文献速递外周动脉疾病

外周动脉疾病患者在线资源的质量分析

Quality Analysis of Online Resources for Patients with Peripheral Artery Disease.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2022-01-05

本研究通过三个搜索引擎和两个元搜索引擎检索「PAD」「Peripheral Artery Disease」和「PVD」,对纳入的63个网站从问责性、交互性、结构和内容四方面评估质量并分析可读性。结果显示网站总体质量差、可读性低,仅1.6%的网站低于推荐的6年级阅读水平,作者建议血管外科界重新审视并改进患者教育网站。

要点

  • 63个网站中位总质量分为47分中的19分(IQR 15-30),不同机构类型间总分差异显著(P=0.007)。
  • 开放获取网站(中位30分,IQR 17-34)和政府机构网站(中位30分,IQR 29-31)得分最高,医院/医疗机构网站得分最低(中位16分,IQR 14-21)。
  • 总体可读性低,Flesch-Kincaid年级水平评分中位数为10.7(IQR 10-12),仅1个网站(1.6%)低于推荐的6年级阅读水平。

核心结论

  • 免费在线外周动脉疾病患者教育材料质量差、参差不齐,且写作水平大多高于美国普通成人水平,使患者难以理解现有信息。
  • 作者建议血管外科界重新审视现有资源,为患者提供更易读的网站以促进患者教育和共享决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 在三个搜索引擎和两个元搜索引擎上检索「PAD」「Peripheral Artery Disease」和「PVD」,每个搜索引擎前30个网站经筛选后纳入63个网站。
  • 从问责性、交互性、结构和内容四个类别评估网站总体质量,并用四种指数评估文本可读性,使用Rstudio进行方差分析。

主要发现

  • 63个网站中25个为开放获取(34.9%),30个来自医院/医疗机构(48%),5个来自政府机构(8%),4个为行业赞助(6%),2个来自专业医学会(3%)。
  • 中位总质量分为47分中的19分(IQR 15-30);其中问责性为17分中的5分(IQR 2-10),交互性为5分中的2分(IQR 2.0-2.0),网站结构为4分中的3分(IQR 2.5-3.0),网站内容为21分中的11分(IQR 7-14)。
  • 总评分随机构类型不同而差异显著(P=0.007);开放获取网站中位30分(IQR 17-34)和政府机构网站中位30分(IQR 29-31)得分最高,医院/医疗机构网站中位16分(IQR 14-21)得分最低。
  • 总体可读性低,Flesch-Kincaid年级水平评分中位数为10.7(IQR 10-12);按此指数,仅1个网站(1.6%)低于推荐的6年级阅读水平。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The burden of peripheral artery disease is significant for public health but the readily available on-line information on the disease is poorly studied. This study seeks to evaluate the quality and readability of patient resources and identify gaps that appear in the top search results for peripheral artery disease. METHODS: Internet searches were performed for "PAD" and "Peripheral Artery Disease" and "PVD" on three search engines and two metasearch engines. The top 30 websites from each search engine were compiled, screened, and evaluated across four categories of information to assess overall quality: accountability, interactivity, structure, and content. Four indices were used to evaluate readability of the text for the viewer. Statistical analyses was performed using Rstudio with ANOVA. RESULTS: Sixty-three websites met inclusion criteria, of which 25 were open access (34.9%), 30 were from hospital/healthcare organization (48%), 5 were from a governmental agency (8%), 4 were industry sponsored (6%), and 2 were from professional medical societies (3%). Median total quality score was 19 out of 47 (IQR, 15 -30): of the components of this score, accountability was 5 out of 17 (2 -10), interactivity was 2 out of 5 (2.0 -2.0), site structure was 3 out of 4 (2.5 -3.0), and site content was 11 out of 21 (7 -14). Total score varied significantly by organization type (P = 0.007). Open access (30, 17 -34, median, IQR) and governmental agency (30, 29 -31) websites scored the highest while hospital/healthcare organization (16, 14v21) websites scored the lowest. Overall readability was low with a median Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level Score of 10.7 (IQR, 10 -12). Using this index, only one website (1.6%) was written below the recommended 6th grade reading level. CONCLUSION: Freely available online patient education materials for peripheral artery disease are poor, have varying quality, and are largely written at a level higher than that of an average US adult thus depriving the patient from understanding the existing information. We recommend that the vascular surgery community re-examine the current offering and provide improved readable websites to patients to facilitate patient education and shared decision making.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Treffalls JA, Treffalls RN, Zachary H, et al. Quality Analysis of Online Resources for Patients with Peripheral Artery Disease. Ann Vasc Surg. 2022. PMID: 34995744. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.12.079

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。