文献速递主动脉疾病

三种工作站用于腹主动脉瘤尺寸测量:对决策制定与移植物选择的影响比较

Comparison of Three Workstations For Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Sizing: Impact in Decision Making and Graft Selection.
PubMed 文献 · J Endovasc Ther · 2022-09-20

研究随机选取20套CT血管造影数据,由2名经验丰富的操作者用3种软件工作站(WS1、WS2、WS3)各重复测量2次,共8项参数(5个直径和3个长度),评估观察者内和观察者间一致性及其对移植物选择的影响。结果显示总体一致性高,但个别参数差异可能导致移植物尺寸选择不同,作者建议经验丰富的使用者使用单一软件并由另一人复核。

要点

  • 观察者1重复测量r=0.989、CCC=0.988(0.982-0.992),观察者2 r=0.998、CCC=0.996(0.994-0.997)。
  • 观察者间总体r=0.987、CCC=0.986(0.982-0.989),但个别参数重复性仅中等。
  • 测量差异可能导致移植物尺寸改变:颈直径2例(WS1)、髂直径4例(WS1 2例、WS2 2例)、同侧髂长度7次测量。

核心结论

  • 尽管不同观察者使用不同工作站测量腹主动脉瘤预期一致性高,但微小差异可能导致选择不同的移植物尺寸。
  • 作者建议经验丰富的使用者使用单一软件,并由另一人复核。

研究设计与样本

  • 从100项连续检查中随机选取20套CT血管造影数据集。
  • 由2名经验丰富的操作者使用3种软件工作站(WS1、WS2、WS3)各重复测量2次,每位观察者完成60项完整测量。
  • 测量包括8项参数(5个直径和3个长度),采用Bland-Altman分析、相关系数(r)和一致性相关系数(CCC [95%CI])评估观察者内和观察者间变异性。

主要发现

  • 观察者1重复测量r=0.989、CCC=0.988(0.982-0.992),观察者2 r=0.998、CCC=0.996(0.994-0.997)。
  • 观察者2各参数重复性优秀,观察者1仅中等。
  • 观察者间总体r=0.987、CCC=0.986(0.982-0.989)。
  • 观察者间差异最大见于中心腔线(CLL)测量主动脉颈直径(WS2)和分叉直径(WS1和WS2),以及所有3种工作站CLL和MPR测量的髂直径。
  • Bland-Altman图显示部分不一致影响移植物选择:颈直径改变2例(WS1测量),髂直径改变4例(WS1 2例、WS2 2例),同侧髂长度不一致影响7次测量(WS1 2例、WS2 3例、WS3 2例)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议经验丰富的使用者使用单一软件,并由另一人复核。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to assess the agreement of multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) and semiautomated central lumen line (CLL) analysis of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA), with 3 different software workstations (WS1, WS2, WS3) and 2 experienced practitioners as well as to analyze its eventual impact in graft selection. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty computed tomography (CT) angiography data sets were randomly chosen from a series of 100 consecutive studies. Measurements were performed twice by each reader, in random order, and included 8 parameters (5 diameters and 3 lengths). Each observer performed a complete set of 60 studies. Intra-observer and interobserver variability for every WS was assessed. Measurements were evaluated using Bland-Altman analysis, correlation coefficients (r), and concordance correlation coefficients (CCC [95% confidence interval (CI)]). RESULTS: A high overall agreement between repeated measurements for both observers was obtained (r=0.989; CCC=0.988 [0.982-0.992] and r=0.998; CCC=0.996 [0.994-0.997], for observers 1 and 2, respectively). However, reproducibility for individual parameters was excellent for observer 2 and only moderate for observer 1. A high overall agreement was obtained for interobserver concordance (r=0.987; CCC=0.986 [0.982-0.989]). When analyzing for individual parameters, greatest interobserver differences were found at CLL measurement of the diameter of aortic neck (WS2) and bifurcation (WS1 and WS2) as well as iliac diameter in all 3 WS for both CLL and MPR. Similar differences were observed in paired comparison between WS when involving these parameters. Careful inspection of Bland-Altman charts revealed some cases of disagreement between WS and observers that would affect decision making on graft selection, changing the neck diameter to a different size, in 2 cases when measuring with WS1, and iliac diameter in 4 cases (2 of them with WS1 and 2 with WS2). Greatest discordance was observed regarding ipsilateral iliac length affecting 7 measurements that would lead to change the length of the selected limb graft (2 with WS1, 3 with WS2, and 2 with WS3). CONCLUSIONS: Although a high agreement between different observers using different WS for AAA measurements is to be expected, small differences may lead to the selection of a different graft size. The use of a single software by experienced users, and double check by a different one, may be advisable. CLINICAL IMPACT: Influence of inter and intraobserver variability in CT measurements during planning of endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) has been extensively reviewed. However, its impact in graft selection (final choose of diameter and lengths) has been scarcely analyzed. The results of this study suggest that, although a high agreement between different observers using different workstations for AAA measurements is to be expected, small differences may lead to the selection of a different graft size. The use of a single software by experienced users, and double check by a different one, may be advisable.

来源:J Endovasc Ther,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ribé L, Candela E, Gálvez L, et al. Comparison of Three Workstations For Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Sizing: Impact in Decision Making and Graft Selection. J Endovasc Ther. 2022. PMID: 36124870. doi:10.1177/15266028221120767

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。