美国预防服务工作组腹主动脉瘤筛查指南对男性从不吸烟者和女性吸烟者修复率的影响微乎其微
该研究基于血管质量倡议国家数据库(2013-2018年),采用双重差分法分析2014年美国预防服务工作组(USPSTF)腹主动脉瘤筛查指南对择期腹主动脉瘤修复数量的影响。结果显示,指南更新后,仅有医保的65-75岁男性从不吸烟者修复数量显著增加,而女性吸烟者无显著变化。
要点
- 2014年USPSTF指南对65-75岁男性从不吸烟者(有心血管危险因素)给予C级推荐,对65-75岁女性吸烟者从负向转为中性(I级)。
- 双重差分分析显示,指南更新后65-75岁男性从不吸烟者与76-85岁相比,修复数量无显著变化(+2.4个百分点,95%CI -0.56至5.26)。
- 在主要保险为Medicare的男性从不吸烟者中,65-75岁组较76-85岁组修复数量显著增加(+3.69个百分点,95%CI 0.16至7.22)。
核心结论
- 2014年USPSTF腹主动脉瘤筛查指南仅与主要保险为Medicare的65-75岁男性从不吸烟者修复数量轻度增加相关。
- 该指南对65-75岁女性吸烟者的修复数量无影响。
- 作者认为,更高级别的推荐和改善的指南依从性可能是改变的前提条件。
研究设计与样本
- 研究查询了血管质量倡议国家数据库(2013-2018年)中的择期腹主动脉瘤腔内修复和开放修复数据。
- 采用双重差分分析(一种调整时间趋势的因果推断技术)比较2014年指南更新前后目标人群与未受影响老年人群的修复数量变化。
- 第一个模型比较65-75岁男性从不吸烟者(干预组)与76-85岁男性从不吸烟者(对照组)的修复数量变化。
- 第二个模型比较65-75岁女性吸烟者(干预组)与76-85岁女性吸烟者(对照组)的修复数量变化。
主要发现
- 男性从不吸烟者共1295例,65-75岁组占42%,76-85岁组占58%,指南更新后4.5年平均修复数量变化无显著差异(+2.4个百分点;95%CI -0.56至5.26)。
- 在主要保险为Medicare的男性从不吸烟者中,65-75岁组较76-85岁组在4.5年内修复数量显著增加(+3.69个百分点;95%CI 0.16至7.22;相当于基线时接受腹主动脉瘤修复的男性从不吸烟者中Medicare参保者比例相对增加10.4%)。
- 女性吸烟者共2312例,65-75岁组占54%,76-85岁组占46%,4.5年内修复数量变化无显著差异(-0.66个百分点;95%CI -4.57至3.26)。
关键数值与推荐
- 2014年USPSTF推荐对65-75岁有心血管危险因素的男性从不吸烟者进行腹主动脉瘤筛查(C级推荐)。
- 2014年USPSTF对65-75岁女性吸烟者的筛查立场从负向转为中性(I级)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: In 2014, in addition to male smokers aged 65-75 years, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommended abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) screening for male never-smokers aged 65-75 years with cardiovascular risk factors (Grade C). The USPSTF evolved from a negative to neutral position on screening for female smokers aged 65-75 years (Grade I). We sought to determine whether 2014 guidelines resulted in more AAA repairs in these populations. METHODS: We queried the Vascular Quality Initiative national database (2013-2018) for elective endovascular aortic repairs and open aortic repairs. We implemented difference-in-differences (DID) analysis, a causal inference technique that adjusts for secular time trends, to isolate changes in repair numbers due to the 2014 USPSTF guidelines. Our DID models compared changes in repair numbers in patient groups targeted by the USPSTF updates (intervention group) to those in unaffected, older patient groups (control), before and after 2014. The first model compared changes in repair numbers between male never-smokers aged 65-75 years (intervention group) and 76-85 years (control). The second model compared repair numbers between female smokers aged 65-75 years (intervention group) and 76-85 years (control). RESULTS: There was no significant change in male never-smokers (n = 1,295) aged 65-75 (42%) vs. 76-85 (58%) undergoing AAA repairs after guideline updates, averaged over 4.5 years (+2.4 percentage points; 95% Confidence Interval [CI] -.56-5.26). However, when their primary insurer was Medicare, male never-smokers aged 65-75 years compared with 76-85 years underwent significantly more repairs over 4.5 years (+3.69 percentage points; 95% CI.16-7.22; representing a 10.4% relative increase from baseline in the proportion of male never-smokers on Medicare undergoing AAA repair). Comparing female smokers (n = 2,312) aged 65-75 (54%) vs. 76-85 (46%), there was no significant change in repairs over 4.5 years (-.66 percentage points; 95% CI -4.57-3.26). CONCLUSIONS: The USPSTF 2014 AAA guidelines were associated with modestly increased repairs in male never-smokers aged 65-75 years only on Medicare. There was no impact among female smokers. Higher-grade recommendations and improved guideline adherence may be requisites for change.
引用
- Levin SR, Farber A, Goodney PP, et al. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Screening Guidelines Negligibly Impacted Repair Rates in Male Never-Smokers and Female Smokers. Ann Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34936889. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.11.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。