文献速递前列腺癌

YouTube与精选来源机器人前列腺切除术视频质量GEARS评分比较

Comparison of Robotic Surgery Video Quality Between YouTube and Curated Sources Using GEARS Criteria.
PubMed 文献 · Urology · 2021-04-21

结果显示YouTube视频总体GEARS评分与AUA组无显著差异(P=0.78),且高于DVS组(P=0.03),提示高观看量视频质量可能不劣于精选来源。

要点

  • YouTube高观看量机器人前列腺切除术视频GEARS评分与AUA精选视频无显著差异。
  • YouTube视频GEARS评分显著高于DaVinci手术社区视频(P=0.03)。
  • 评审者间总体GEARS评分可靠性高(α=0.843)。

核心结论

  • 尽管对YouTube手术视频教育质量存在担忧,但观看量最高的机器人前列腺切除术视频GEARS评分与精选来源相当或更好。
  • 这可能反映大量视频中通过众包方式筛选出了最佳视频。

研究设计与样本

  • 从DaVinci手术社区和AUA手术视频库按发表时间由近及远各选5个视频代表精选来源。
  • 视频去标识后盲法平行评审,使用GEARS标准评分,评审者间一致性用Chronbach's alpha衡量,组间比较用student t-test。

主要发现

  • 评审者间总体GEARS评分可靠性高(α=0.843)。
  • YouTube视频总体GEARS评分均值24.8(SDEV 1.85),AUA组均值24.3(SDEV 6.18),两组无显著差异(P=0.78)。
  • YouTube视频GEARS评分高于DVS视频(均值22.1,SDEV 2.34)(P=0.03)。

关键数值与推荐

  • GEARS评分评审者间总体可靠性α=0.843。
  • YouTube组GEARS均值24.8(SDEV 1.85),AUA组均值24.3(SDEV 6.18),P=0.78。
  • DVS组GEARS均值22.1(SDEV 2.34),YouTube与DVS比较P=0.03。

临床怎么用

  • 泌尿外科医生可参考YouTube上高观看量的机器人前列腺切除术视频进行学习,其GEARS评分不劣于部分精选来源。
  • 选择教学视频时仍需结合GEARS等客观评分工具评估质量。

局限性

  • 仅纳入机器人前列腺切除术视频,结论不能推广至其他术式。
  • 视频按观看量或发表时间选择,可能存在选择偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To compare the quality of robotic prostatectomy surgical videos on the popular website YouTube with more curated, professional sources using the Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills (GEARS) criteria. METHODS: A search was performed on YouTube for robotic prostatectomy. Results were sorted by views and the first ten that met inclusion criteria were selected for review. To represent curated sources five robotic prostatectomy videos were selected from the DaVinci Surgery Community (DVS) video repository and the AUA Surgical Video Library in order of publishing from present to past. Videos were edited to be deidentified. The videos were reviewed blindly in parallel and graded using the GEARS criteria. Concordance among reviewers was measured using Chronbach's alpha. Comparisons between groups were made using student t-test. RESULTS: There was a high level of reliability of overall GEARS scores between reviewers for each video (α = 0.843). There was no significant difference between overall GEARS scores between the YouTube videos (mean 24.8, SDEV 1.85) and the AUA group (mean 24.3, SDEV 6.18) (P = 0.78). YouTube videos scored higher than the DVS videos (mean 22.1, SDEV 2.34) (P 0.03). CONCLUSION: Despite concerns about the quality of surgical videos on YouTube for education, the most viewed surgical videos for robot assisted laparoscopic prostatectomy score as well or better than more curated sources using the GEARS criteria. This may represent selection via crowd sourcing of the best videos amongst a much larger overall quantity.

来源:Urology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Crisostomo-Wynne T, Hertz A, Banti M, et al. Comparison of Robotic Surgery Video Quality Between YouTube and Curated Sources Using GEARS Criteria. Urology. 2021. PMID: 33891925. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2021.04.005

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。