慢性下肢外周动脉疾病血管内治疗报告标准依从性的文献计量学分析
该文献计量学分析检索2020年1月至2022年8月发表的54篇相关文献,评估其对血管外科学会(SVS)2016年慢性肢体威胁性缺血血管内治疗报告标准的依从性。平均仅报告42.0%的标准,74.1%的文章(n=40)未依从至少50.0%的标准;美国研究及有行业赞助的研究更可能依从>50%的标准(P<0.05)。
要点
- 平均依从42.0%的SVS报告标准,范围25.0-65.2%。
- 74.1%的文章(n=40)未依从至少50.0%的标准。
- 美国研究及行业赞助研究更可能依从>50%标准(P<0.05)。
核心结论
- 无论期刊质量如何,对SVS下肢外周动脉疾病血管内治疗报告标准的依从性均不理想。
- 作者认为应优先提高对报告标准的依从性,以提供跨技术研究比较的框架。
研究设计与样本
- 文献数据库检索纳入2020年1月至2022年8月发表的英文临床试验、随机对照试验和回顾性比较研究,排除系统综述、病例报告和Meta分析,最终纳入54篇手稿。
主要发现
- 文章平均报告42.0%的SVS报告标准(范围25.0-65.2%)。
- 74.1%的文章(n=40)未依从至少50.0%的标准。
- 手稿最完整遵循患者因素相关指南,最不可能依从慢性肢体威胁性缺血描述和研究并发症的指南。
- 任何手稿均未在支架试验、疾病结局指标、技术结局指标、患者因素和临界肢体缺血描述等子类别中完全依从指南,其他子类别完全依从率低(范围5.6-18.6%)。
- 美国境内开展的研究和有行业赞助的研究更可能依从>50%的报告标准(P<0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应优先提高对报告标准的依从性,以提供跨技术研究比较的框架。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The treatment of chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI) involves a broad spectrum of therapies including many new and emerging techniques. To standardize the results of studies examining this pathology and to allow critical analysis and comparison between studies, the Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) recommended reporting standard guidelines for the endovascular management of CLTI in 2016. Research studies that do not adhere to complete reporting standards are often more ambiguous in impact and external validity, leading to bias and misinformation that has potentially damaging effects on clinical decision-making. We thus sought to examine adherence to and factors associated with noncompliance with these recommended guidelines. METHODS: A literature database search was conducted to include all clinical trials, randomized controlled trials, and retrospective comparative studies written in English examining the endovascular treatment of peripheral artery disease (PAD)/CLTI from January 2020 to August 2022. Systematic reviews, case reports, and meta-analysis were excluded. The manuscripts were reviewed for adherence with the SVS guidelines (overall and by guideline subcategories based on demographics, treatment methods, and outcomes), and factors associated with this adherence were determined. These data were used to calculate descriptive and comparative statistics. RESULTS: Fifty-four manuscripts were identified from this time frame. On average, articles reviewed reported on 42.0% of the SVS reporting standards (range, 25.0-65.2%, Fig 1) with 74.1% of articles (n = 40) not adhering to at least 50.0% of the standards. Manuscripts most completely followed guidelines regarding "patient factors" and were least likely to demonstrate adherence to the description of CLTI and study complications. Within the guideline subcategories, complete adherence to guidelines was not demonstrated in any manuscript in stent trials, disease outcome measures, technical outcome measures, patient factors and critical limb ischemia description, and complete adherence rates within the other subcategories was low (range, 5.6-18.6%). Studies conducted within the United States and those with industry sponsorship were more likely to adhere to >50% of the reporting standards (P < 0.05). Journal impact factor, year of publication, and number of authors had no correlation to the percent adherence to guidelines in specific categories or adherence overall. CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to reporting standard guidelines for endovascular treatment of lower extremity PAD specifically outlined by the SVS is suboptimal regardless of the quality of the journal the research is published in. Increasing adherence to reporting standards to provide a framework for comparison of studies across techniques used should be prioritized by authors, journal editors, and vascular societies.
引用
- Modi N, Timmer Z, Taylor A, et al. A Bibliometric Analysis on Adherence to Reporting Standards for Endovascular Treatment of Chronic Lower Extremity Peripheral Artery Disease. Ann Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 39019254. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2024.06.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。