外周动脉疾病观察性研究中病例识别标准的统一化:一项范围综述
该范围综述通过系统检索PubMed 2010至2021年注册数据库研究,纳入90项外周动脉疾病研究,发现36项(40%)未明确所研究的PAD分级,49项(54%)明确了分级,5项(6%)在方法和基线人口学中区分了不同PAD亚组但未在后续分析中区分;所应用的ICD代码存在显著异质性、重叠和不一致。作者认为这些发现挑战研究有效性并妨碍研究间比较,并提出标准化病例选择的共识框架初步设想。
要点
- 90项注册数据库PAD研究中,36项(40%)未明确所研究的PAD分级。
- 49项(54%)研究明确了PAD分级,5项(6%)仅在方法和基线中区分亚组。
- 明确PAD分级的研究中,用于病例识别的ICD代码存在显著异质性、重叠和不一致。
核心结论
- 很大比例的注册数据库PAD研究未能定义研究焦点;在报告了焦点的研究中,PAD病例识别策略不一致,挑战研究有效性并妨碍研究间比较。
- 本范围综述为外周动脉疾病行政数据库研究中标准化病例选择的共识框架提供了首个初步设想。
- 作者预期更统一的编码将提高研究有效性并促进研究间比较。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,通过系统PubMed检索识别2010年至2021年间发表的注册数据库报告。
- 共纳入90项研究,按表达的研究焦点分为跛行、严重肢体缺血或一般外周动脉疾病,并映射用于病例识别的ICD代码。
主要发现
- 90项研究中,36项(40%)未明确所研究的PAD分级。
- 49项(54%)文章明确了所研究的PAD分级。
- 5项(6%)文章在方法和基线人口学中明确了不同PAD亚组,但未在后续分析中区分。
- 对明确PAD分级的研究进行ICD代码映射显示显著异质性、重叠和不一致。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The diagnosis of peripheral arterial disease (PAD) is commonly applied for symptoms related to atherosclerotic obstructions in the lower extremity, though its clinical manifestations range from an abnormal ankle-brachial index to critical limb ischemia. Subsequently, management and prognosis of PAD vary widely with the disease stage. A critical aspect is how this variation is addressed in administrative database-based studies that rely on diagnosis codes for case identification. The objective of this scoping review is to inventory the identification strategies used in studies on PAD that rely on administrative databases, to map the pros and cons of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes applied, and to propose a first outline for a consensus framework for case identification in administrative databases. METHODS: Registry-based reports published between 2010 and 2021 were identified through a systematic PubMed search. Studies were subcategorized on the basis of the expressed study focus: claudication, critical limb ischemia, or general peripheral arterial disease, and the ICD code(s) applied for case identification mapped. RESULTS: Ninety studies were identified, of which 36 (40%) did not specify the grade of PAD studied. Forty-nine (54%) articles specified PAD grade studied. Five (6%) articles specified different PAD subgroups in methods and baseline demographics, but not in further analyses. Mapping of the ICD codes applied for case identification for studies that specified the PAD grade studied indicated a remarkable heterogeneity, overlap, and inconsistency. CONCLUSIONS: A large proportion of registry-based studies on PAD fail to define the study focus. In addition, inconsistent strategies are used for PAD case identification in studies that report a focus. These findings challenge study validity and interfere with inter-study comparison. This scoping review provides a first initiative for a consensus framework for standardized case selection in administrative studies on PAD. It is anticipated that more uniform coding will improve study validity and facilitate inter-study comparisons.
引用
- Keekstra N, Biemond M, van Schaik J, et al. Toward Uniform Case Identification Criteria in Observational Studies on Peripheral Arterial Disease: A Scoping Review. Ann Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 38615752. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2024.02.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。