下腔静脉滤器:互联网患者信息的可读性与质量评估
该研究于2022年12月使用Google、Yahoo和Bing检索下腔静脉滤器相关网站,纳入110个网站,按学术、医生、商业和未指定分类,采用JAMA标准、DISCERN工具和HONcode认证评估质量,采用FRES和FKGL评估可读性。结果显示网站质量欠佳,可读性未达推荐标准,学术和商业网站尤其需要提升内容质量。
要点
- 纳入110个网站,商业网站占25%、医院24%、学术21%、未指定16%、医生14%。
- JAMA平均分1.93±1.19,DISCERN平均分45.20±12.58,仅2个网站有HONcode认证。
- FRES平均分51.57±12.04,仅12个来源达到≤6年级阅读水平目标。
核心结论
- 在线下腔静脉滤器信息质量欠佳,学术和商业网站尤其需要提升内容质量。
- 鉴于HONcode已停止作为标准化质量评估标志,建议开发并实施类似的认证工具用于在线患者信息认证。
研究设计与样本
- 2022年12月使用Google、Yahoo和Bing三个搜索引擎检索下腔静脉滤器相关网站,共纳入110个网站。
- 按内容将网站分为学术、医生、商业和未指定四类。
- 采用JAMA标准、DISCERN工具和HONcode认证评估信息质量,采用FRES和FKGL评估可读性,统计学显著性设定为P<0.05。
主要发现
- 网站分类:商业25%、医院24%、学术21%、未指定16%、医生14%。
- JAMA平均分1.93±1.19(中位数1.5,范围0-4),DISCERN平均分45.20±12.58(中位数45.5,范围21-75)。
- 医生网站JAMA平均分最高为3.07±1.16,医院网站DISCERN平均分最高为52.85±12.66。
- 医生、医院和未指定网站JAMA平均分显著高于学术和商业网站(均P<0.001);医院网站DISCERN平均分显著高于学术(P=0.007)、商业(P<0.001)和未指定网站(P=0.017)。
- 可读性:FRES平均分51.57±12.04,对应10至12年级阅读水平;FKGL平均分8.20±1.70,对应8至10年级阅读水平;仅12个来源达到≤6年级目标阅读水平。
临床怎么用
- 研究作者建议开发并实施类似HONcode的认证工具用于在线患者信息认证,原文未据此给出其他临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The internet is an increasingly favorable source of information regarding health-related issues. The aim of this study is to apply appropriate evaluation tools to assess the evidence available online about inferior vena cava (IVC) filters with a focus on quality and readability. METHODS: A search was performed during December 2022 using three popular search engines, namely Google, Yahoo, and Bing. Websites were categorized into academic, physician, commercial, and unspecified websites according to their content. Information quality was determined using Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) criteria, the DISCERN scoring tool, and whether a Health On the Net Foundation certification (HONcode) seal was present. Readability was established using the Flesch Reading Ease Score (FRES) and Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL). Statistical significance was accepted as P < .05. RESULTS: In total, 110 websites were included in our study. The majority of websites were categorized as commercial (25%), followed by hospital (24%), academic (21%), unspecified (16%), and physician (14%). Average scores for all websites using JAMA and DISCERN were 1.93 ± 1.19 (median, 1.5; range, 0-4) and 45.20 ± 12.58 (median, 45.5; range, 21-75), respectively. The highest JAMA mean score of 3.07 ± 1.16 was allocated to physician websites, and the highest DISCERN mean score of 52.85 ± 12.66 was allocated to hospital websites. The HONcode seal appeared on two of the selected websites. Physician, hospital, and unspecified websites had a significantly higher mean JAMA score than academic and commercial websites (all with P < .001). Hospital websites had a significantly higher mean DISCERN score than academic (P = .007), commercial (P < .001), and unspecified websites (P = .017). Readability evaluation generated a mean FRES score of 51.57 ±12.04, which represented a 10th to 12th grade reading level and a mean FKGL score of 8.20 ± 1.70, which represented an 8th to 10th grade reading level. Only 12 sources were found to meet the ≤6th grade target reading level. No significant correlation was found between overall DISCERN score and overall FRES score. CONCLUSIONS: The study results demonstrate that the quality of online information about IVC filters is suboptimal, and academic and commercial websites, in particular, must enhance their content quality regarding the use of IVC filters. Considering the discontinuation of the HONcode as a standardized quality assessment marker, it is recommended that a similar certification tool be developed and implemented for the accreditation of patient information online.
引用
- Ko TK, Yun Tan DJ, Hadeed S, et al. IVC filter - assessing the readability and quality of patient information on the Internet. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2023. PMID: 37898304. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2023.101695
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。