关于血管腔内主髂动脉瘤修复中髂总动脉密封区的跨大西洋德尔菲共识(DECIDE研究)
该研究采用德尔菲共识法,组织77名国际血管外科医生对血管腔内动脉瘤修复(EVAR)中髂动脉锚定区的术前评估、支架选择与随访达成共识。核心推荐将不良髂动脉锚定区定义为短(<15 mm)、宽(>24 mm)或锥形(锚定区内径差>10%),并强调术后CT血管造影随访评估远端密封长度。
要点
- 不良髂动脉锚定区定义为短(<15 mm)、宽(>24 mm)或锥形(锚定区内径差>10%)。
- 推荐术后使用CT血管造影随访,评估远端密封长度并明确CT随访时机。
- 对密封逐渐丧失但无IB型内漏的处理策略尚存争议,需进一步探索。
核心结论
- 该国际专家德尔菲共识建立了一套以共识为基础的建议,聚焦EVAR中不良髂动脉锚定区的定义与管理。
- 核心推荐将不良髂动脉锚定区定义为短(<15 mm)、宽(>24 mm)或锥形(锚定区内径差>10%)。
- 尽管多个关键方面达成共识,研究也揭示持续存在的争议与考量需进一步探索,包括如何处理无IB型内漏的密封逐渐丧失。
研究设计与样本
- 采用德尔菲共识法,纳入在EVAR方面有经验的国际血管外科医生组成专家组。
- 第一轮为开放式与多项选择题以探索当前实践,后续轮次通过4点Likert量表精炼陈述。
- 共识定义为>75%同意或不同意,分析包括稳定性检验与共识强度。
主要发现
- 研究纳入77名国际血管外科医生,反映不同地理区域与医院隶属关系。
- 在EVAR关键术前规划要素上达成共识,包括不良髂动脉锚定区的明确定义。
- 强调CT血管造影用于术后随访影像的重要性,包括评估远端密封长度,并推荐CT随访扫描的具体时机及对髂动脉密封逐渐丧失的干预策略。
关键数值与推荐
- 不良髂动脉锚定区定义为短(<15 mm)、宽(>24 mm)或锥形(锚定区内径差>10%)。
- 共识阈值定义为>75%同意或不同意。
- 推荐术后使用CT血管造影随访影像,评估远端密封长度。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 研究揭示持续存在的争议与考量需进一步探索,包括如何处理无IB型内漏的密封逐渐丧失。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Knowledge of hostile factors and their influence on long-term seal in the iliac landing zone is limited. Currently endorsed clinical practice guidelines lack structural evidence on how the iliac landing zone should be assessed in the pre-, intra-, and postoperative phases. The goal of this study was to obtain an international, expert-based consensus on the definition of a hostile iliac landing zone, on how to size and plan stent-grafts to optimize sustainable distal seal, and on the postprocedural follow-up protocol. METHODS: Delphi consensus methodology was used, involving a panel of international vascular surgeons experienced in endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR). The first round consisted of open-ended and multiple-choice questions to explore current practices, with subsequent rounds refining statements through a 4-point Likert scale. Consensus was defined as >75% agreement or disagreement, and the analysis included stability testing and strength of consensus. RESULTS: The study engaged 77 international vascular surgeons, reflecting diverse geographic locations and hospital affiliations. Consensus was achieved on critical preoperative planning elements for EVAR, including a clear definition for a hostile iliac landing zone. The importance of computed tomography angiography for postoperative follow-up imaging was emphasized, including evaluating distal seal length and recommending specific timing for follow-up computed tomography scans and intervention strategies for diminishing iliac seal. CONCLUSIONS: This international expert-based Delphi consensus establishes a comprehensive set of consensus-driven recommendations focused on the definition and management of hostile iliac landing zones in EVAR. The key recommendation of this study is the definition of a hostile iliac landing zone as short (<15 mm), wide (>24 mm), or conical (>10% diameter difference along the landing zone). Although consensus was achieved on several critical aspects, the study also reveals ongoing debates and considerations that warrant further exploration, including how to tackle diminishing seal without a type IB endoleak.Clinical ImpactThis Delphi consensus introduces a standardized definition of a hostile iliac landing zone as short (<15 mm), wide (>24 mm), or conical (>10% diameter difference), clinicians now have a clearer framework for assessing complex anatomies. This study provides a comprehensive set of consensus-driven recommendations focused on the definition and management of hostile iliac landing zones in EVAR which gives guidance where current guidelines lack specificity, particularly for distal iliac sealing. The study also reveals ongoing debates and considerations that warrant further exploration, including how to tackle diminishing seal without a type IB endoleak.
引用
- Kooijman MA, D'Oria M, Bertoglio L, et al. Transatlantic Delphi Consensus on the Common Iliac Artery Sealing Zone in Endovascular Aorto-Iliac Aneurysm Repair (the DECIDE Study). J Endovasc Ther. 2024. PMID: 39564868. doi:10.1177/15266028241295919
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。