关于接受颈动脉内膜切除术的患者报告结局测量:一项德尔菲共识研究
针对动脉粥样硬化性颈动脉狭窄(症状性或无症状性)接受颈动脉内膜切除术(CEA)缺乏疾病特异性患者报告结局测量(PROM)的问题,本研究通过三轮改良德尔菲共识研究,由国际血管外科医生和神经内科医生及患者组成的混合专家小组,在四个预设领域达成共识。专家在49个条目中同意23个条目,仅「行走困难」和「进行日常活动的能力」与既往使用的PROM一致,共识强调诊断、治疗和随访的影响以及对未来和严重卒中的恐惧或担忧。该共识定义的疾病特异性PROM需要在未来特定人群中进行独立验证。
要点
- 三轮改良德尔菲共识研究在49个条目中达成23个条目共识。
- 共识条目分布:通用领域5条、生活质量领域6条、症状领域6条、治疗领域6条。
- 与既往PROM一致的条目仅「行走困难」和「进行日常活动的能力」。
核心结论
- 该共识定义了一个新的疾病特异性PROM,需要在未来特定人群中进行独立验证。
研究设计与样本
- 采用三轮改良德尔菲共识研究,由医生(国际血管外科医生和神经内科医生小组)和患者(符合颈动脉血运重建标准的症状性或无症状性患者)组成混合专家小组。
- 预设四个领域:通用、生活质量、症状相关和治疗相关,预设共识标准为总体专家同意率>70%,在第二轮和第三轮达成共识。
主要发现
- 专家在49个条目中同意23个条目:通用领域5条、生活质量领域6条、症状领域6条、治疗领域6条。
- 与本研究中达成共识的条目相比,既往用于颈动脉疾病研究的通用和疾病特异性PROM中唯一一致的条目是症状领域的「行走困难」和「进行日常活动的能力」。
- 在其他领域达成专家共识的条目中,强调诊断、治疗和随访的影响,以及对「未来」和「严重卒中」的恐惧或担忧。
- 在治疗领域,还强调副作用、长期患者满意度以及提供的有关治疗选择的信息。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识标准为总体专家同意率>70%,在第二轮和第三轮达成。
- 49个条目中23个达成共识:通用领域5条、生活质量领域6条、症状领域6条、治疗领域6条。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出,随着硬临床结局越来越罕见,评估CEA的影响变得越来越困难。
- 原文指出,该共识定义的疾病特异性PROM需要在未来特定人群中进行独立验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Currently, evidence is lacking for disease specific patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) for use in atherosclerotic carotid artery stenosis (either symptomatic or asymptomatic) submitted to carotid endarterectomy (CEA). This study aimed to obtain expert consensus on the most important items to include in a PROM designed to capture the impact of atherosclerotic carotid artery stenosis and its treatment on health related quality of life. METHODS: A three round modified Delphi consensus study was performed. A mixed expert Delphi panel of doctors (international panel of dedicated vascular surgeons and neurologists) and patients (either symptomatic or asymptomatic patients meeting criteria for carotid artery revascularisation) was implemented. The aim was to obtain pre-defined consensus on items in four pre-defined domains: generic, quality of life, symptom related, and treatment related. Consensus was reached in rounds two and three with > 70% overall expert agreement. RESULTS: The experts agreed on 23 items (out of 49) which were distributed as follows: five in the generic, six in the quality of life, six in the symptom, and six in the treatment related domain. Interestingly, comparing the items that reached consensus in this study, with the generic and disease specific PROMs previously used in carotid artery disease investigation, the only constant items were "difficulty with walking" and "ability to perform daily activities" included in the symptom domain. Considering the items that reached expert consensus in the additional domains, emphasis was given to the impact of the diagnosis, treatment and follow up, and to fear or concern "about the future" and "about severe stroke". In the treatment domain emphasis was also attained on the side effects, long term patient satisfaction, and on the information provided regarding treatment options. DISCUSSION: As hard clinical outcomes become increasingly rare, assessment of the impact of CEA becomes increasingly difficult. The consensus reached provides a newly defined disease specific PROM that warrants independent validation in specific populations in the future.
引用
- Coelho A, Peixoto J, Canedo A, et al. A Delphi Consensus Study on Undergoing Carotid Endarterectomy: Patient Reported Outcome Measures. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2023. PMID: 36731764. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2023.01.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。