编者选择——感染性自体主动脉瘤:关于术语、定义、分类、诊断和报告标准的德尔菲共识文件
该德尔菲共识研究邀请37名国际专家参与四轮在线问卷,最终38名专家全部完成四轮,就感染性自体主动脉瘤(INAA)的术语、定义、分类、诊断标准、算法和报告标准达成共识,25条声明和9个报告条目均达到预设共识标准。
要点
- 感染性自体主动脉瘤(INAA)被共识确定为最佳术语。
- 全部25条声明和9个报告条目均达成共识,共识定义为≥75%专家选择「强烈同意」或「同意」。
- Cronbach's alpha系数逐轮升高(第1轮=.84,第2轮=.87,第3轮=.90,第4轮=.92)。
核心结论
- 该德尔菲研究建立了首个关于INAA术语、定义、分类、诊断标准、算法及报告标准的共识文件。
- 该共识为针对该疾病的科学研究创造了基本条件。
- 所呈现的共识将需要根据新获得的知识进行未来修订。
研究设计与样本
- 采用德尔菲方法,通过邮件邀请37名国际专家参与。
- 进行了四轮为期两周的德尔菲轮次,使用在线问卷,初始包含22条声明和9个报告条目。
- 专家组成员在五点李克特量表上对声明进行评分,对声明的评论进行分析、声明修订,并在迭代轮次中呈现结果。
- 共识定义为专家组中≥75%选择李克特量表的「强烈同意」或「同意」,最终评估的共识定义为Cronbach's alpha系数>.80。
主要发现
- 全部38名专家组成员完成了所有四轮,参与率为100%,并同意该研究是必要的。
- INAA被同意为最佳术语。
- 基于专家组的結果和评论,新增了三条声明,最终形成25条声明和9个报告条目。
- 全部25条声明达到≥87%的同意率,全部9个报告条目达到100%的同意率。
- Cronbach's alpha系数逐轮增加(第1轮=.84,第2轮=.87,第3轮=.90,第4轮=.92),因此所有声明和报告条目均达成共识。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识定义为专家组中≥75%选择李克特量表的「强烈同意」或「同意」。
- 最终评估的共识定义为Cronbach's alpha系数>.80。
- 全部25条声明达到≥87%的同意率,全部9个报告条目达到100%的同意率。
- Cronbach's alpha系数:第1轮=.84,第2轮=.87,第3轮=.90,第4轮=.92。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: There is no consensus regarding the terminology, definition, classification, diagnostic criteria, and algorithm, or reporting standards for the disease of infective native aortic aneurysm (INAA), previously known as mycotic aneurysm. The aim of this study was to establish this by performing a consensus study. METHODS: The Delphi methodology was used. Thirty-seven international experts were invited via mail to participate. Four two week Delphi rounds were performed, using an online questionnaire, initially with 22 statements and nine reporting items. The panellists rated the statements on a five point Likert scale. Comments on statements were analysed, statements revised, and results presented in iterative rounds. Consensus was defined as ≥ 75% of the panel selecting "strongly agree" or "agree" on the Likert scale, and consensus on the final assessment was defined as Cronbach's alpha coefficient > .80. RESULTS: All 38 panellists completed all four rounds, resulting in 100% participation and agreement that this study was necessary, and the term INAA was agreed to be optimal. Three more statements were added based on the results and comments of the panel, resulting in a final 25 statements and nine reporting items. All 25 statements reached an agreement of ≥ 87%, and all nine reporting items reached an agreement of 100%. The Cronbach's alpha increased for each consecutive round (round 1 = .84, round 2 = .87, round 3 = .90, and round 4 = .92). Thus, consensus was reached for all statements and reporting items. CONCLUSION: This Delphi study established the first consensus document on INAA regarding terminology, definition, classification, diagnostic criteria, and algorithm, as well as reporting standards. The results of this study create essential conditions for scientific research on this disease. The presented consensus will need future amendments in accordance with newly acquired knowledge.
引用
- Sörelius K, Wyss TR, Adam D, et al. Editor's Choice - Infective Native Aortic Aneurysms: A Delphi Consensus Document on Terminology, Definition, Classification, Diagnosis, and Reporting Standards. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 36470311. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2022.11.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。