经脑血管双功超声检测椎动脉血流模式/锁骨下动脉盗血的深度分析及其临床意义
本研究分析5615次脑血管双功超声(CDUS)检查中锁骨下动脉盗血的发生率及临床意义。171次(3.1%)检出盗血,其中117次为逆向血流、54次为双向血流;多数患者无症状,26例(15.2%)因致残症状接受干预,仅10例(5.8%)因后循环致残症状干预且症状几乎均完全缓解。作者认为CDUS中盗血相对少见,多数可保守治疗。
要点
- 5615次CDUS中171次(3.1%)检出锁骨下动脉盗血,其中逆向血流117次(2.1%)、双向血流54次(1%)。
- 63%患者合并>50%颈动脉狭窄,104/171(60.8%)盗血位于左侧。
- 26/171(15.2%)因致残症状接受干预,仅10/171(5.8%)因后循环致残症状干预。
核心结论
- CDUS检查患者中锁骨下动脉盗血发生率相对少见,多数患者无症状并可保守治疗,仅少数因致残症状需干预且症状缓解良好。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析1年期间连续进行的5615次脑血管双功超声(CDUS)检查,评估锁骨下动脉盗血(定义为椎动脉逆向/双向血流)的发生率及临床意义。
主要发现
- 171/5615(3.1%)CDUS检查发现盗血,其中逆向血流117例(2.1%)、双向血流54例(1%),104/171(60.8%)位于左侧。
- CDUS指征:颈动脉内膜切除/颈动脉支架术后监测39例(22.8%)、颈动脉狭窄进展监测76例(44.4%)、TIA/卒中26例(15%)、无症状筛查/颈动脉杂音18例(10.5%)、孤立后循环症状12例(7%)。
- 63%患者合并>50%颈动脉狭窄;无症状患者平均臂部多普勒压差32.2 mm Hg vs 有后循环症状患者37 mm Hg(P = .3254)。
- 逆向血流vs前向血流vs双向血流的平均臂部收缩压分别为105 mm Hg vs 146 mm Hg vs 134 mm Hg(P < .0001)。
- 逆向血流患者除1例外均存在>50%锁骨下动脉狭窄或闭塞(117例中100例为次全/完全闭塞);双向血流54例中52例存在>50%锁骨下动脉狭窄(6例次全/完全闭塞),2例为正常/<50%狭窄(P < .0001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 26/171(15.2%)因致残症状接受干预,其中11/26干预针对致残性臂部跛行,仅10/171(5.8%)因致残性后循环症状干预,除1例外症状完全缓解。
- 平均18个月(范围1-37个月)随访期间无晚期重大卒中,仅2例腔隙性梗死(与盗血无关);7例晚期死亡,均与卒中无关。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为CDUS检出锁骨下动脉盗血相对少见,多数患者无症状并可保守治疗,仅少数因致残症状需干预且症状缓解良好。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The prevalence of subclavian steal (defined as retrograde/bidirectional vertebral artery flow) in the general population and in patients undergoing cerebrovascular duplex ultrasound (CDUS) examinations is variable. This is the largest study to date to analyze the incidence of duplex-suggested subclavian steal in 5615 CDUS examinations over a 1-year period and to examine its clinical implications. PATIENT POPULATION AND METHODS: All consecutive CDUS examinations performed over a 1-year period were analyzed for the presence of subclavian steal. Indications of testing, presence of posterior cerebral circulation/subclavian steal symptoms, and any interventions for subclavian steal were analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 171 of 5615 (3.1%) CDUS examinations were found to have subclavian steal (duplex-suggested). One hundred seventeen (2.1%) had retrograde flow and 54 (1%) had bidirectional flow. Of 171, 104 (60.8%) were left sided. Indications for CDUS were post-carotid endarterectomy/carotid artery stenting surveillance in 39 patients (22.8%), surveillance for progression of carotid stenosis in 76 patients (44.4%), transient ischemic attack/stroke in 26 patients (15%), asymptomatic screening/carotid bruit in 18 patients (10.5%), and isolated posterior cerebral circulation symptoms in 12 patients (7%). A total of 63% patients had associated >50% carotid stenosis. The mean arm Doppler pressure gradient was 32.2 mm Hg for asymptomatic patients vs 37 mm Hg for patients with posterior circulation symptoms (P = .3254). There were significant differences between the mean systolic arm pressure for patients with retrograde vs antegrade vs bidirectional flow (105 mm Hg vs 146 mm Hg vs 134 mm Hg, respectively, P < .0001). All patients with retrograde flow had >50% subclavian stenosis or occlusion (100 of 117 had subtotal/total occlusion) except for one patient. Meanwhile, 52 of 54 patients with bidirectional flow had >50% subclavian stenosis (6 of 54 with subtotal/total occlusion), whereas two patients were normal/<50% stenosis (P < .0001). Overall, 26 of 171 patients (15.2%) had interventions for disabling symptoms. Eleven of 26 of all interventions were for disabling arm claudication, and only 10 of 171 patients (5.8%) were intervened for disabling posterior circulation symptoms with complete resolution of symptoms in all except one. At a late follow-up with a mean of 18 months (range: 1-37 months), there was no late major stroke with only two lacunar infarcts (not subclavian steal related). There were also seven late deaths, none stroke related. CONCLUSIONS: The incidence of subclavian steal in patients who undergo CDUS is relatively rare. Most of these patients are asymptomatic and can be treated conservatively, and only a few may need intervention for disabling symptoms with good symptom resolution.
引用
- AbuRahma AF, Santini A, Beasley M, et al. Critical analysis of vertebral artery flow patterns/subclavian steal detected by cerebrovascular duplex ultrasound examinations and its clinical implications. J Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 35835320. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2022.05.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。