血管腔内主动脉修复术中的步骤、错误与事件框架
本研究基于改良德尔菲共识流程,邀请国际血管外科与介入放射学专家,为肾下腹主动脉-髂动脉瘤的择期血管腔内主动脉修复术(EVAR)制定步骤、错误与事件评估框架。98名受邀者中38人组成专家组,经三轮调查达成共识(Cronbach α=0.82-0.93),最终错误、步骤和事件框架分别包含15、32和25个条目,条目内同意度为74%-100%。
要点
- 采用改良德尔菲法构建EVAR步骤、错误与事件评估框架。
- 38名专家经三轮达成共识,Cronbach α=0.82-0.93。
- 最终框架含错误15项、步骤32项、事件25项,条目内同意度74%-100%。
核心结论
- 开发了针对肾下EVAR操作步骤、错误和事件的详细评估工具,未来将在录制的手术中进行验证。
研究设计与样本
- 基于改良德尔菲共识流程,邀请国际血管外科与介入放射学专家参与。
- 98名受邀操作者中38人组成专家共识小组(39%),包括29名血管外科医生和9名介入放射学医生,34%来自北美、66%来自欧洲。
- 初始开放式调查要求专家列出标准肾下腹主动脉-髂动脉瘤EVAR的步骤、错误和事件,后续轮次以5点Likert量表评分。
- 德尔菲调查重复直至达到预设共识阈值(Cronbach α>0.7),最终框架条目需获得超过70%专家同意(评分4或5)。
主要发现
- 第三轮德尔菲流程后达到共识标准(Cronbach α=0.82-0.93)。
- 错误框架含15个条目、步骤框架含32个条目、事件框架含25个条目。
- 条目内同意度为74%-100%。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识阈值:Cronbach α>0.7。
- 最终条目纳入标准:超过70%专家评分4或5。
- 错误、步骤、事件框架条目数分别为15、32、25。
- 条目内同意度74%-100%。
临床怎么用
- 该工具未来将在录制的手术中进行验证,可能将技能发展聚焦于常见错误和危险步骤。
- 该工具可能用于为受训者和经验丰富的外科医生提供技术表现的高质量反馈,从而促进外科精通。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Competency-based surgical education requires detailed and actionable feedback to ensure adequate and efficient skill development. Comprehensive operative capture systems such as the Operating Room Black Box (ORBB; Surgical Safety Technologies, Inc), which continuously records and synchronizes multiple sources of intraoperative data, have recently been integrated into hybrid rooms to provide targeted feedback to endovascular teams. The objective of this study is to develop step, error, and event frameworks to evaluate technical performance in elective endovascular aortic repair (EVAR) comprehensively captured by the ORBB (Surgical Safety Technologies, Inc; Toronto, Canada). METHODS: This study is based upon a modified Delphi consensus process to create evaluation frameworks for steps, errors, and events in EVAR. International experts from Vascular Surgery and Interventional Radiology were identified, based on their records of publications and invited presentations, or serving on relevant journal editorial boards. In an initial open-ended survey round, experts were asked to volunteer a comprehensive list of steps, errors, and events for a standard EVAR of an infrarenal aorto-iliac aneurysm (AAA). In subsequent survey rounds, the identified items were presented to the expert panel to rate on a 5-point Likert scale. Delphi survey rounds were repeated until the process reached consensus with a predefined agreement threshold (Cronbach α>0.7). The final frameworks were constructed with items achieving an agreement (responses of 4 or 5) from greater than 70% of experts. RESULTS: Of 98 invited proceduralists, 38 formed the expert consensus panel (39%), consisting of 29 vascular surgeons and 9 interventional radiologists, with 34% from North America and 66% from Europe. Consensus criteria were met following the third round of the Delphi consensus process (Cronbach α=0.82-0.93). There were 15, 32, and 25 items in the error, step, and event frameworks, respectively (within-item agreement=74%-100%). CONCLUSION: A detailed evaluation tool for the procedural steps, errors, and events in infrarenal EVAR was developed. This tool will be validated on recorded procedures in future work: It may focus skill development on common errors and hazardous steps. This tool might be used to provide high-quality feedback on technical performance of trainees and experienced surgeons alike, thus promoting surgical mastery.
引用
- Gordon L, Soenens G, Doyen B, et al. Step, Error, and Event Frameworks in Endovascular Aortic Repair. J Endovasc Ther. 2022. PMID: 35012393. doi:10.1177/15266028211068768
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。