指南与共识颈动脉与弓上血管

基于调查的颈动脉狭窄指南报告质量评估

Survey-Based Assessment of the Quality of Reporting Guidelines of Carotid Artery Stenosis.
指南 / 共识 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2024-07-14

本研究由43名血管外科、心脏科、神经科或介入放射科医生使用AGREE II工具和RIGHT声明,对ESVS 2023、ESO 2021和SVS 2021三部颈动脉狭窄指南的质量与报告进行评估;ESVS指南总体质量得分最高,ESVS、SVS、ESO的AGREE II总体质量得分分别为87.3%、79.4%、82.9%(P=0.001),RIGHT声明总体质量得分分别为84.0.7%、74.3%、79.0%(P=0.001)。

要点

  • ESVS 2023颈动脉狭窄指南在3部指南中评估最佳,得分比其他2部指南高5%以上。
  • AGREE II总体质量得分:ESVS 87.3%、SVS 79.4%、ESO 82.9%(P=0.001)。
  • RIGHT声明总体质量得分:ESVS 84.0.7%、SVS 74.3%、ESO 79.0%(P=0.001)。

核心结论

  • 2023年ESVS颈动脉狭窄指南是3部指南中评估最佳的,得分比其他2部指南高5%以上。
  • 指南编写委员会应在制定未来指南时考虑AGREE II和RIGHT声明,以产生高质量推荐。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于调查的评估,由43名血管外科医生、心脏科医生、神经科医生或介入放射科医生参与。
  • 使用AGREE II工具和RIGHT声明2种经过验证的指南质量与报告评估工具。
  • 评估对象为ESVS 2023、ESO 2021和SVS 2021三部颈动脉狭窄指南。

主要发现

  • AGREE II工具总体质量得分:ESVS 87.3%、SVS 79.4%、ESO 82.9%(P=0.001)。
  • ESVS和ESO在范围和目的领域得分更好,SVS在表述清晰性领域得分更好。
  • RIGHT声明总体质量得分:ESVS 84.0.7%、SVS 74.3%、ESO 79.0%(P=0.001)。
  • 3部指南在证据检索方法和制定循证推荐方面均表现突出。
  • 3部指南在制定推荐时的成本和资源影响方面主要被负面评价。

关键数值与推荐

  • AGREE II总体质量得分:ESVS 87.3%、SVS 79.4%、ESO 82.9%(P=0.001)。
  • RIGHT声明总体质量得分:ESVS 84.0.7%、SVS 74.3%、ESO 79.0%(P=0.001)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: No evaluation of the quality of different carotid guidelines using validated scales has been performed to date. The present study aims to analyze 3 carotid stenosis guidelines, apprizing their quality and reporting using validated tools. METHODS: A survey-based assessment of the quality of the European Society for Vascular Surgery (ESVS) 2023, European Stroke Organisation (ESO) 2021, and the Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) 2021 carotid stenosis guidelines, was performed by 43 vascular surgeons, cardiologists, neurologist or interventional radiologists using 2 validated appraisal tools for quality and reporting guidelines, the AGREE II instrument and the RIGHT statement. RESULTS: Using the AGREE II tool, the ESVS, SVS, and ESO guidelines had overall quality scores of 87.3%, 79.4%, and 82.9%, respectively (P = 0.001) The ESVS and ESO had better scores in the scope and purpose domain, and the SVS in the clarity of presentation domain. In the RIGHT statement, the ESVS, SVS, and ESO guidelines had overall quality scores of 84.0.7%, 74.3%, and 79.0%, respectively (P = 0.001). All 3 guidelines stood out for their methodology for search of evidence and formulating evidence-based recommendations. On the contrary, were negatively evaluated mostly in the cost and resource implications in formulating the recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: The 2023 ESVS carotid stenosis guideline was the best evaluated among the 3 guidelines, with scores over 5% higher than the other 2 guidelines. Efforts should be made by guideline writing committees to take the AGREE II and RIGHT statements into account in the development of future guidelines to produce high-quality recommendations.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gonzalez-Urquijo M, Gómez-Gutiérrez OA, Hinojosa-Gonzalez DE, et al. Survey-Based Assessment of the Quality of Reporting Guidelines of Carotid Artery Stenosis. Ann Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 39004276. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2024.05.019

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。