毕业后医学教育认证委员会血管外科亚能力与常见血管外科手术患者结局概念对齐的专家共识
通过改良德尔菲法,由13名血管外科专家将31项ACGME血管外科亚能力与8个VQI临床注册模块进行映射,两轮专家一致性极佳(ICC分别为0.79和0.97),最终各注册模块保留9至15项亚能力,基于系统的实践、基于实践的学习与改进及职业素养被判定与VQI所 capture 的患者结局相关性较低。
要点
- 两轮德尔菲专家一致性ICC分别为0.79和0.97,共识阈值定为75%及以上专家判定为强制。
- 31项ACGME亚能力映射至8个VQI注册模块后,各模块保留9至15项。
- 基于系统的实践中仅放射安全在两项血管腔内注册模块中被判定相关。
核心结论
- 国家专家组对ACGME亚能力与VQI注册所 capture 的患者结局相关性达成高度一致,基于系统的实践、基于实践的学习与改进及职业素养被判定与特定手术后的患者结局相关性较低。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲专家共识法,招募13名在临床与教育方面专长的血管外科医生,其中12名(92%)参与两轮德尔菲。
- 将31项ACGME血管外科亚能力与8个VQI临床注册模块(EVAR、开放AAA、TEVAR、CEA、CAS、腹股沟下、腹股沟上及外周血管介入)纳入迭代德尔菲流程。
主要发现
- 第一轮ICC=0.79(95%CI 0.74-0.84),第二轮ICC=0.97(95%CI 0.960-0.98),专家一致性极佳。
- 使用预设共识阈值,德尔菲流程将映射至患者结局的亚能力从31项降至8个VQI注册模块各9至15项。
- 最终轮后,基于实践的学习与改进及职业素养亚能力被判定与VQI注册所 capture 的患者结局变量相关性较低。
- 基于系统的实践亚能力中仅放射安全在两项血管腔内注册模块中被判定相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 阳性共识定义为75%或以上参与者将条目评为强制。
- 第一轮ICC=0.79(95%CI 0.74-0.84),第二轮ICC=0.97(95%CI 0.960-0.98)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The quality and effectiveness of vascular surgery education should be evaluated based on patient care outcomes. To investigate predictive associations between trainee performance and subsequent patient outcomes, a critical first step is to determine the conceptual alignment of educational competencies with clinical outcomes in practice. We sought to generate expert consensus on the conceptual alignment of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) Vascular Surgery subcompetencies with patient care outcomes across different Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI) registries. METHODS: A national panel of vascular surgeons with expertise in both clinical care and education were recruited to participate in a modified Delphi expert consensus building process to map ACGME Vascular Surgery subcompetencies (educational markers of resident performance) to VQI clinical modules (patient outcomes). A master list of items for rating was created, including the 31 ACGME Vascular Surgery subcompetencies and 8 VQI clinical registries (endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair, open abdominal aortic aneurysm, thoracic endovascular aortic repair, carotid endarterectomy, carotid artery stent, infrainguinal, suprainguinal, and peripheral vascular intervention). These items were entered into an iterative Delphi process. Positive consensus was reached when 75% or more of the participants ranked an item as mandatory. Intraclass correlations (ICCs) were used to evaluate consistency between experts for each Delphi round. RESULTS: A total of 13 experts who contributed to the development of the Vascular Surgery Milestones participated; 12 experts (92%) participated in both rounds of the Delphi process. Two rounds of Delphi were conducted, as suggested by excellent expert agreement (round 1, ICC = 0.79 [95% confidence interval, 0.74-0.84]; round 2, ICC = 0.97 [95% confidence interval, 0.960-.98]). Using the predetermined consensus cutoff threshold, the Delphi process reduced the number of subcompetencies mapped to patient care outcomes from 31 to a range of 9 to 15 across the 8 VQI clinical registries. Practice-based learning and improvement, and professionalism subcompetencies were identified as less relevant to patient outcome variables captured by the VQI registries after the final round, and the only the systems-based practice subcompetency that was identified as relevant was radiation safety in two of the endovascular registries. CONCLUSIONS: A national panel of vascular surgeon experts reported a high degree of agreement on the relevance of ACGME subcompetencies to patient care outcomes as captured in the VQI clinical registry. Systems-based practice, practice-based learning and improvement, and professionalism competencies were identified as less relevant to patient outcomes after specific surgical procedures.
引用
- Smith BK, Hamstra SJ, Yamazaki K, et al. Expert consensus on the conceptual alignment of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education competencies with patient outcomes after common vascular surgical procedures. J Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 35798280. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2022.06.091
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。