阴茎假体手术伦理困境:高手术量术者调查
该调查向泌尿假体外科医师协会成员发放问卷,设置6个伦理挑战场景(HIV阳性、认知障碍、性犯罪者、非言语患者、好诉讼患者、即将失效的未控制糖尿病患者),主要结局为提供手术的可能性。回应率15.6%(n=29)。与基线患者相比,除HIV阳性患者外,术者在所有场景中提供手术的可能性均降低,对性犯罪者最低(P<.01);特定临床信息可提高提供手术的比值比。
要点
- 对性犯罪者提供阴茎假体手术的可能性最低(P<.01)。
- 知晓唐氏综合征患者高功能(OR 5.0,CI:1.4-17.8)等特定因素可提高手术意愿。
- HIV阳性患者的手术意愿未低于基线。
核心结论
- 泌尿假体外科医师在伦理挑战中应用自主、不伤害、有利和公正原则,多数困境降低手术意愿,但特定临床因素常增强决策。
研究设计与样本
- 向泌尿假体外科医师协会成员发放问卷,含6个伦理挑战场景,回应率15.6%(n=29),主要结局为提供手术的可能性。
主要发现
- 与基线患者相比,除HIV阳性患者外,所有场景提供手术的可能性均降低,对性犯罪者最低(P<.01)。
- 知晓唐氏综合征患者高功能与提供手术的比值比OR 5.0(CI:1.4-17.8)相关。
- 性犯罪者目前已婚与提供手术的比值比OR 16.5(CI:3.5-99.8)相关。
- 好诉讼患者曾因遗留海绵起诉外科医生与提供手术的比值比OR 6.3(CI:1.7-24.3)相关。
- 非言语患者曾表达对阴茎假体手术有兴趣与提供手术的比值比OR 4.5(CI:1.3-16.2)相关。
临床怎么用
- 术者面对伦理困境时手术意愿普遍降低,但应综合特定临床因素(如患者功能状态、社会支持、既往意愿)个体化决策。
局限性
- 回应率仅15.6%(n=29),样本量小,结果可能不代表全体假体外科医师。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate how surgeons approach ethically challenging scenarios that arise in penile prosthesis surgery and identify patient-related factors that impact their approach. METHODS: A survey was distributed to the Society for Urologic Prosthetic Surgeons membership consisting of 6 ethically challenging scenarios: an HIV+ patient, a patient with cognitive disability, a registered sex offender, a nonverbal patient, a litigious patient, and an uncontrolled diabetic patient whose insurance will lapse soon. Additional clinical information was provided to assess how the likelihood to offer surgery might change. The primary outcome was the likelihood of offering surgery in each scenario. RESULTS: The response rate was 15.6% (n = 29). When compared to the baseline patient, respondents had a lower likelihood of offering surgery in all scenarios except the HIV+ patient, with the lowest likelihood of offering surgery to a sex offender (P < .01). Within each scenario, factors associated with an increased odds of offering surgery included knowledge that a patient with Down Syndrome is high functioning (odds ratio [OR] 5.0, confidence interval [CI]: 1.4-17.8), that a prior sex offender is currently married (OR 16.5, CI:3.5-99.8), that a litigious patient sued a surgeon for a retained sponge (OR 6.3, CI:1.7-24.3), and that a nonverbal patient had expressed prior interest in penile prosthesis surgery (OR 4.5, CI: 1.3-16.2). CONCLUSION: Ethical principles, including respect for autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice, are appropriately applied by urological prosthetic surgeons when ethical challenges arise. While the likelihood of offering penile prosthesis surgery is decreased with most ethical dilemmas, specific clinical factors often augment decision-making.
引用
- Mohan C, Sonntag E, Ehlers M, et al. Challenging Ethical Scenarios in the Surgical Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction: A Survey of High-Volume Penile Prosthesis Surgeons. Urology. 2020. PMID: 33285211. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2020.10.053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。