小儿泌尿外科医院排名中样本量与统计功效及误分类风险
该研究评估《美国新闻与世界报道》2019和2020年小儿泌尿外科手术修正率排名方法的统计功效与误分类风险。基于2016-2018年医院手术量数据,发现多数医院手术量不足以达到80%统计功效,误分类风险高。
要点
- 多数医院的小儿泌尿手术年量不足以达到80%统计功效区分修正率差异
- 2020年方法下98.0%医院输尿管再植术量不足以获满分
- 误分类风险在多个场景超过50%,排名方法存在缺陷
核心结论
- 当前排名方法统计功效不足且误分类风险高
研究设计与样本
- 基于2016-2018年儿科健康信息系统数据库计算医院年手术量中位数
- 评估2019和2020年排名方法计算统计功效与误分类风险
主要发现
- 医院年手术量中位数(IQR):远端尿道下裂72(43-97),肾盂成形术19(9-34),输尿管再植术35(19-50)
- 2019年方法达到80%功效区分1% vs 3%修正率需764例/医院,3% vs 5%需1500例/医院,1% vs 5%需282例/医院
- 2020年方法下98.0%医院输尿管再植术量不足,66.0%肾盂成形术量不足,10.9%远端尿道下裂量不足
- 使用2019和2020年方法时,报告远端尿道下裂和肾盂成形术修正率的医院在多个场景误分类风险超过50%
临床怎么用
- 临床应谨慎解读基于低手术量指标的医院排名
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We investigated 2019 and 2020 U.S. News & World Report methodologies of assessing pediatric urology surgical revision rates for distal hypospadias, pyeloplasty, and ureteral reimplantation to evaluate statistical power and misclassification risks. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Median annual volumes of distal hypospadias, pyeloplasty, and ureteral reimplantation procedures by hospital from 2016 to 2018 were calculated using the Pediatric Health Information System® database. U.S. News & World Report 2019 and 2020 methodologies were assessed to calculate power required to detect differences between hospitals and risk of hospital misclassifications. RESULTS: Median (IQR) annual hospital procedure volume was 72 (43-97) for distal hypospadias procedures, 19 (9-34) for pyeloplasties, and 35 (19-50) for ureteral reimplantations. Based on 2019 methodology, in order to achieve 80% power 764 cases/hospital are required to distinguish between a 1% vs 3% surgical revision rate, 1,500 cases/hospital are required to distinguish between a 3% vs 5% revision rate, and 282 cases/hospital are required to distinguish between a 1% vs 5% revision rate. Based on 2020 methodology, 98.0% of hospitals do not have adequate ureteral reimplantation volume to achieve full points even when reporting no revisions; similarly, 66.0% do not have adequate pyeloplasty volume, and 10.9% do not have adequate distal hypospadias volume. Risks of misclassification exceed 50% in several instances among hospitals reporting distal hypospadias and pyeloplasty revisions using both 2019 and 2020 methodology. CONCLUSIONS: Based on median-volume hospitals, current U.S. News & World Report methods for classifying revision rates for distal hypospadias, pyeloplasty, and ureteral reimplantation have insufficient power and are at high risk for misclassification.
引用
- Baker Z, Bhaskar N, Herbst KW, et al. Sample Size, Power, and Risk of Misclassification in Pediatric Urology Hospital Rankings. J Urol. 2021. PMID: 33983039. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000001844
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。