均为92%(P=0.59)。
- 第2组三种方式插管时间无显著差异,但IOPS-FS或IOPS-AR较荧光透视有缩短趋势(平均时间分别为2.5±0.9、4.4±4.0、5.2±4.5分钟)。
- 第2组技术成功率荧光透视92%、IOPS-FS与IOPS-AR均为100%(P>0.99)。
- 专家外科医生每种方式重复插管任务四次,技术成功率100%,各影像方式间平均插管时间无差异(P=0.89)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,增强现实可缩短无血管腔内操作经验者的门控插管时间,可能对早期从业者有益并减轻学习曲线。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the completion of gate cannulation task performed by participants of varying experience using fluoroscopy, the Intraoperative Positioning System (IOPS)-a United States Food and Drug Administration-cleared endovascular navigation system that has been developed to reduce dependence on fluoroscopy-or an investigational augmented reality electromagnetic navigation technology based on IOPS. METHODS: The task consisted in the cannulation of the gate of a GORE Excluder AAA endoprosthesis bifurcated aortic stent graft (W.L. GORE & Associates) deployed into a three-dimensional printed abdominal aortic aneurysm model connected to a 7000 MDX flow pump (Sarns Inc/3M) reproducing physiological conditions. The procedure was performed in a hybrid operating room (GE Allia IGS 7). Each participant performed the cannulation task with fluoroscopy, standard IOPS guidance with flat screen display (IOPS-FS), and the investigational IOPS with augmented reality headset (IOPS-AR), in a randomly assigned order. All participants used the same sensorized guidewire and steerable 6Fr catheter during their three cannulation tasks. A total of 26 participants were classified in three groups of experience: Group 1 (endovascular naïve; n = 13), Group 2 (surgeon in training; n = 12) and Group 3 (one expert surgeon). Primary endpoints included cannulation time and technical success, which was defined as the advancement of the catheter over the guidewire within the main body of the aortic stent graft within a maximum 15-minute cutoff time for each trial. RESULTS: In group 1, the mean cannulation time was shorter using IOPS-AR vs fluoroscopy (4.3 ± 4.4 vs 7.1 ± 4.9 minutes; P = .04), but not statistically different when comparing IOPS-FS and fluoroscopy (6.3 ± 4.5 vs 7.1 ± 4.9 minutes; P = .63). In group 1, technical success was 77% with fluoroscopy and 92% with both IOPS-FS and IOPS-AR (P = .59). In group 2, although there was no significant difference between cannulation time among the three different endovascular approaches, there was a trend towards shorter cannulation times with IOPS-FS or IOPS-AR as compared with fluoroscopy (mean time of 2.5 ± 0.9, 4.4 ± 4.0, and 5.2 ± 4.5 minutes, respectively). In group 2, technical success was 92% with fluoroscopy and 100% with both IOPS-FS and IOPS-AR (P > .99). The expert vascular surgeon repeated the cannulation task four times for each endovascular approach, with 100% technical success and no difference in mean cannulation time between the imaging modalities (P = .89). CONCLUSIONS: Augmented reality allows for reducing the gate cannulation time as compared with fluoroscopy in participants with no previous exposure to any endovascular procedure. This suggests that augmented reality can be beneficial for individuals early in their career and can mitigate the learning curve. As individuals become experts, their ability to adapt to different endovascular modalities increases, eliminating the learning curve altogether.
引用
- Wong J, Mesnard T, Vacirca A, et al. Intraoperative position system guided with augmented reality improves the learning curve of endovascular navigation in endovascular-naïve operators. J Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 39522573. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2024.10.074
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。