保留顺行髂内动脉血流对主髂动脉瘤修复术后跛行发生的影响
本研究基于OVER试验(开放手术对比血管内修复)前瞻性收集的881例主髂动脉瘤修复患者数据,采用贝叶斯生存模型分析顺行髂内动脉灌注与臀肌跛行发生时间的关系。调整吸烟、慢性阻塞性肺疾病等因素后,髂内动脉灌注的干预相关改变对臀肌跛行发生时间无影响;全部患者中略低于5%(n=41)发生臀肌跛行。
要点
- 881例中788例维持双侧顺行髂内动脉灌注,63例右侧、27例左侧髂内动脉覆盖/闭塞,3例双侧覆盖/闭塞。
- 全部患者中略低于5%(n=41)发生臀肌跛行。
- 调整混杂因素后,髂内动脉灌注的干预相关改变对臀肌跛行发生时间无影响。
核心结论
- 作者未能找到证据支持保留顺行髂内动脉血流可降低臀肌跛行症状发生率的论断。
- 臀肌跛行在总体及亚组中的发生率均低,值得注意。
研究设计与样本
- 基于退伍军人事务部开放手术对比血管内修复(OVER)协作研究的前瞻性收集数据,分析881例有髂内动脉血流状态信息的主髂动脉瘤修复患者。
- 试验参与者在术前和术后均被专门提示报告多个解剖层面的跛行症状,研究者接受过专门训练以闭塞髂内动脉主干并保留前后分支。
- 采用贝叶斯生存模型评估左、右或双侧臀肌跛行发生时间与顺行髂内动脉灌注存在/缺失的关系。
主要发现
- 788例维持双侧顺行髂内动脉灌注,63例右侧髂内动脉覆盖/闭塞,27例左侧覆盖/闭塞,3例双侧覆盖/闭塞。
- 全部患者中略低于5%(n=41)发生臀肌跛行。
- 调整吸烟、慢性阻塞性肺疾病、药物、研究分组、术前活动水平、体重指数、年龄和糖尿病后,髂内动脉灌注的干预相关改变对臀肌跛行发生时间无影响。
- 最大后验Kullback-Leibler失拟χ2为14.45,自由度24,拟合优度P=.94,提示拟合良好。
局限性
- 作者指出,尽管OVER是规模最大的前瞻性收集跛行发生及髂内动脉保留状态数据的动脉瘤治疗研究,仍未找到支持保留顺行髂内动脉血流降低臀肌跛行发生率的证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to compare the rate of development of buttock claudication in patients undergoing aortoiliac aneurysm repair with and without exclusion of antegrade hypogastric arterial flow. In the absence of convincing data, questions remain regarding the best management of hypogastric arterial flow to prevent the theoretical risk of buttock claudication. METHODS: The Veterans' Affairs Open Versus Endovascular Repair (OVER) Cooperative Study prospectively collected information on buttock claudication. Trial participants were specifically prompted both pre- and postoperatively to report the development of claudication symptoms at several anatomic levels. Of note, trial investigators were specifically trained to occlude the trunk hypogastric arterial, preserving the anterior and posterior divisions. Bayesian survival models were created to evaluate time to development of left, right, or bilateral buttock claudication according to the presence/absence of antegrade hypogastric perfusion. RESULTS: A total of 881 patients from the OVER trial with information regarding status of hypogastric flow were included in the analysis. Of these, 788 patients maintained bilateral antegrade hypogastric arterial perfusion, 63 had right hypogastric coverage/occlusion, and 27 had left hypogastric coverage/occlusion, whereas 3 patients had bilateral hypogastric coverage/occlusion. Just under 5% of all patients (n = 41) developed buttock claudication. After adjustment for smoking, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, medications, study arm, preoperative activity level, body mass index, age, and diabetes, intervention-related changes to hypogastric perfusion had no effect on time to development of buttock claudication. A Maximum A Posteriori Kullback- Leibler misfit χ2 was 14.45 with 24 degrees of freedom, resulting in a goodness of fit P-value of P = .94, indicative of a good fit. CONCLUSIONS: OVER is the largest aneurysm treatment study to prospectively collect data related to the development of claudication as well as hypogastric preservation status. Despite this, we were unable to find evidence to support the assertion that preservation of antegrade hypogastric flow decreases the rate of development of buttock claudication symptoms. The low rate of development of buttock claudication overall and in the subgroups is striking.
引用
- Bennett KM, Hurley L, Kyriakides TC, et al. Effect of preservation of antegrade hypogastric flow on development of claudication following aortoiliac aneurysm repair. J Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 36565778. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2022.12.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。