标准与定制梯度弹力袜治疗慢性静脉疾病患者的随机对照试验
这项随机单盲对照试验将79例C2或C3期慢性静脉疾病患者分为定制梯度弹力袜(c-GECS)组与标准梯度弹力袜(s-GECS)组,比较第1、3、6个月静脉功能不全生活质量(VEINES-QOL)评分变化。c-GECS组在三个时间点评分改善均显著优于s-GECS组(P < .0001),两组小腿体积均有效降低且无显著差异,c-GECS贴合性与舒适性更好、依从性更高。
要点
- c-GECS组第1、3、6个月VEINES-QOL评分改善均显著优于s-GECS组(P < .0001)。
- 两组均有效降低小腿体积,组间无显著差异。
- c-GECS压力维持更稳定,第1个月日均穿戴时间10.7小时 vs 9.5小时(P < .05)。
核心结论
- 基于个体腿部参数模型的c-GECS较s-GECS显著改善C2或C3期慢性静脉疾病患者的VEINES-QOL评分,并提供稳定持久的压力。
- c-GECS与s-GECS均有效降低小腿体积,但c-GECS更贴合舒适、提高患者依从性,是难以耐受s-GECS患者的可行替代选择。
研究设计与样本
- 随机单盲对照试验,纳入79例C2或C3期慢性静脉疾病患者,分为c-GECS组与s-GECS组。
- 主要结局为第1、3、6个月VEINES-QOL评分较基线的变化。
- 次要结局包括弹力袜穿戴依从性、踝部最小周长处(B点)与小腿最大周长处(C点)的界面压力及小腿体积。
主要发现
- VEINES-QOL评分改善:第1个月c-GECS组8.47(95%CI 7.47-9.45)vs s-GECS组5.89(95%CI 5.00-6.78);第3个月9.60(95%CI 8.47-10.72)vs 6.72(95%CI 5.62-7.83);第6个月7.09(95%CI 5.93-8.24)vs 3.92(95%CI 2.67-5.18);P < .0001。
- 第1个月日均穿戴时间:c-GECS组10.7小时 vs s-GECS组9.5小时(P < .05)。
- s-GECS组局部高压与日均穿戴时长呈负相关(rpb = -0.388;n = 38;P < .05)。
- s-GECS组压力变异更大,c-GECS在压力维持方面具优势。
- 小腿体积降低(mL):第1个月c-GECS组90.0(95%CI 71.4-108.5)vs s-GECS组85.0(95%CI 65.6-104.2);第3个月93.8(95%CI 69.7-117.8)vs 85.9(95%CI 65.5-106.2);第6个月70.8(95%CI 46.5-95.2)vs 60.8(95%CI 44.1-77.5);组间无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,c-GECS是难以耐受s-GECS患者的可行替代选择。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the efficacy of customized graduated elastic compression stockings (c-GECSs) based on lower leg parameter models with standard GECSs (s-GECSs) in patients with chronic venous disease (CVD). METHODS: In this randomized, single-blind, controlled trial, 79 patients with stage C2 or C3 CVD were assigned to one of two groups: c-GECSs or s-GECSs. The primary outcome was change to Venous Insufficiency Epidemiological and Economic Study Quality of Life (VEINES-QOL) scores at months 1, 3, and 6 as compared with baseline. Secondary outcomes included compliance with wearing ECSs, interface pressure at the smallest circumference of the ankle (point B) and the largest circumference of the calf (point C), and calf volume (CV). RESULTS: There were 13 pairs of s-GECS and 2 pairs of c-GECS that showed pressure values higher than the standard at either point B or C. The c-GECSs were significantly superior to s-GECSs in terms of score improvement at all three time points (month 1, 8.47 [95% confidence interval (CI), 7.47-9.45] vs 5.89 [95% CI, 5.00-6.78]; month 3, 9.60 [95% CI, 8.47-10.72] vs 6.72 [95% CI, 5.62-7.83]; month 6, 7.09 [95% CI, 5.93-8.24] vs 3.92 [95% CI, 2.67-5.18]; P < .0001). Besides, at month 1, the mean daily use time of the c-GECS and s-GECS groups was 10.7 and 9.5 hours, respectively (P < .05). Correlation analysis indicated a negative relationship between local high pressure and daily duration in the s-GECS group (rpb = -0.388; n = 38; P < .05). Variances in pressure were greater in the s-GECSs group. The c-GECSs showed advantage in maintaining pressure. Both c-GECSs and s-GECSs effectively reduced CV (mL), with no significant differences between groups (month 1, 90.0 [95% CI, 71.4-108.5] vs 85.0 [95% CI, 65.6-104.2]; month 3, 93.8 [95% CI, 69.7-117.8] vs 85.9 [95% CI, 65.5-106.2]; month 6, 70.8 [95% CI, 46.5-95.2]) vs 60.8 [95% CI, 44.1-77.5]). CONCLUSIONS: The c-GECSs based on individual leg parameter models significantly improved VEINES-QOL scores and provided stable and enduring pressure as compared with s-GECSs for patients with stage C2 or C3 CVD. Although both c-GECSs and s-GECSs effectively reduced CV, the superior fit and comfort of c-GECSs improved patient compliance. Hence, c-GECSs are a viable alternative for patients who have difficulty tolerating s-GECSs.
引用
- Yang WT, Xiong Y, Wang SX, et al. A randomized controlled trial of standard vs customized graduated elastic compression stockings in patients with chronic venous disease. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2023. PMID: 37708938. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2023.08.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。