颈动脉血运重建时代的患者决策:经颈动脉血运重建背景下的共享决策质性研究
该研究通过纵向围手术期半结构化访谈,对20例接受颈动脉内膜切除术或经颈动脉血运重建(TCAR)的患者及9名血管外科医生进行质性分析,识别出影响患者术式选择的三个重要领域:个人价值观、对疾病与术式的理解、以及医疗决策偏好风格。作者认为共享决策(SDM)在颈动脉血运重建中具有细微差异,患者自主性偏好存在差异,该分析可为医患对话提供参考。
要点
- 患者术式选择受个人价值观、疾病与术式理解、决策偏好风格三个领域影响。
- 患者对颈动脉疾病理解程度的需求各异,但均希望与手术医生讨论每种选项。
- 患者决策风格从完全自主到希望医生代为决定不等,手术医生被视为最重要信息来源。
核心结论
- 围绕颈动脉血运重建的共享决策具有细微差异,患者在选择治疗时的自主性偏好存在差异;鉴于联邦医疗保险(Medicare)要求颈动脉支架置入前进行共享决策互动,该分析为引导患者与提供者之间高效有效的对话以达成共享决策提供了关键见解。
研究设计与样本
- 采用目的性最大变异抽样的质性研究,对20名接受颈动脉内膜切除术或经颈动脉血运重建(TCAR)的参与者进行纵向围手术期半结构化访谈,并对9名血管外科医生进行访谈,访谈数据采用归纳内容分析编码进行分析。
主要发现
- 识别出三个影响参与者最终术式选择的重要领域:个人价值观、对疾病及每种术式的理解、以及偏好如何做出医疗决策。
- 参与者价值观包括成功率、「希望感觉更好」以及手术医生的经验等主题;参与者对颈动脉疾病所需理解程度各异,但所有个体都希望与手术医生讨论每种选项。
- 参与者的医疗决策风格从完全自主到希望手术医生代为决定不等;选择颈动脉内膜切除术的参与者认为其结局优于TCAR,且常表达希望消除颈动脉斑块;选择TCAR的参与者认为其是更新、创伤更小且手术与恢复时间最短的选项。
- 外科医生常提及患者因素如年龄和解剖结构,以及长期数据的可获得性,作为优先选择某种术式的理由;对大多数参与者而言,其外科医生被视为围绕其疾病和术式的最重要信息来源。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The National Coverage Determination on carotid stenting by Medicare in October 2023 stipulates that patients participate in a shared decision-making (SDM) conversation with their proceduralist before an intervention. However, to date, there is no validated SDM tool that incorporates transcarotid artery revascularization (TCAR) into its decision platform. Our objective was to elicit patient and surgeon experiences and preferences through a qualitative approach to better inform the SDM process surrounding carotid revascularization. METHODS: We performed longitudinal perioperative semistructured interviews of 20 participants using purposive maximum variation sampling, a qualitative technique designed for identification and selection of information-rich cases, to define domains important to participants undergoing carotid endarterectomy or TCAR and impressions of SDM. We also performed interviews with nine vascular surgeons to elicit their input on the SDM process surrounding carotid revascularization. Interview data were coded and analyzed using inductive content analysis coding. RESULTS: We identified three important domains that contribute to the participants' ultimate decision on which procedure to choose: their individual values, their understanding of the disease and each procedure, and how they prefer to make medical decisions. Participant values included themes such as success rates, "wanting to feel better," and the proceduralist's experience. Participants varied in their desired degree of understanding of carotid disease, but all individuals wished to discuss each option with their proceduralist. Participants' desired medical decision-making style varied on a spectrum from complete autonomy to wanting the proceduralist to make the decision for them. Participants who preferred carotid endarterectomy felt outcomes were superior to TCAR and often expressed a desire to eliminate the carotid plaque. Those selecting TCAR felt it was a newer, less invasive option with the shortest procedural and recovery times. Surgeons frequently noted patient factors such as age and anatomy, as well as the availability of long-term data, as reasons to preferentially select one procedure. For most participants, their surgeon was viewed as the most important source of information surrounding their disease and procedure. CONCLUSIONS: SDM surrounding carotid revascularization is nuanced and marked by variation in patient preferences surrounding autonomy when choosing treatment. Given the mandate by Medicare to participate in a SDM interaction before carotid stenting, this analysis offers critical insights that can help to guide an efficient and effective dialog between patients and providers to arrive at a shared decision surrounding therapeutic intervention for patients with carotid disease.
引用
- Krafcik BM, Stone DH, Scali ST, et al. Patient decision-making in the era of transcarotid artery revascularization. J Vasc Surg. 2024. PMID: 38447624. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2024.02.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。