三维CAD与3D打印前列腺模型对比mp-MRI用于根治性前列腺切除术前规划
6名泌尿肿瘤医生随机评估三种模态。结果显示3D-CAD和3D打印模型在病灶识别准确性、速度、信心和易解释性上均优于mp-MRI,且3D打印模型在易解释性、速度和阴性切缘获取等方面较3D-CAD有显著提升。
要点
- 3D-CAD和3D打印模型识别病灶准确性分别为mp-MRI的2.4倍和2.8倍。
- 3D打印模型在易解释性、速度和阴性切缘获取上优于3D-CAD。
- 3D模型可作为mp-MRI的辅助工具用于术前规划。
核心结论
- 3D-CAD和3D打印模型是mp-MRI的有用辅助工具,能为泌尿科医生提供更实用、准确和高效的术前规划。
研究设计与样本
- 6名泌尿肿瘤医生随机评估mp-MRI、3D-CAD和3D打印模型三种模态,识别病灶位置并与放射科医生答案对照评分,同时填写问卷评估决策信心、易解释性和术前规划有用性。
主要发现
- 与mp-MRI相比,使用3D-CAD和3D打印模型识别病灶的准确性分别为2.4倍和2.8倍,速度分别为2.7倍和3.2倍,信心分别为1.6倍和1.63倍,易解释性分别为1.6倍和1.7倍。
- 3D-CAD和3D打印模型在整体术前规划、识别病灶位置、确定神经保留程度、获取阴性切缘和患者咨询方面被报告显著更有用。
- 亚组分析显示,3D打印模型在易解释性、速度、获取阴性切缘的有用性和患者咨询方面较3D-CAD有显著改善。
临床怎么用
- 在根治性前列腺切除术前,除放射科解读的mp-MRI外,可考虑使用3D-CAD或3D打印模型辅助术前规划。
- 3D打印模型可能有助于确定神经保留程度、获取阴性切缘和患者咨询。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the use of 3D computed aided designs and 3D-printed models as pre-operative planning tools for urologists, in addition to radiologist interpreted mp-MRIS, prior to radical prostatectomy procedures. METHODS: Ten patients with biopsy-positive lesions detected on mp-MRI were retrospectively selected. Radiologists identified lesion locations using a Prostate Imaging-Reporting and Data System (PI-RADS) map and segmented the prostate, lesion(s), and surrounding anatomy to create 3D-CADs and 3D-printed models for each patient. 6 uro-oncologists randomly reviewed three modalities (mp-MRI, 3D-CAD, and 3D-printed models) for each patient and identified lesion locations which were graded for accuracy against the radiologists' answers. Questionnaires assessed decision confidence, ease-of-interpretation, and usefulness for preoperative planning for each modality. RESULTS: Using 3D-CADs and 3D-printed models compared to mp-MRI, urologists were 2.4x and 2.8x more accurate at identifying the lesion(s), 2.7x and 3.2x faster, 1.6x and 1.63x more confident, and reported it was 1.6x and 1.7x easier to interpret. 3D-CADs and 3D-printed models were reported significantly more useful for overall pre-operative planning, identifying lesion location(s), determining degree of nerve sparing, obtaining negative margins, and patient counseling. Sub-analysis showed 3D-printed models demonstrated significant improvements in ease-of-interpretation, speed, usefulness for obtaining negative margins, and patient counseling compared to 3D-CADs. CONCLUSION: 3D-CADs and 3D-printed models are useful adjuncts to mp-MRI in providing urologists with more practical, accurate, and efficient pre-operative planning.
引用
- Saba P, Melnyk R, Holler T, et al. Comparison of Multi-Parametric MRI of the Prostate to 3D Prostate Computer Aided Designs and 3D-Printed Prostate Models for Pre-Operative Planning of Radical Prostatectomies: A Pilot Study. Urology. 2021. PMID: 34496263. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2021.08.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。