基于高危解剖特征比较经颈动脉血运重建与经股动脉颈动脉支架置入术
基于血管质量倡议(VQI)数据库,比较经颈动脉血运重建(TCAR)与经股动脉颈动脉支架置入术(TFCAS)在有症状和无症状患者中按斑块钙化程度和主动脉弓分型分层的院内结局。严重钙化(>50%)的有症状患者中,TCAR 较 TFCAS 的死亡、卒中/死亡、卒中/死亡/心梗及术后并发症率更低;TFCAS 在复杂主动脉弓解剖下卒中/死亡风险增加,而 TCAR 不受弓型影响。作者认为,对于解剖上被视为 TFCAS 高危的患者,应优先考虑 TCAR。
要点
- 有症状且钙化>50%患者,TCAR 较 TFCAS 死亡 0.9% vs 2.8%,卒中/死亡 2.7% vs 5.8%。
- 有症状且钙化>50%患者,TCAR 较 TFCAS 卒中/死亡/心梗 3.3% vs 6.5%,术后并发症 6.0% vs 12.4%。
- TCAR 后卒中/死亡在 I 型弓 2.6% vs II 型弓 2.8%,TFCAS 后 I 型弓 4.2% vs II 型弓 5.2%。
核心结论
- 钙化加重与 TFCAS 后不良事件增加相关,而 TCAR 后未见此趋势;严重钙化患者中 TCAR 的死亡和卒中/死亡更低;TCAR 在各钙化程度下死亡风险均低于 TFCAS;复杂主动脉弓解剖与 TFCAS 后卒中/死亡风险增加相关,而 TCAR 后卒中/死亡在各弓型间相似;作者认为,对于解剖上被视为 TFCAS 高危的患者,应优先考虑 TCAR。
研究设计与样本
- 基于血管外科学会血管质量倡议(VQI)数据库的分析,纳入 2017 年 1 月至 2020 年 4 月接受 TCAR 或 2005 年 5 月至 2020 年 4 月接受 TFCAS 且颈动脉钙化或主动脉弓分型分级数据非缺失的患者。
- 钙化分析共纳入 9,868 例患者(TCAR:4,224 例;TFCAS:5,644 例)。
- 钙化程度分为 3 组:无钙化、≤50% 钙化和 >50% 钙化;主动脉弓分型分为 I 型、II 型和 III 型。
主要发现
- 有症状患者中,TCAR 与 TFCAS 之间卒中、卒中/短暂性脑缺血发作(TIA)和心肌梗死(MI)发生率按钙化严重程度无差异;但仅 TFCAS 后三种事件风险随钙化增高呈增加趋势。
- 有症状且严重(>50%)钙化患者,TCAR 较 TFCAS 死亡 0.9% vs 2.8%(P=0.013),卒中/死亡 2.7% vs 5.8%(P=0.006),卒中/死亡/MI 3.3% vs 6.5%(P=0.007),术后并发症 6.0% vs 12.4%(P<0.001)。
- TCAR 在所有钙化程度下死亡风险均低于 TFCAS。
- 无症状且 >50% 钙化患者中,TCAR 较 TFCAS 死亡 0.4% vs 1.1%(P=0.080),卒中/死亡 1.5% vs 3.1%(P=0.029)。
- 按弓型比较,TCAR 后卒中/死亡在 I 型弓 2.6% vs II 型弓 2.8%,不随弓复杂度变化;TFCAS 后 I 型弓 4.2% vs II 型弓 5.2%,在复杂高危解剖下增加。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对于解剖上被视为 TFCAS 高危的患者,应优先考虑 TCAR 进行血运重建。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Anatomic details affecting the adverse outcomes following carotid artery stenting have not been well characterized. We compared in-hospital outcomes following transcarotid artery revascularization (TCAR) and transfemoral carotid artery stenting (TFCAS) among symptomatic and asymptomatic patients stratified by degree of lesion calcification and aortic arch type. METHODS: Data from patients in the Society for Vascular Surgery's Vascular Quality Initiative database undergoing TCAR (January 2017 to April 2020) or TFCAS (May 2005 to April 2020) and had non-missing grading on carotid artery calcification or aortic arch type was analyzed. Degree of calcification was stratified into 3 groups: none, ≤ 50% calcification, and >50% calcification. Arch type was stratified as Type I, Type II, and Type III. RESULTS: A total of 9,868 patients (TCAR: 4,224; TFCAS: 5,644) were included in the calcification analysis. TCAR patients were generally older, white, smokers, and had more comorbidities than TFCAS patients. Among the symptomatic patients, there was no difference in rates of stroke, stroke/transient ischemic attack (TIA), and myocardial infarction (MI) by calcification severity between TCAR and TFCAS. However, there was a trend towards increased risk in all 3 events with higher calcification only after TFCAS. Symptomatic patients with severe (>50%) calcification had lower rates of death (TCAR: 0.9% vs. TFCAS: 2.8%, P = 0.013), stroke/death (TCAR: 2.7% vs. TFCAS: 5.8%, P = 0.006), stroke/death/MI (TCAR: 3.3% vs. TFCAS: 6.5%, P = 0.007), and postop complications (TCAR: 6.0% vs. TFCAS: 12.4%, P < 0.001) after TCAR compared to TFCAS. Furthermore, TCAR had lower risk of mortality at all degrees of calcification compared to TFCAS. Similar findings were noted among asymptomatic TCAR patients with >50% calcification, in which the rates of death (TCAR: 0.4% vs. TFCAS: 1.1%, P = 0.080) and stroke/death (TCAR: 1.5% vs. TFCAS: 3.1%, P = 0.029) were reduced. A comparison of TCAR to TFCAS by arch type showed that rates of stroke/death after TCAR were similar regardless of arch complexity (Type I: 2.6% vs. Type II: 2.8%), but increased after TFCAS with complex, high risk anatomy (Type I: 4.2% vs. Type II: 5.2%). CONCLUSIONS: While increased calcification increased rates of adverse events after TFCAS, this trend was not observed after TCAR, which also had lower rates of death and stroke/death among patients with severe calcification. Furthermore, TCAR had lower risk of mortality than TFCAS across all degrees of calcification. TFCAS was associated with increased risk of stroke/death with complex aortic arch anatomy, however, rates of stroke/death after TCAR were similar regardless of arch complexity. Our results suggests that TCAR should be preferentially considered in revascularization of patients with anatomy considered high-risk for TFCAS.
引用
- Zhu J, Rao A, Ting W, et al. Comparison of Transcarotid Artery Revascularization and Transfemoral Carotid Artery Stenting Based on High Risk Anatomic Characteristics. Ann Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 35398198. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2022.03.034
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。