欧洲与北美学会腹主动脉瘤手术量指南对择期开放腹主动脉瘤修复术后围手术期死亡率的区分能力存在差异
该回顾性国家注册队列分析比较了血管质量倡议(2010-2020)中满足欧洲血管外科学会(ESVS,≥20例腹主动脉瘤修复/年)或血管外科学会(SVS,≥10例开放修复/年)体积阈值的中心,择期开放腹主动脉瘤修复的院内死亡率。结果显示SVS单纯开放修复体积阈值对围手术期死亡率的区分能力优于ESVS复合体积指南,EVAR作为开放修复体积代理的临床有效性存疑。
要点
- SVS单纯开放修复体积阈值对围手术期死亡率的区分能力优于ESVS复合体积指南。
- 满足ESVS与SVS最低病例量阈值的中心比例分别为12%(n=22)与25%(n=48)。
- ≥20例 vs ≥10例开放修复/年中心的绝对死亡率差异为0.3%(2.6% vs 2.9%;p=.51)。
核心结论
- SVS推荐的单纯开放腹主动脉瘤修复中心体积阈值对围手术期死亡率结局具有中等区分能力,优于当前ESVS复合体积指南区分中心绩效的能力。
- 这些发现对使用EVAR作为开放修复体积代理的临床有效性提出了疑问。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性国家注册基于队列的分析,比较血管质量倡议(2010-2020)中满足ESVS(≥20例腹主动脉瘤修复/年)或SVS(≥10例开放修复/年)体积阈值的中心。
- 共在193个美国中心完成8761例开放腹主动脉瘤修复,开放修复体积中位数(IQR)为6.6(3.3, 9.9)例/年。
- 主要结局为院内死亡,采用逻辑回归进行风险调整比较。
主要发现
- 应用SVS中心体积定义时,满足ESVS与SVS最低病例量阈值的中心比例分别为12%(n=22)与25%(n=48)。
- ≥20例 vs ≥10例开放修复/年中心的绝对死亡率差异为0.3%(2.6% vs 2.9%;p=.51)。
- 开放修复体积与粗死亡率之间存在递增关联,但较低与较高阈值之间的绝对差异仅为每例操作0.2%(OR 0.98,95%CI 0.97-0.99;p<.001)。
- 两种体积标准之间未检测到风险调整死亡率的差异(≥10 vs ≥20;p=.78)。
- 亚组分析中,ESVS≥20总复合腹主动脉瘤修复体积阈值与死亡率无关(p=.17);但开放修复病例占中心年度总腹主动脉瘤体积比例的增加与死亡率呈负相关(p=.008)。
关键数值与推荐
- ESVS指南推荐最低腹主动脉瘤修复体积为每年20例开放和/或血管内腹主动脉瘤修复。
- SVS推荐每年10例单纯开放腹主动脉瘤修复。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The European Society for Vascular Surgery (ESVS) guidelines endorse a minimum abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair volume of 20 open (OAR) and or endovascular (EVAR) AAA repair procedures per year as a proxy for high quality care. In contrast, the Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) espouses 10 exclusively OARs per year. Given the differences in these volume standards and definitions, debate persists regarding surgeon credentialing and healthcare resource allocation. This analysis aimed to determine which society endorsed volume benchmark better discriminates OAR mortality. METHODS: A retrospective national registry based cohort analysis. Patients undergoing elective OAR were compared between centres meeting either ESVS (≥ 20 AAA procedures/year) or SVS (≥ 10 OARs/year) volume thresholds within the Vascular Quality Initiative (2010 - 2020). The primary outcome was in hospital death. Logistic regression was used for risk adjusted comparisons. RESULTS: A total of 8 761 OARs were performed at 193 US centres, and the median (IQR) volume was 6.6 (3.3, 9.9) OARs/year. When applying the SVS centre volume definition, the proportion of centres meeting ESVS and SVS minimum case thresholds was 12% (n = 22) and 25% (n = 48), respectively. The absolute mortality difference was 0.3% between centres performing ≥ 20 vs. ≥ 10 OARs/year (2.6% vs. 2.9%; p = .51). There was an incremental association between OAR volume and crude mortality rate; however, this absolute difference between lower and higher thresholds was only 0.2%/procedure (OR 0.98, 95% CI 0.97 - 0.99; p < .001). Moreover, no difference in risk adjusted mortality was detected between volume standards (≥ 10 vs. ≥ 20; p = .78). In sub-analysis, the ESVS ≥ 20 total composite AAA repair volume threshold was not associated with mortality (p = .17); however, increasing the proportion of OAR cases making up the total annual AAA centre volume inversely correlated with mortality (p = .008). CONCLUSION: It appears that the SVS endorsed AAA centre volume threshold using exclusively OAR had a modest ability to discriminate peri-operative mortality outcomes and was superior to the current composite ESVS volume guideline in differentiating centre performance. These findings raise questions regarding the clinical validity of using EVAR as a volume proxy for OAR.
引用
- Scali S, Wanhainen A, Neal D, et al. Conflicting European and North American Society Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm (AAA) Volume Guidelines Differentially Discriminate Peri-operative Mortality After Elective Open AAA Repair. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37573937. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2023.08.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。