受训人员对血管外科手术操作效率的影响有限
该研究回顾性分析了2019年1月1日至2021年10月15日期间在本机构进行的853例择期血管外科手术,旨在了解麻醉和外科受训人员的存在以及巡回护士数量对手术时间的影响,次要目标分析一天中不同时间对总手术时间的影响。结果显示,普外科住院医师通常不会增加血管外科手术时间,但在某些手术(如动静脉瘘建立)中可能会增加时间。
要点
- 与参考团队相比,麻醉医师带受训人员可显著缩短关闭至出室间期(平均-2.4分钟,95%CI -4.7至-0.12,P=0.04)。
- 动静脉瘘建立中,有外科住院医师参与时,入室至切皮时间(平均+4.2分钟,95%CI 0.92至7.4,P=0.01)和切皮至关闭时间(平均+13分钟,95%CI 3.2至23,P<0.01)显著延长。
- 动脉造影中,仅外科医生(无住院医师)时入室至切皮时间更长(平均+5.6分钟,95%CI 0.29至11,P=0.04)。
核心结论
- 普外科住院医师通常不会增加血管外科手术时间,但在某些手术中可能增加时间,或许是因为给予了他们更多自主权(如动静脉瘘建立)。
- 未来研究应关注多个中心、特定血管手术和培训水平,以探究住院医师经验(如实习生与高年资住院医师)和病例复杂性是否影响手术时长。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性审查2019年1月1日至2021年10月15日期间在本机构进行的所有择期血管外科手术,共纳入853例血管手术。
- 参考手术为动静脉瘘(AVF)建立;参考团队包括巡回护士少于2名、麻醉团队为麻醉医师加注册麻醉护士(CRNA)、外科团队为外科医生加执业护士。
- 主要因变量为从入室至出室的时间间隔(分钟),分为三个子区间:入室至切皮、切皮至关闭、关闭至出室。
- 采用单因素分析检查每个手术的入室至出室时间间隔分布,采用线性回归确定团队组成和一天中时间对手术时长的影响。
主要发现
- 与参考手术(AVF建立)相比,截肢术和动脉造影术总体手术时间更短(分别-30分钟,P=0.03;-12分钟,P=0.05)。
- 与参考手术相比,其他手术时间更长:动脉内膜切除术(+48分钟,P<0.01)、肋骨切除术(+78分钟,P<0.01)、血管内主动脉修复(+120分钟,P<0.01)、下肢旁路术(+170分钟,P<0.01)和开放主动脉修复(+410分钟,P<0.01);颈动脉支架置入无显著差异。
- 麻醉医师带受训人员时,关闭至出室间期显著缩短(平均-2.4分钟;95%CI -4.7至-0.12;P=0.04)。
- AVF建立中,有外科住院医师参与时,入室至切皮时间(平均+4.2分钟;95%CI 0.92至7.4;P=0.01)和切皮至关闭时间(平均+13分钟;95%CI 3.2至23;P<0.01)显著延长。
- 动脉造影中,仅外科医生(无住院医师)时入室至切皮时间更长(平均+5.6分钟;95%CI 0.29至11;P=0.04);外科团队组成变化或开始时间变化无其他统计学显著发现。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,普外科住院医师通常不会增加血管外科手术时间,但在某些手术中可能增加时间,或许是因为给予了他们更多自主权(如AVF建立)。
- 作者建议未来研究应关注多个中心、特定血管手术和培训水平,以探究住院医师经验和病例复杂性是否影响手术时长。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
- 作者在结论中提出未来研究应关注多个中心、特定血管手术和培训水平。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Surgical residents prepare during their training for independent operating experience. However, there is a fine balance between supervised intraoperative teaching and the need to keep operations short since this is associated with improved patient safety. We aim to understand if the composition of the vascular surgical team-presence of anesthesia and surgical trainees as well as the number of circulating nurses-affects elective operative times at our institution. As a secondary aim, we analyzed how time of day affects overall operative time. METHODS: We performed a retrospective review of all vascular surgery elective operations occurring between January 1, 2019, and October 15, 2021. Our reference operation between procedures was the construction of an arteriovenous fistula (AVF). Reference teams included circulating staff (fewer than two nurses), anesthesia (anesthesiologist with certified registered nurse anesthetist [CRNA]), and surgery (surgeon with nurse practitioner). The primary dependent variable was the time interval in minutes from wheels-in to wheels-out of surgery, which was divided into three subintervals: wheels-in to cut, cut to close, and close to wheels-out. Univariate analysis was performed to examine each surgical procedure's distribution of wheels-in to wheels-out time interval. Linear regression was performed to determine the effect of team composition and time of day on operative durations. RESULTS: We included a total of 853 vascular operations. Regarding overall operative time, different procedures took various amounts of time compared with the reference operation (AVF creation). Amputations and arteriograms were shorter (-30 min, P = 0.03, and -12 min, P = 0.05, respectively). Other procedures were longer: endarterectomy (+48 min, P < 0.01), rib resection (+78 min, P < 0.01), endovascular aorta repair (+120 min, P < 0.01), lower extremity bypass (+170 min, P < 0.01), and open aortic repair (+410 min, P < 0.01). No significant difference was found in carotid artery stent placement. Overall, there was a significant reduction in the close to wheels-out interval for anesthesiologists with a trainee (mean: -2.4 min; 95%; CI: -4.7, -0.12; P = 0.04). AVF took significantly more time with a surgical resident: wheels-in to cut time (mean: +4.2 min; 95%; CI: 0.92, 7.4; P = 0.01) and cut to close time (mean: +13 min; 3.2, 23; P < 0.01). Arteriogram wheels-in to cut time took longer with a surgeon alone (mean: +5.6; 95%; CI: 0.29, 11; P = 0.04). There were no other statistically significant findings with change in composition of the surgical team or changes in start time. CONCLUSIONS: General surgery residents generally do not add time to vascular surgery cases but may do so in certain cases, perhaps when they are given more autonomy (i.e. AVF creation). Future studies should look at multiple centers, specific vascular procedures, and level of training to explore whether experience among residents (i.e., intern versus senior resident) and case complexity play a role in procedural length, as this may indirectly affect attending surgeon burnout and patient outcomes.
引用
- Steiger K, Edwards MA, Spaulding A, et al. Trainee Effect on Procedural Efficiency is Limited in Vascular Surgery Operations. Ann Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 36442706. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2022.10.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。