主动脉手术中经皮穿刺腋动脉第一段与第三段的结局比较
该回顾性多中心注册研究纳入2008至2021年412例经皮腋动脉穿刺并使用Perclose ProGlide闭合的主动脉手术患者,比较第一段(AXA1,172例)与第三段(AXA3,240例)的结局。结果显示开放转流率1%,主要局部并发症少见且可经腔内补救,卒中率4.4%;AXA1与AXA3成功率无显著差异(OR=0.537,95%CI 0.011-1.22,p=0.104),但AXA3联合>10F鞘管结局劣于AXA1(OR=0.367,95%CI 0.176-0.767,p=0.008);>12F鞘管时两段结局相似(p=0.31)。
要点
- 经皮腋动脉穿刺开放转流率1%,无主要血管并发症,仅1例主要非血管并发症。
- AXA1与AXA3成功率无显著差异(OR=0.537,95%CI 0.011-1.22,p=0.104)。
- AXA3联合>10F鞘管结局劣于AXA1(OR=0.367,95%CI 0.176-0.767,p=0.008)。
核心结论
- 经皮腋动脉入路使用≤12F鞘管时主要局部并发症少见且可通过补救性腔内介入解决,卒中风险仍是问题。
- 第一段与第三段腋动脉均适合穿刺且结果良好,但较大鞘管(12F)在第一段腋动脉表现更好。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心注册研究(NCT: 04589962),纳入2008至2021年所有经皮腋动脉穿刺并使用Perclose ProGlide装置闭合的主动脉手术患者,共412例穿刺。
- 比较第一段腋动脉(AXA1)172例(42%)与第三段腋动脉(AXA3)240例(58%)。
主要发现
- 左侧腋动脉置管363例(AXA1占76% vs AXA3占97%,p<0.001),91%的开窗/分支腔内修复(F/BEVAR)手术经左侧进行。
- 49%的手术使用了内径≥12F的鞘管;开放转流率1%,无主要血管并发症,仅记录1例主要非血管并发症。
- AXA1组18例(11%)与AXA3组32例(13%)发生主要闭合失败,分别经覆膜支架(8.3%)或裸金属支架(2.7%)治疗。
- 补救支架中位随访12个月通畅率100%,随访>36个月的6枚支架中6枚仍通畅;卒中率4.4%。
- 鞘管>12F与穿刺并发症(p<0.001)及卒中(p=0.005)独立相关,右侧穿刺仅与卒中相关(p=0.034);校正协变量后AXA1与AXA3成功率相等(AXA3的OR=0.537,95%CI 0.011-1.22,p=0.104)。
关键数值与推荐
- 疗效终点为经皮手术技术成功(无开放转流);安全终点为卒中和入路并发症,依据瓣膜学术研究联盟-3(VARC-3)报告标准。
- 主要闭合失败经覆膜支架(8.3%)或裸金属支架(2.7%)治疗;补救支架中位随访12个月通畅率100%。
临床怎么用
- 第一段和第三段腋动脉均可用于经皮穿刺且结果良好;使用较大鞘管(12F)时第一段腋动脉表现更好。
- 经皮腋动脉入路使用≤12F鞘管时主要局部并发症少见且可通过补救性腔内介入解决;卒中风险仍是问题。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This article aims at investigating the outcomes of percutaneous access via the first versus third axillary artery (AXA) segments with closure devices during aortic procedures. MATERIALS AND METHODS: All patients receiving percutaneous AXA access closed with Perclose ProGlide device (Abbott, Santa Clara, California) from 2008 to 2021 were included in a retrospective multicenter registry (NCT: 04589962). Efficacy endpoint was the technically successful percutaneous procedure (no open conversion). Safety endpoints were stroke and access complications according to the Valve Academic Research Consortium-3 reporting standards. The first (AXA1) or third (AXA3) axillary puncture sites were compared. RESULTS: A total of 412 percutaneous AXA accesses were included: 172 (42%) in AXA1 and 240 (58%) in AXA3. Left AXA was catheterized in 363 cases (76% of AXA1 vs 97% of AXA3, p<0.001) and 91% of fenestrated/branched endovascular repair (F/BEVAR) procedures were conducted from the left. A ≥12F internal diameter (ID) sheath was used in 49% of procedures. Open conversion rate was 1%, no major vascular complications occurred, and only one major non-vascular complication was recorded. Primary closure failure occurred in 18 AXA1 (11%) and 32 AXA3 accesses (13%), treated by covered (8.3%) or bare-metal (2.7%) stenting. Bailout stent patency was 100% at median follow-up of 12 months, with 6 of 6 stents still patent after >36 months of follow-up. Stroke rate was 4.4%. An introducer sheath >12F was independently associated with both access complications (p<0.001) and stroke (p=0.005), while a right-side access was associated with stroke only (p=0.034). Even after adjustment for covariates, AXA1 versus AXA3 showed an equal success rate (odds ratio [OR]=0.537, 95% confidence interval [CI]=0.011-1.22 for AXA3, p=0.104). The combination of AXA3 and a >10F introducer sheath provided worse outcomes compared with >10F sheaths through AXA1 (OR for success=0.367, 95% CI=0.176-0.767, p=0.008). This was not confirmed for >12F sheaths, associated with similar outcomes (p=0.31 AXA 1 vs AXA 3). CONCLUSION: Major local complications with the percutaneous axillary approach and ≤12F sheaths are infrequent and solvable by complementary endovascular interventions. Stroke risk remains an issue. First and third AXA segments are both amenable for access with good results, but larger sheaths (12F) perform better in AXA1.Clinical ImpactPercutaneous access with vascular closure devices at the first or third axillary artery (AXA) segments during aortic procedures is burdened by a negligible risk of open conversion. Local complications with the percutaneous axillary approach are infrequent and solvable by complementary endovascular interventions. First and third AXA segments are both amenable to access with excellent results, but larger sheaths (12F) perform better in the wider first AXA segment. In this setting, bailout stenting does not appear to be associated with mid-term stent occlusion.
引用
- Melloni A, Bertoglio L, Van den Eynde W, et al. Outcomes of Percutaneous Access to the First Versus Third Segment of Axillary Artery During Aortic Procedures. J Endovasc Ther. 2023. PMID: 37750487. doi:10.1177/15266028231202456
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。