对血管外科学会间歇性跛行管理适宜使用标准的评估:关键发现与实施考虑
血管外科学会于2022年发布间歇性跛行管理适宜使用标准(AUC),采用加州大学洛杉矶分校RAND适宜性方法对2280个场景进行评分。评分小组认为药物管理和运动疗法在所有场景中均为适宜的初始管理,血运重建在部分场景中也适宜,主要受身体受限严重程度和有利病变特征影响。膝下段因风险均大于获益而全体同意放弃逐场景评分。
要点
- 药物管理和运动疗法在所有场景中均为适宜的初始管理。
- 血运重建在部分场景中也适宜,主要受身体受限严重程度和有利病变特征影响。
- 膝下段因评分小组全体认为风险均大于获益而放弃逐场景评分。
核心结论
- 血管外科学会间歇性跛行AUC是识别和减少过度使用的重要努力,其使用需考虑多种因素。
- 最简单应用是临床医生在床旁与患者共同决策时使用;支付方使用更复杂,理想情况下需额外研究其表现后再用于支付方决策。
- AUC还识别出大量证据缺乏领域,为未来研究提供重要目标。
研究设计与样本
- 血管外科学会于2022年发布间歇性跛行管理适宜使用标准(AUC)文件,采用加州大学洛杉矶分校RAND适宜性方法。
- 评分小组评估了2280个场景的适宜性,涵盖初始管理和运动疗法失败后的管理。
主要发现
- 评分小组认为药物管理和运动疗法在所有场景中均为适宜的初始管理。
- 有多个场景中血运重建也被认为适宜,主要受身体受限严重程度和有利病变特征影响。
- 运动疗法失败后管理时,评分小组引用的指导原则包括干预耐久性、戒烟和既往良好 faith 运动疗法努力证据。
- 有许多场景为不确定。
- 关于膝下段,评分小组全体同意放弃逐场景评分,因其认为所有情况下风险均大于获益。
关键数值与推荐
- 评分小组评估了2280个场景的适宜性。
- 药物管理和运动疗法在所有场景中均为适宜的初始管理。
- 膝下段所有情况下风险均大于获益,评分小组全体同意放弃逐场景评分。
临床怎么用
- 最简单应用是临床医生在床旁与患者共同决策时使用。
- 支付方使用更复杂,理想情况下需额外研究其表现后再用于支付方任何决策。
局限性
- 有许多场景为不确定。
- AUC识别出大量证据缺乏领域。
- 理想情况下,关于如何最佳使用AUC的决策需额外研究其表现后再用于支付方任何决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Several concerns have been raised over the past several years about the potential for overuse of vascular interventions for peripheral artery disease. These interventions can have serious complications, including limb loss. Given that the natural history of intermittent claudication rarely includes limb loss, it is critically important that interventions to treat it have appropriate indications. METHODS: To address this matter, the Society for Vascular Surgery published an appropriate use criteria (AUC) document for the management of intermittent claudication in 2022. Using the rigorously studied University of California Los Angeles RAND Appropriateness Method, the rating panel assessed the appropriateness of 2,280 scenarios for [1] the initial management and [2] the management after a failed trial of exercise therapy. RESULTS: The findings of the rating panel included that medical management and exercise therapy are appropriate initial management in all scenarios. There were several scenarios in which revascularization was also considered appropriate, mainly influenced by severity of physical limitations and favorable lesion characteristics. When considering management after a failed trial of exercise, guiding principles cited by the rating panel included durability of intervention, smoking cessation, and evidence of prior good-faith effort at exercise therapy. There were many scenarios which were indeterminate. With respect to the infrapopliteal segment, the rating panelists unanimously agreed to forgo individual scenario ratings, since they deemed the risks outweigh the benefits in all cases. CONCLUSIONS: The Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) AUC for intermittent claudication represents an important effort to identify and reduce overuse. There are several considerations for how they should be used. The simplest application is by practicing clinicians, at the bedside, as they engage in shared decision-making with patients. The matter of their use by payors is more complex. Ideally, decisions on how to best use AUC require additional study of their performance before they are used by payors for anything. Finally, these AUC have identified a myriad of areas where evidence is lacking. The AUC provide important targets for future research to improve the care of patients with intermittent claudication.
引用
- Forsyth AM, Simons JP. An Assessment of the Society for Vascular Surgery Appropriate Use Criteria for the Management of Intermittent Claudication: Key Findings and Considerations for Implementation. Ann Vasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37944895. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2023.10.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。