文献速递外周动脉疾病

使用多准则决策分析比较患者与提供者对截肢水平结局的优先排序

Comparing Patient and Provider Priorities Around Amputation Level Outcomes Using Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2023-05-30

研究纳入26例血管性下肢截肢患者和38名提供者,用多准则决策分析比较双方对截肢水平结局的优先排序。患者比提供者更看重经跖骨截肢(72% vs 63%),双方对行走能力、愈合、假肢使用、肢体长度和康复强度的排序存在差异。提供者对截肢水平的认知与患者价值观一致,但各结局重要性的认知有差异,提示共享决策的作用。

要点

  • 患者比提供者更看重经跖骨截肢(72% vs 63%)。
  • 患者与提供者对行走能力重视分别为47% vs 42%,愈合为18% vs 28%。
  • 提供者对截肢水平的认知与患者价值观一致,但各结局重要性认知有差异。

核心结论

  • 提供者对截肢水平的认知与患者价值观一致,但围绕每个结局重要性的认知存在差异,提示共享决策的作用。
  • 将多准则决策分析框架嵌入未来决策辅助工具可能促进这些讨论。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用多准则决策分析中的层次分析法,因认知负担低且易于实施。
  • 纳入5项标准(结局):行走能力、截肢术后愈合、康复项目强度、肢体长度、假肢/矫形器使用便利性。
  • 从退伍军人健康管理局招募全国血管性下肢截肢患者和提供者,提供者在线、患者电话完成多准则决策分析。
  • 共26例血管性截肢患者和38名提供者参与;50%患者接受经跖骨截肢,50%接受经胫骨截肢。

主要发现

  • 与提供者相比,患者更看重经跖骨截肢(72% vs 63%)。
  • 患者与提供者的优先排序:行走能力(47% vs 42%)、愈合(18% vs 28%)、假肢使用便利性(17% vs 13%)、肢体长度(11% vs 13%)、康复强度(7% vs 6%)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这些发现揭示了患者价值观与提供者对患者价值观认知之间的一些差异,提示共享决策的作用。
  • 作者提出将多准则决策分析框架嵌入未来决策辅助工具可能促进这些讨论。

局限性

  • 样本可能无法推广到其他人群。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Patients with chronic limb threatening ischemia may require a transmetatarsal amputation (TMA) or a transtibial amputation. When making an amputation-level decision, these patients face a tradeoff-a TMA preserves more limb and may provide better mobility but has a lower probability of primary wound healing and may therefore result in additional same or higher level amputation surgeries with an associated negative impact on function. Understanding differences in how patients and providers prioritize these tradeoffs and other outcomes may enhance shared decision-making. OBJECTIVES: Compare patient priorities with provider perceptions of patient priorities using Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA). METHODS: The MCDA Analytic Hierarchy Process was chosen due to its low cognitive burden and ease of implementation. We included 5 criteria (outcomes): ability to walk, healing after amputation surgery, rehabilitation program intensity, limb length, and ease of use of prosthetic/orthotic device. A national sample of dysvascular lower-limb amputees and providers were recruited from the Veterans Health Administration with the MCDA administered online to providers and telephonically to patients. RESULTS: Twenty-six dysvascular amputees and 38 providers participated. Fifty percent of patients had undergone a TMA; 50%, a transtibial amputation. When compared to providers, patients placed higher value on TMA (72% vs. 63%). Patient versus provider priorities were ability to walk (47% vs. 42%), healing (18% vs. 28%), ease of prosthesis use (17% vs. 13%), limb length (11% vs. 13%), and then rehabilitation intensity (7% vs. 6%). LIMITATIONS: Our sample may not generalize to other populations. CONCLUSIONS: Provider perceptions aligned with patient values on amputation level but varied around the importance of each outcome. IMPLICATIONS: These findings illuminate some differences between patients' values and provider perceptions of patient values, suggesting a role for shared decision-making. Embedding this MCDA framework into a future decision aid may facilitate these discussions.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Poehler D, Czerniecki J, Norvell D, et al. Comparing Patient and Provider Priorities Around Amputation Level Outcomes Using Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis. Ann Vasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37263414. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2023.05.026

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。