运动疗法对静脉性腿部溃疡愈合与复发的系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析检索至2022年4月6日,纳入7项随机对照试验,共121例接受运动疗法联合压力治疗与125例单纯压力治疗。12周溃疡愈合的合并相对危险度为1.38(95%CI 1.11-1.71),仅1项研究报告复发情况,运动依从性范围为33%至81%,证据质量极低。
要点
- 12周溃疡愈合的合并RR为1.38(95%CI 1.11-1.71),支持运动联合压力治疗优于单纯压力治疗。
- 仅1项研究报告溃疡复发,无法合并数据,无证据显示运动对复发有益。
- 运动依从性范围为33%至81%,纳入研究入组率低且偏倚风险高,证据质量极低。
核心结论
- 运动对静脉性腿部溃疡复发影响的研究匮乏,无证据显示运动有益。
- 支持运动作为溃疡愈合辅助措施的证据质量极低,试验存在严重方法学缺陷,主要在记录干预组参与者所从事的活动方面。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,遵循PRISMA指南并使用注册方案(CRD42021220925)。
- 检索MEDLINE、Embase、Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials、ClinicalTrials.gov、European Union Clinical Trials及International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number注册库,截至2022年4月6日。
- 纳入比较运动疗法联合压力治疗与单纯压力治疗的研究,共筛选1046篇报告后纳入7项随机对照试验,运动疗法组121例,单纯压力治疗组125例。
- 溃疡愈合比例数据采用固定效应荟萃分析合并。
主要发现
- 全部7项报告均为随机对照试验,均报告了12周溃疡愈合情况,运动组对比压力治疗组的溃疡愈合合并相对危险度为1.38(95%CI 1.11-1.71)。
- 仅1项研究报告了复发情况,因此未进行数据合并。
- 运动与常规护理之间未显示出差异。
- 运动依从性范围为33%至81%。
- 纳入研究入组率低且偏倚风险高,且大多数试验未能显示干预组与对照组在完成活动方面存在任何差异。
临床怎么用
- 英国国家指南推荐静脉性腿部溃疡患者进行规律运动。
- 作者认为,未来的随机对照试验应实施活动监测并标准化报告关键患者、溃疡和反流特征,以便进行有意义的荟萃分析以确定运动作为静脉性腿部溃疡愈合辅助措施的作用。
局限性
- 仅1项研究报告了复发情况,因此未进行数据合并。
- 运动与常规护理之间未显示出差异。
- 纳入研究入组率低且偏倚风险高。
- 大多数试验未能显示干预组与对照组在完成活动方面存在任何差异。
- 支持运动作为溃疡愈合辅助措施的证据质量极低,试验存在严重方法学缺陷,主要在记录干预组参与者所从事的活动方面。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: National guidelines in the United Kingdom have recommended regular exercise for individuals with venous leg ulceration. However, data on the effects of exercise on ulcer healing and recurrence are sparse. In the present study, we aimed to quantify the evidence for exercise regarding venous ulcer healing with respect to the primary outcomes of the proportion of healed ulcers and rate of ulcer recurrence. The secondary outcomes were improvement in ulcer symptoms, ulcer healing time, quality of life, compliance, and adverse events reported. METHODS: The review followed PRISMA (preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses) guidelines using a registered protocol (CRD42021220925). The MEDLINE and Embase databases and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, ClinicalTrials.gov, European Union Clinical Trials, and International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number registries were searched up to April 6, 2022 and included studies comparing exercise therapy and compression vs compression alone. Data for the proportion of healed ulcers were pooled using a fixed effects meta-analysis. RESULTS: After screening 1046 reports, 7 were included, with 121 participants allocated to exercise therapy and 125 to compression alone. All the reports were of randomized controlled trials and had reported ulcer healing at 12 weeks, with a pooled relative risk of ulcer healing of 1.38 for exercise vs compression (95% confidence interval, 1.11-1.71). Only one study had reported on recurrence; thus, data pooling was not performed. No differences between exercise and usual care were demonstrated. Compliance with exercise ranged from 33% to 81%. The included studies demonstrated low enrollment and a high risk of bias. Also, most of the trials had failed to demonstrate any differences in activity completed between the intervention and control arms. CONCLUSIONS: A paucity of studies has examined leg ulcer recurrence after exercise programs, with no evidence to show that exercise is beneficial. Furthermore, the quality of evidence supporting exercise as an adjunct to ulcer healing is very low, and the trials demonstrated serious methodologic flaws, chiefly in recording the activity undertaken by the participants in the intervention arm. Future randomized controlled trials should implement activity monitoring and standardize the reporting of key patient, ulcer, and reflux characteristics to enable future meaningful meta-analyses to determine the role of exercise as an adjunct to venous leg ulceration healing.
引用
- Turner BRH, Jasionowska S, Machin M, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of exercise therapy for venous leg ulcer healing and recurrence. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2022. PMID: 36202303. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2022.09.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。