EAU认证手术直播活动5年结果(2015-2020)及EAU直播手术委员会更新指南
该研究回顾了2015年1月至2020年1月间EAU认证的18场手术直播活动(LSE)共246例手术,评估其与2014年指南的依从性及并发症情况。结果显示短期并发症44例(17.8%),长期并发症11.3%(9/79),Clavien III/IV级并发症短期和长期分别为5.2%和7.5%,表明LSE安全且符合指南。委员会据此更新了LSE指南并新增半直播活动指南。
要点
- EAU认证LSE共246例手术,短期并发症17.8%,长期并发症11.3%。
- Clavien III/IV级并发症短期5.2%、长期7.5%,安全性可接受。
- 建议由本地外科医生在熟悉环境中实施LSE以平衡安全与教学。
核心结论
- EAU认证的LSE在5年内安全且符合2014年指南。
- 本地外科医生在所属医院实施LSE可能最佳平衡患者安全与教育价值。
- 委员会已更新LSE指南并新增半直播活动指南。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性注册研究,纳入2015年1月至2020年1月EAU认证的18场LSE共246例手术。
- 所有活动经EAU直播手术委员会预评估并符合EAU LSE标准,结局录入注册系统。
- 收集手术类型及术中、短期和长期并发症数据。
主要发现
- 246例手术中机器人辅助109例(44.3%)、腹腔镜21例(8.5%)、经尿道膀胱手术10例(4%)、前列腺剜除11例(4.4%)、腔内泌尿外科72例(29.2%)、男科或重建23例(9.3%)。
- 5年内共实施77种不同手术技术变体,涉及55种手术类型。
- 短期并发症44例(17.8%),长期并发症11.3%(9/79)。
- Clavien III/IV级并发症短期5.2%、长期7.5%。
关键数值与推荐
- EAU LSE需经直播手术委员会预评估并符合既定标准。
- 更新指南建议LSE由本地外科医生在所属医院对熟悉患者和团队实施。
- 技术进步应使直播过程无缝化。
临床怎么用
- 开展LSE应遵循EAU委员会预评估标准并录入结局注册。
- 优先选择本地外科医生在所属医院实施LSE以保障安全。
- 需监测短期和长期并发症,尤其Clavien III/IV级事件。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT: Live surgery events (LSEs) have been used in all surgical fields for education and training and to demonstrate new techniques. The European Association of Urology (EAU) live surgery guidelines were established in 2014. OBJECTIVE: To review the compliance of outcomes for procedures performed at EAU-affiliated LSEs with the 2014 guidelines and to establish updated guidelines for LSEs and semi-LSEs. EVIDENCE ACQUISITION: Patients from EAU-affiliated LSEs were included for all surgical procedures carried out between January 2015 and January 2020. All these events were pre-evaluated by the EAU Live Surgery Committee and met the criteria for an EAU LSE, with outcomes recorded and submitted to the registry. Data were collected for the type of procedure and for intraoperative and short- and long-term complications. EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: A total of 246 procedures were performed across 18 LSEs, with an annual volume ranging from 19 to 74 procedures. These included 109 (44.3%) robot-assisted procedures, 21 (8.5%) laparoscopic procedures, 10 (4%) transurethral bladder procedures, 11 (4.4%) prostate enucleation procedures, 72 (29.2%) endourological procedures, and 23 (9.3%) andrology or reconstruction procedures. A total of 77 different surgical techniques and variations for 55 different types of surgery were performed as LSEs over the past 5 yr. There were 44 (17.8%) short-term complications and 11.3% (nine/79) long-term complications observed, with Clavien grade III/IV complications seen in 5.2% and 7.5% of cases over short- and long-term follow-up, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The 5-yr outcomes for EAU LSEs show that they are safe and follow previous guidelines set by the panel. It seems likely that the fine balance between patient safety and educational value might be best achieved if LSEs are performed by local surgeons in their parent hospital with patients and staff they know, and that technological advances will make live streaming a seamless process. The current EAU Live Surgery Committee has updated the guidelines on LSEs and provided new guidelines for semi-live events. PATIENT SUMMARY: We reviewed 5-year outcomes for live surgery events endorsed by the European Association of Urology. We found that the operations carried out at these events were safe and followed the guidelines previously set. We have updated the guidelines and provided new guidelines for semi-live events.
引用
- Somani B, Liatsikos E, Mottrie A, et al. Outcomes of EAU-endorsed Live Surgical Events over a 5-year Period (2015-2020) and Updated Guidelines from the EAU Live Surgery Committee. Eur Urol. 2021. PMID: 34020827. doi:10.1016/j.eururo.2021.04.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。