编辑推荐——腹主动脉直径超声测量中卡尺放置方法可重复性的比较:诊断准确性研究的系统综述与Meta分析
本系统综述与Meta分析评估腹主动脉最大前后径超声测量中哪种卡尺放置方法可重复性最佳,纳入21项研究(12项可定量分析),比较外-外(OTO)、内-内(ITI)与前缘-前缘(LELE)三种方法。结果显示OTO与ITI的观察者间可重复性为LELE的2.5倍小(即更好),但方法间差异无统计学意义,GRADE证据确定性低。
要点
- OTO与ITI的观察者间可重复性比LELE小2.5倍(提示更好),但方法间差异无统计学意义。
- 三种超声卡尺放置方法的观察者间可重复性合并估计:OTO 0.182±0.440,ITI 0.170±0.554,LELE 0.437±0.419。
- GRADE证据确定性低,需额外数据验证这些发现。
核心结论
- OTO与ITI的观察者间可重复性比LELE小2.5倍(提示更好),但方法间差异无统计学意义,且GRADE证据确定性低。
- 需额外数据验证这些发现,同时需强调方法间的固有差异。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与诊断准确性研究的Meta分析,遵循PRISMA-DTA声明,检索MEDLINE、Scopus和Web of Science(PROSPERO ID: 276694)。
- 纳入报告腹主动脉前后径超声评估中OTO、ITI和/或LELE卡尺放置的观察者内和/或观察者间一致性的研究,采用Bland-Altman分析(均值±标准差)。
- 21项研究纳入定性分析,其中12项符合定量分析条件;使用QUADAS-2工具及QUADAS-C扩展评估偏倚风险,GRADE框架评定证据确定性。
- 采用固定效应Meta分析(均值同质性检验后)合并各超声方法的估计值,并用成对单侧t检验比较;另进行敏感性分析(2010年及以后发表的研究)和Meta回归。
主要发现
- 纳入研究在所用超声型号和探头、参与者性别以及观察者职业、经验和培训方面存在异质性。
- 各超声方法的研究共享共同均值(OTO:p=1.0,ITI:p=1.0,LELE:p=1.0)。
- 观察者间可重复性合并估计(结合各研究Bland-Altman分析的均值±标准差):OTO 0.182±0.440;ITI 0.170±0.554;LELE 0.437±0.419。
- 方法间差异无统计学意义(OTO vs ITI:p=.52,OTO vs LELE:p=.069,ITI vs LELE:p=.17)。
- 考虑2010年及以后发表的研究,LELE的合并估计最小,方法间差异无统计学意义。
局限性
- 纳入研究在所用超声型号和探头、参与者性别以及观察者职业、经验和培训方面存在异质性。
- 尽管偏倚风险低,两个Meta分析结局的证据确定性仍为低。
- 需额外数据验证这些发现。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess which ultrasound (US) method of maximum anteroposterior (AP) abdominal aortic diameter measurement can be considered most reproducible. DATA SOURCES: MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science were searched (PROSPERO ID: 276694). Eligible studies reported intra- and or interobserver agreement according to Bland-Altman analysis (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) for abdominal aortic diameter AP US evaluations with an outer to outer (OTO), inner to inner (ITI), and or leading edge to leading edge (LELE) calliper placement. REVIEW METHODS: The Preferred Reporting Items for a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Diagnostic Test Accuracy Studies statement was followed. The QUADAS-2 tool and QUADAS-C extension were used for risk of bias assessment and the GRADE framework to rate the certainty of evidence. Pooled estimates (fixed effects meta-analysis, after a test of homogeneity of means) for each US method were compared with pairwise one sided t tests. Sensitivity analyses (for studies published in 2010 or later) and meta-regression were also performed. RESULTS: 21 studies were included in the qualitative analysis. Twelve were eligible for quantitative analysis. Studies showed heterogeneity in the US model and transducer used, sex of participants, and observer professions, expertise, and training. Included studies shared a common mean for each US method (OTO: p = 1.0, ITI: p = 1.0, and LELE: p = 1.0). A pooled estimate of interobserver reproducibility for each US method was obtained, combining the mean ± SD (Bland-Altman analysis) from each study: OTO: 0.182 ± 0.440; ITI: 0.170 ± 0.554; and LELE: 0.437 ± 0.419. There were no statistically significant differences between the methods (OTO vs. ITI: p = .52, OTO vs. LELE: p = .069, ITI vs. LELE: p = .17). Considering studies published in 2010 and later, the pooled estimate for LELE was the smallest, without statistically significant differences between the methods. Despite the low risk of bias, the certainty of the evidence for both meta-analysed outcomes remained low. CONCLUSION: The interobserver reproducibility for OTO and ITI was 2.5 times smaller (indicating better reproducibility) than LELE; however, without statistically significant differences between the methods and low GRADE evidence certainty. Additional data are needed to validate these findings, while inherent differences between the methods need to be emphasised.
引用
- Bissacco D, Mandigers TJ, Savaré L, et al. Editor's Choice - Comparison of the Reproducibility of Ultrasound Calliper Placement Methods in Abdominal Aortic Diameter Measurements: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Diagnostic Test Accuracy Studies. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 37331424. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2023.06.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。