外周动脉疾病外科与腔内治疗后的监测:荷兰一项调查
本研究向荷兰血管外科学会全体血管外科医生发放在线调查,评估外周动脉疾病(PAD)开放与腔内血运重建后的监测方案。210名血管外科医生中97名(46.2%)回复,76%报告使用常规随访方案;10种干预中6种以多普勒超声(DUS)为最常用影像方式,监测频率与持续时间在同一干预内差异很大。作者建议开展前瞻性研究评估标准化监测项目的临床需求与成本效益。
要点
- 210名荷兰血管外科医生中97名(46.2%)回复调查,76%报告使用常规随访方案。
- 股动脉内膜切除术后仅临床随访最常见(53%),外周旁路术后仅临床随访很少(4-8%)。
- 6/10种干预以DUS为最常用随访影像;旁路术后76-86%行DUS(联合或不联合ABI),腔内术后21-60%行DUS监测。
核心结论
- 荷兰PAD患者外科与腔内治疗后的监测存在显著实践差异。
- 作者建议开展前瞻性研究以评估治疗结局并明确标准化监测项目的临床需求与成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 向荷兰血管外科学会全体血管外科医生发放在线调查,评估PAD开放与腔内血运重建后的随访。
- 监测定义为干预后至少一次随访访视,伴或不伴额外影像或踝肱指数(ABI)测量。
- 调查涵盖10种PAD干预类型;210名血管外科医生中97名(46.2%)回复。
主要发现
- 97名回复者中76%报告在侵入性干预后使用常规随访方案。
- 股动脉内膜切除术后仅临床随访最常见(53%);外周旁路术后仅临床随访很少(4-8%)。
- 10种调查干预中6种以DUS为最常用随访影像方式。
- 旁路术后76-86%的血管外科医生行DUS伴或不伴ABI测量;腔内干预后21-60%行DUS监测。
- 主动脉双股动脉旁路术后终身监测最常应用(57%);同一干预内监测频率与持续时间差异很大,频率从每3或6个月至每年,持续时间从单次监测至终身随访。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: At present, there is no clear, optimal approach to surveillance after invasive treatment of peripheral artery disease (PAD) in terms of modality, duration, clinical benefit, and cost effectiveness. The ongoing debate on the clinical benefit and cost effectiveness of standard surveillance creates a clear knowledge gap and may result in overtreatment or undertreatment. In this study, a survey was conducted among vascular surgeons in the Netherlands to assess the currently applied surveillance programmes. METHODS: All vascular surgeons from the Dutch Society for Vascular Surgery received an online survey on follow up after open and endovascular revascularisation in patients with PAD. Surveillance was defined as at least one follow up visit after intervention with or without additional imaging or ankle brachial index (ABI) measurement. Ten types of PAD intervention were surveyed. RESULTS: Surveys were returned by 97 (46.2%) of 210 vascular surgeons, and 76% reported using a routine follow up protocol after an invasive intervention. Clinical follow up only is most commonly performed after femoral endarterectomy (53%). After peripheral bypass surgery, clinical follow up only is applied rarely (4 - 8%). In six of the 10 interventions surveyed, duplex ultrasound (DUS) was the most used imaging modality for follow up. After bypass surgery, 76 - 86% of vascular surgeons perform DUS with or without ABI measurement. After endovascular interventions, 21 - 60% performed DUS surveillance. Lifelong surveillance is most often applied after aortobifemoral bypass (57%). Surveillance frequency and duration vary greatly within the same intervention. Frequencies range from every three or six months to annually. Duration ranges from one time surveillance to lifelong follow up. CONCLUSION: There is significant practice variation in surveillance after surgical and endovascular treatment of patients with PAD in the Netherlands. Prospective studies to evaluate treatment outcomes and to define the clinical need and cost effectiveness of standardised surveillance programmes for patients with PAD are recommended.
引用
- Hoitz N, Kraima A, Fioole B, et al. Surveillance After Surgical and Endovascular Treatment for Peripheral Artery Disease: a Dutch Survey. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 38159674. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2023.12.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。