开窗式腔内主动脉瘤修复术所用导引鞘的稳态漏血率体外比较
本研究在体外模型中比较了三种大孔径导引鞘(Gore DrySeal Flex、Cook Performer Check-Flo、Medtronic Sentrant)在插入多个小鞘时的漏血率。结果显示,仅插入一个鞘时漏血率很低;插入多个鞘时漏血率显著增加,Medtronic漏血最多,Cook次之,Gore最低。Gore DrySeal在插入3个小直径鞘时漏血率仍接近1 ml/s,视手术时长仍可能导致显著失血。
要点
- 仅插入1个6F鞘时,三种大孔径导引鞘的漏血率均很低。
- 插入多个鞘时漏血率显著增加,Medtronic漏血最多,Cook次之,Gore最低。
- Gore DrySeal在插入2个6F+1个7F鞘时漏血率略低于1 ml/s。
核心结论
- 插入多个鞘时漏血率显著增加,Gore大孔径导引鞘在需要同时插入多个小鞘时漏血率显著低于Cook和Medtronic。
- Gore DrySeal在插入3个小直径鞘时漏血率最低(略低于1 ml/s),但视手术时长仍可能导致显著失血。
研究设计与样本
- 体外实验:构建含18升储液器的测试装置,以恒压水柱评估三种大孔径导引鞘(Gore DrySeal Flex、Medtronic Sentrant、Cook Performer Check-Flo)在不同小鞘组合下的漏血率。
主要发现
- 仅插入一个6F鞘时,所有三种大孔径导引鞘的漏血率均很低。
- 插入多个鞘时漏血率显著增加,Medtronic漏血最多,Cook次之,Gore最低。
- Cook大孔径导引鞘在插入2个6F鞘时的漏血率约为Gore的106倍,在插入2个6F+1个7F鞘时约为Gore的5倍。
- Medtronic大孔径导引鞘在插入2个6F鞘时的漏血率约为Gore的132倍,在插入2个6F+1个7F鞘时约为Gore的8倍。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Fenestrated Endovascular Aneurysm Repair (fEVAR) involves deploying a covered stent into the aorta followed by multiple visceral stents through fenestrations in the main body of graft. The most commonly used large sheaths for cannulation of visceral vessels are the Gore DrySeal Flex, Cook Performer Check-Flo, and Medtronic Sentrant. None of these sheaths were designed for the insertion of multiple sheaths, and so a slow but steady leakage of blood occurs during the procedure. The aim of this paper is to assess in an in vitro setting which large bore sheath has the best valve for use when multiple smaller sheaths are inserted through it. METHODS: Three large bore introducer sheaths (LBISs) were used for this study, The Gore DrySeal Flex LBIS, Medtronic Sentrant LBIS and Cook Performer Check-Flo LBIS. A test rig was constructed, made of an 18-liter fluid reservoir mounted vertically and receiving a constant supply of water from a domestic water supply which flowed into the reservoir and out of an overflow. The reservoir was connected to the LBIS by a vertical plastic pipe with an internal diameter of 40 mm and an isolation valve. The LBIS was connected to the isolation valve by inserting the LBIS up a flexible silicone tube connected to the isolation valve. The LBIS was subject to a constant column/pressure of water and fluid leakage from the LBIS was collected in a plastic pot/tray placed underneath the LBIS. The leakage rates through each LBIS were determined for the following smaller diameter sheath combinations inserted through the valve, one 6 French Sheath, two 6 French Sheaths, two 6 French Sheaths and one 7 French Sheath. This was done to closely mimic a fEVAR procedure in vitro. The procedure was to insert different sheath combinations through the nonreturn valves in the LBIS and measure the volume of fluid that leaked through the valves. The leaked fluid was weighed, and the weight was converted to volume using the density of water (1 g/ml). RESULTS: The average (mean) leakage rates for each LBIS and each sheath combination showed that leakage rates when only one sheath was inserted were very low. For all 3 LBIS's tested, the leakage rates increased dramatically when multiple sheaths were inserted. The Medtronic LBIS leaked the most, followed by Cook, followed by Gore. For the Cook LBIS, the leakage rates exhibited with 2 × 6 French sheaths were approx. 106 times greater than those for the Gore LBIS and 5 times greater for the 2 × 6 French +1 × 7 French sheath combination. A similar comparison for the Medtronic LBIS versus the Gore LBIS yields factors of 132 and 8. CONCLUSIONS: Leakage rates increase significantly when multiple sheaths are inserted and the Gore LBIS demonstrates significantly lower leakage than both the Cook and Medtronic during procedures that require simultaneous, multiple insertions of smaller sheaths. Although the Gore Dryseal has by far the lowest leakage rate when 3 small diameter sheaths are inserted (just under 1 ml/s), depending on the duration of the procedure this could still result in significant blood loss.
引用
- Corden J, Khan K, Wong JH, et al. An In-Vitro Comparison of Steady State Leakage Rates through Introducer Sheaths Used for Fenestrated Endovascular Aortic Aneurysm Repair. Ann Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 38582209. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2024.01.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。