指南与共识主动脉疾病

关于血管内主动脉瘤修复术后不良事件危险因素的专家德尔菲共识:国际血管内动脉瘤修复风险分层(IRIS-EVAR)工作组第一层级研究

An Expert Delphi Consensus on Risk Factors for Adverse Events After Endovascular Aortic Aneurysm Repair: Tier 1 Study From the International RIsk Stratification in EVAR (IRIS-EVAR) Working Group.
指南 / 共识 · J Endovasc Ther · 2024-07-31

国际IRIS-EVAR项目第一层级通过三轮德尔菲专家共识(2022年7月至12月)评估EVAR术后不良事件危险因素,35名来自12个国家的专家对64项因素评分,其中37项(58%)达成共识,分属术前解剖、器械选择、手术操作和术后监测4个领域,各领域最高共识因素分别为近端瘤颈长度<15 mm(98%)、解剖不符合使用说明书(94%)、植入后近端瘤颈长度<10 mm(98%)以及着陆区或重叠区密封不满意/瘤囊扩张/扭结或狭窄(各100%)。

要点

  • 64项EVAR术后不良事件危险因素中37项(58%)达成专家共识。
  • 共识因素分4领域:术前解剖14项(38%)、器械选择3项(8%)、手术操作8项(22%)、术后监测12项(32%)。
  • 各领域最高共识因素分别为近端瘤颈长度<15 mm(98%)、解剖不符合使用说明书(94%)、植入后近端瘤颈长度<10 mm(98%)、着陆区或重叠区密封不满意/瘤囊扩张/扭结或狭窄(各100%)。

核心结论

  • 通过专家共识识别了EVAR术后不良事件的临床重要危险因素,将用于制定基于专家共识的风险分层和监测策略。

研究设计与样本

  • 国际IRIS-EVAR项目第一层级德尔菲共识,指导委员会提出EVAR术后不良事件危险因素,专家可补充;专家通过3轮结构化在线调查评分,第一轮于2022年7月开放,第三轮于2022年12月关闭;采用4点李克特量表评分,共识定义为每轮>70%参与者同意/强烈同意或不同意/强烈不同意。

主要发现

  • 35名来自12个国家的专家完成了3轮调查。
  • 64项个体危险因素中37项(58%)达成共识为EVAR术后不良事件的重要危险因素。
  • 风险因素分层:术前解剖相关14项(38%)、主动脉器械选择相关3项(8%)、手术操作相关8项(22%)、术后监测相关12项(32%)。
  • 各领域最高共识因素:近端主动脉瘤颈长度<15 mm(98%共识)、解剖不符合使用说明书(94%共识)、植入后获得的近端主动脉瘤颈长度<10 mm(98%共识)、着陆区或重叠区密封不满意/瘤囊扩张/扭结或狭窄(各100%共识)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识定义为每轮>70%参与者同意/强烈同意或不同意/强烈不同意。
  • 近端主动脉瘤颈长度<15 mm获98%共识。
  • 解剖不符合使用说明书获94%共识。
  • 植入后获得的近端主动脉瘤颈长度<10 mm获98%共识。
  • 着陆区或重叠区密封不满意、瘤囊扩张、扭结或狭窄各获100%共识。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。
  • 作者指出这些因素将用于开发基于专家共识的风险分层和监测策略,并有望为血管外科医生日常使用的风险分层工具提供信息。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Tier 1 of the International RIsk Stratification in EndoVascular Aneurysm Repair (IRIS-EVAR) project aimed to identify important risk factors for adverse events following endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Initially, the steering committee proposed a number of risk factors for adverse events following EVAR. A Delphi consensus was performed as expert panelists were presented with risk factors and provided the opportunity to propose additional risk factors during the process. Experts in EVAR completed an online survey via 3 structured rounds. The first round opened in July 2022, and the third round closed in December 2022. Panelists rated risk factors using a 4-point Likert scale. Consensus was defined as >70% of participants agreeing/strongly agreeing or disagreeing/strongly disagreeing with a statement in each round. RESULTS: Thirty-five panelists from 12 countries completed the 3 rounds of surveys. Of a total of 64 individual risk factors assessed by the panelists, 37 (58%) had consensus that they were important for adverse events following EVAR. Risk factors were stratified in 4 domains: 14 (38%) were related to preoperative anatomy, 3 (8%) related to the aortic device selection, 8 (22%) related to the procedure performance, and 12 (32%) related to postoperative surveillance. Factors with the highest consensus in each domain were as follows: proximal aortic neck length <15 mm (98% consensus), anatomy non-compliant with instructions for use (94% consensus), length of achieved proximal aortic neck post implantation <10 mm (98% consensus), and non-satisfactory seal at landing or overlapping zones/sac expansion/kink or stenosis (100% consensus each), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Clinically important risk factors for adverse events after EVAR were identified via expert consensus. These factors will be used to develop an expert consensus-informed risk stratification and surveillance strategies.Clinical impactThis is the first study to apply an in-depth Delphi methodology to achieve an expert consensus on risk factors for adverse events after endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR). Important risk factors were stratified in 4 domains: preoperative anatomy (14 factors), aortic device (3 factors), EVAR procedure (8 factors), and postoperative surveillance (12 factors). This study will potentially influence future clinical practice by providing evidence informed by experts regarding predictors of adverse events following EVAR that can be taken into account during decision making and developing post-EVAR surveillance strategies. These findings will inform a risk stratification tool for everyday use by vascular surgeons.

来源:J Endovasc Ther,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Talbot AB, Schermerhorn ML, Forbes TL, et al. An Expert Delphi Consensus on Risk Factors for Adverse Events After Endovascular Aortic Aneurysm Repair: Tier 1 Study From the International RIsk Stratification in EVAR (IRIS-EVAR) Working Group. J Endovasc Ther. 2024. PMID: 39082433. doi:10.1177/15266028241267014

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。